Sierra Club Response
Thank you for contacting the Sierra Club Political Committee concerning the Club's endorsement of Senator Lincoln Chafee of Rhode Island. Criticism of this endorsement is based on a misapprehension of the nature of the Sierra Club's political program. For the 25 years that this program has been in place we have rewarded good environmental actions and criticized bad environmental actions in an even-handed and non-partisan fashion. The Sierra Club political program will continue to operate in this independent fashion: should it fail to do so it would lose credibility with the American voting public, which relies on the organization for unbiased and accurate political information.
It was alleged on the political blog Daily Kos that Senator Chafee's voting record was 20%. In fact, the most commonly consulted environronmenal voting record is produced by the League of Conservation Voters, which gave him a 90% voting record for the 109th Congress, 2003-2004. The Sierra Club produces its own voting compilation for use internally by the political staff and committee. Of four indicator votes that were on issues of particular interest to the Sierra Club in 2004, and that were used to evaluate every senator's voting record, Senator Chafee voted with the Club 100% of the time. We are currently engaged in highlighting votes that we will use to perform a similar evaluation of the 2005-2006 Congressional cycle. We have tenatively identified seven key environmental and trade votes, and Senator Chafee has voted correctly on all seven.
Moreover, Senator Chafee has been an active leader on environmental issues in ways that go well beyond simply voting positively. As a key member of the Environment and Public Works Committee and chair of the subcommittee on Fisheries, Wildlife and Water, he has consistently demonstrated independence and leadership on issues ranging from clean air, to global warming, to cleaning up toxic waste and protecting special places. Some of the highlights include:
-- He has been a champion for rallying colleagues to vote to protect the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge,
-- He nearly single-handedly assured that the Clean Air Act was not weakened to produce more polluting oil refineries,
-- He is working to assure that the Endangered Species Act is preserved despite attacks from special interests.
The blog implies that the Chafee endorsement was engineered by a small number of Sierra Club top staff. In fact, every Congressional endorsement requires a 2/3 vote by at least two broadly representative committees of volunteers. In this instance the Chafee endorsement was approved unanimously by the Rhode Island Chapter Political Committee, the Rhode Island Chapter Executive Committee, and the national Sierra Club Political Committee.
In 2005 the Sierra Club Board of Directors created a task force to examine and make recommendations on the principles and operations of the Club's political program. One finding of the task force report, which was adopted by the Board, was:
"The strength of our endorsements and our reputation is in our ability to declare in a nonpartisan/bipartisan manner which candidate is the best choice for the environment. Our opponents seek to diminish our power in this arena by labeling us as a special interest, so we need to constantly strive to maintain our reputation."
One of the surest ways of sabotaging our public reputation and consequently diminishing our power would be not to recognize that the Senate needs more environmental champions like Lincoln Chafee.
Sincerely yours,
Jonathan Ela
Chair, Sierra Club Political Committee
Recommended
- CNN has published a deeply troubling report on the torture that Israel is committing on Gazan detainees at the Sde Teiman prison in Israel’s Negev desert. The Israeli whistleblower revealed that detainees, some of whom are innocent surgeons and...299 comments 426 Recs
- Burn, baby, burn. Ukraine hit this same refinery two months ago. Oh look! Lots of new job opportunities in Russia. I wonder if they have a good health plan. It has been anticipated for a while now that Russia would attempt an offensive near Kharkiv....26 comments 149 Recs
- Stormy Daniels is standing strong after spending more than seven hours over two days testifying about what happened one night in a Lake Tahoe hotel room with Donald Trump. And Trump attorney Susan Necheles’ attempt at “slut-shaming” the adult film star...63 comments 140 Recs
- Last winter, Rep. Nancy Mace (R-SC) lost all nine of her congressional staffers. On November 1, 2023, she fired her chief of staff, Dan Hanlon. In the next three months, the other eight quit. The reviews were not good. Mace earned a reputation as an...45 comments 117 Recs
- I thought it was a joke and then I read Yahoo News. Let us not forget Trump had and may still have classified information but ah ha, then I thought, how many copies did he make of the classified docs? I mean the article said his mobile human printer...38 comments 79 Recs
- I know that the GOP believes a lot of ridiculous nonsense. It’s their stock-in-trade. But hearing this nutty theory espoused by the current Speaker of the House is more than a little jarring. In a clear attack on the executive branch, the judicial...195 comments 255 Recs
- UPDATE: Friday, May 10, 2024 · 2:15:25 PM +00:00 · distraught Over 2 months ago, Biden nominated someone to fill 1 of 2 vacancies on the Postal Board. Walsh would be the fourth Democrat to sit on the board, joining three Republicans and one...183 comments 297 Recs
- A Severe G4 Geomagnetic Storm is expected to lash at earth around 03:00 — 09:00 UTC Saturday morning (11 p.m. EDT Friday night to 5 a.m. EDT Saturday morning). A series of strong solar flares and Coronal Mass Ejections took place Wednesday and...67 comments 254 Recs
- ...until someone called. I’m feeling a bit good about myself today. Because I was the person who called. And then called another number and a couple more numbers. And then sent some emails. And then made another call or two. A couple of days ago, I...14 comments 44 Recs
- Early this morning a Russian oil refinery in Kaluga Oblast had a full 30 minutes warning that a Ukrainian drone was headed their way. The drone arrived right on time to hit the facility …. unmolested and with devastating effect. What air defense doing?...50 comments 139 Recs
- Primum non nocere (first, or above all, do no harm) is a Latin expression generally applied to the medical profession. However, I viewed it as equally applicable to the practice of law and often reminded myself of it in my own practice. Trump’s...415 comments 918 Recs
- A lot has changed since I first wrote about E-bikes back in 2020. Today sales of E-bikes are vastly outpacing sales of electric cars. Seems like they’re everywhere now. In 2023 roughly 40 million E-bikes were sold worldwide. I was just at the local...120 comments 223 Recs
Recent Diaries
- Our system of government relies on a set of checks and balances. These checks and balances allow for harmful government actions to be corrected. The Judiciary Branch corrects many Legislative Branch and /or Executive Branch actions. Within the...1 comments 0 Recs
- That’s the short title. I should properly call this, “The End of Donald Trump’s Political Career”, because that’s the question facing us. How do we end Donald Trump’s political career? ...1 comments 0 Recs
- 1 comments 0 Recs
- 🔥 "The children who remember their past lives- What happens when your toddler is haunted by memories that arenât hers?"3 comments 0 Recs
- A series of witnesses testified today as the prosecution is beginning to wind up its case against Trump. Perhaps most damaging was a Trump tweet which proved an opening statement claim made to the jury by his attorney to be a lie. Here are today’s...1 comments 3 Recs
- The Biden administration has concluded it is “reasonable to assess” that Israel’s military campaign in Gaza may have violated international law or “established best practices” for protecting civilians, but has not found specific instances that would...3 comments 4 Recs
- The magnitude of the maladjustment within today's Republican Party has reached unprecedented levels of chaos and hostility. And while they unload plenty of vile on their Democratic foes, they frequently aim at one another, ripping themselves to shreds...7 comments 7 Recs
- x ...2 comments 0 Recs
- “Capital will not ignore a profit, just as Nature was formerly said to abhor a vacuum. With adequate profit, capital is very bold. A certain 10 percent profit will ensure its employment anywhere; 20 percent certain will produce eagerness; 50 percent,...1 comments 8 Recs
- Cartoon by Brian McFadden. Follow me on � Mastodon ,� Bluesky ,� Facebook ,� ...3 comments 12 Recs
- In the clean economy revolution, globally, there are truly many great stories and tremendous advances. Solar power continues its double-digit growth, clean generation is blowing away fossil fuels in new power plants, battery prices continue to fall...7 comments 18 Recs
- Commentary by Black Kos editor JoanMar One hundred years ago, some wise man wrote, “Justice must not only be done, but must also be seen to be done.” Whatever the legal complexities, the notion of someone facing 40 years in federal prison for “lying on...122 comments 36 Recs
- Took me a couple days to mull this one over in my head, what I wanted to say and how I wanted to say it. At first, I was going for short and snappy, and then I thought, “No, maybe I should let Stormy speak for herself.” Also, I could not freaking get...9 comments 27 Recs
- Pete Seeger opened his autobiography with this song because of how important he felt diversity. Andy Antipin is Philadelphia's best known labor singer and this video and its audio counterpart include an all-star lineup including David Amram on tin...1 comments 2 Recs
- A DEADLY THREAT FROM A CHRISTIAN NATIONALIST FANATIC: SHEER LUNACY (AGAIN!) FROM TRUMP: PROJECT 2025— A DAGGER AIMED AT THE HEART OF AMERICAN FREEDOM: THE PARTY OF SMALL GOVERNMENT: WHAT YOU CAN DO TO STOP THIS MAGA NIGHTMARE: Hope Springs from Field...1 comments 15 Recs
- I thought it was a joke and then I read Yahoo News. Let us not forget Trump had and may still have classified information but ah ha, then I thought, how many copies did he make of the classified docs? I mean the article said his mobile human printer...38 comments 79 Recs
- I wanted to offer a follow up to my last diary in which I supported Joe Biden’s decision to withhold 2,000 pound bombs and related unguided destructive offensive weapons from Netanyahu. It’s been a while coming, too. I want to talk about the remarkable...18 comments 7 Recs
- At 70 years old, I was raised though the battles of the 1960’s. That decade was full of protests of the Vietnam War, a war that many people of my generation, including myself, considered an immoral war. Students rallied along with many of the adults in...5 comments 3 Recs
- Greetings and welcome to the real fluff, the hardcore fluff, the fluffy stuff that's built Tonka Tough™. But you've had enough of my guff. Rough, buff, snuff, scruff …11 comments 12 Recs
- ...until someone called. I’m feeling a bit good about myself today. Because I was the person who called. And then called another number and a couple more numbers. And then sent some emails. And then made another call or two. A couple of days ago, I...14 comments 44 Recs