That notion was nothing more than an insistence on replaying elections of the past rather than looking towards the future.
Sometimes the argument was disingenuous, used more to push an otherwise-favored candidate than out of conviction. We heard a bit of it from supporters of Wesley Clark and Mark Warner, who both eventually declined to run. And we heard it often from some Edwards supporters. Thankfully, THANKFULLY, THANKFULLY the Democratic Party didn't buy the idea. Whether just used as an argument or honestly believed, the idea was wrong.
Illinois. Chicago. There's nothing swing about those locations. They're liberal, period. If I were to 'build' the perfect candidate from scratch, I wouldn't have that candidate be from Chicago. And yet we found our candidate there, a candidate who ran a smashingly successful campaign. A candidate who won a larger percentage of the popular vote than anyone else since LBJ in 1964.
Of course, the entire "We must nominate a Southerner in order to win the Presidency!" argument was always nonsense.
Read More