Skip to main content

45 years ago today, the world premiere took place of one of the relatively few famous classical music pieces of the second half of the 20th century:  the War Requiem of Benjamin Britten, where he used texts from the Latin Missa pro defunctis together with poems of Wilfred Owen (1893-1918).  (teacherken diaried on the War Requiem 2 years ago here.)  Britten was a lifelong pacifist, and this work, written for the consecration of the reconstructed Coventry Cathedral, following the original's destruction in World War II, allowed Britten a big forum to express his sentiments.

The plural in this diary's title is because a thematically related Britten work also has an anniversary this month, after a fashion.  This is his opera Owen Wingrave, adapted from the 1893 short story by Henry James by librettist Myfanwy Piper, and originally written on commission from BBC2 for television.  The performance was recorded and taped in November 1970, and the first broadcast was on BBC2 on May 16, 1971.  The work was recently revived at the Royal Opera House, Covent Garden.  More below the flip....

The story is about a young man, Owen Wingrave, who has decided to defy his family tradition and refuse to become a soldier, while under instruction at the London military "cramming establishment" of Spencer Coyle.  This is unacceptable in the extreme to the Wingrave family, who pride themselves on sending generations of soldiers into combat.  Owen has to face the wrath of his family, not to mention the disdain of his intended, Kate Julian, and her mother.  

Furthermore, there's a supernatural element to the story, related to an incident in the Wingrave past where a Wingrave boy refused to fight back when another boy called him a liar.  The father saw this, and took the boy to a bedroom in the Manor, where he struck the boy, fatally.  Soon after, the father himself was found dead in that room, but without a mark on him.  Since then, no one has ever entered that room.

Tim Ashley recently wrote this article in anticipation of the recent London revival, where you see clearly that he greatly admires the work.  In Michael Church's preview article, Britten himself was quoted from 1970 in a letter to a friend:

"I feel it to be one of the best things I have done, and certainly the most serious".

The reviews of the production, and also of the music, are more mixed:

Rupert Christiansen, Telegraph
Andrew Clark, Financial Times
Andrew Clements, The Guardian
Richard Morrison, The Times
Anna Picard, The Independent
Edward Seckerson, The Independent

I had listened to the work years ago in college, but after hearing about this new production, I gave the recording another listen.  I also read James' story for the first time.

Since Britten clearly takes Owen's side and shares the character's feelings about war, one would expect this diary to say that this is truly a neglected masterpiece, all the criticisms are wrong and war-mongering, and every opera company should stage this work now in Dumbya's America without delay.  I exaggerate, but you get the idea.  However, it turns out that the critics do have several points about this work.

The depiction of Owen's family and the Julians is pretty one-sided, where they do express pretty loathsome sentiments. It's kind of like (bad mixing of metaphors here) a 19th-century English equivalent of the worst Freeper stereotypes, transposed into an opera.  One example is when Mrs. Coyle tries to defend Owen at the Wingrave family dinner, by saying that Owen "has his scruples".  The family then wails on Owen:

"Sir Philip (Owen's grandfather): Say what right has he to have scruples?"
Miss Wingrave (Owen's aunt): His not to question but obey.
Kate Julian: Might is right, the soldier's truth.

(following is overlapping of the 4 characters)
Mrs. Julian: Scruples are for milksops.
Sir Philip: Scruples are for women.
Kate: Scruples are for parsons.
Miss Wingrave: Scruples are for weaklings.

All four together: Scruples are for adolescent boys."

Pretty ugly, but the point is that the libretto stacks the deck.  Donald Mitchell, the executor of the Britten-Pears Estate and the de facto keeper of the Britten flame, even unwittingly acknowledges this in his original notes to the 1971 commercial recording, but then also tries to qualify that point:

"In so far as [the Wingraves] live by slogans, and suppress their imaginations, they are less than human....We are conscious of it when the Wingraves forgo their humanity and take their stand on mindless tradition, when they also freeze into identical attitudes....At the same time, satire does not decline into caricature, and there is room, as there must be, for substantial flashes of humanity...."

With respect, I'm, the Wingraves pretty much are caricatures.  One has to look really closely for small moments that makes those characters a little more subtle.  For example, the General, who at one point calls his own grandson "traitor", sings after that "scruples" section:

"What good are scruples when the enemy charges? When the garrison's dying, women, children, gasping for food and water?"

Granted, this line implicitly has war as a perpetual fact of life in Sir Philip's world, but within that constraint, that passage has some subtlety.

In a strange way, the treatment is understandable, if a little unfair.  The reason is that in James' original story, we see surprisingly little of the Wingraves.  Of the two Wingrave elders, it is Owen's aunt, Miss Jane Wingrave ("Miss Wingrave" in the opera), who gets the most narrative time.  General Sir Philip Wingrave, the grandfather, is barely there, more of an "off-stage" presence, albeit still a viciously denouncing one.  In other words, Piper and Britten had to create characters to fill out the stage, so they had license to depict as they saw fit.

There is, however, one character who shows a fair degree of complexity, in both the story and the opera: Spencer Coyle, the teacher.  When Owen 'comes out' as a newly minted pacifist, Coyle objects also, more vehemently in the story than the opera, but not to the extreme point of the Wingrave family.  He acknowledges later that his visit to the Wingrave manor, Paramore, is not a friendly call, but that he is on a mission to convert Owen back to the Wingrave family creed, of "pride, pomp and circumstance of glorious war", to cite another literary source.  

What makes Coyle more complex, and thus more interesting, is that he embodies the Voltairean epigram of "I disagree with everything you say, but....":

"What he thinks right I may deplore, but cannot conscientiously dismiss."

He is also wise enough to realize that in spite of Owen's pacifism, "the pity is you are a fighter".  Coyle is smart enough to see that fighting can be something else other than physical.  This contrasts with Kate's more superficial mindset (age vs. youth, after all):

"Coyle: " my sense, he is, in a high sense of the term, a fighting man."
Kate: "Ah let him prove it."

In the opera, this line is transposed to a conversation between Coyle and Miss Wingrave:

"Coyle: The boy has spirit, you will admit.
Miss Wingrave: No Wingrave lacks spirit.
Coyle: Then may he not be guided by his beliefs?
(snip a few lines)
Miss Wingrave: Is it not your job to encourage fighting men?
Coyle: He is, in the highest sense, a fighting man."

Coyle also somewhat wryly comments at one point:

"All my life I have taught the art of war, but for war in the family there's no answer in the books."

As Tim Ashley notes, the none-too-subtle irony is that Paramore itself is a war zone, for this ultimate "battle of the mind" between Owen and the remaining Wingraves and the Julians.

You may have noticed that so far, this diary hasn't said much about Owen himself.  That is because in some strange way, he isn't totally the central character, especially in the James story, where Coyle is really the heart of plot evolution.  In the opera, though, Piper and Britten give Owen some solo moments where he freely expresses his sentiments, including a setting of passages from Shelley's Queen Mab in Act I:

"War is the statesman's game, the priest's delight,
The lawyer's jest....
And to those royal murderers whose mean thrones                  
Are bought by crimes of treachery and gore...
Guards, garbed in blood-red livery, surround
Their palaces, participate the crimes
That force defends.....
These are the hired bravos who defend
The tyrant's throne - the bullies of his fear;
The refuse of society, the dregs
Of all that is most vile; They cajole with gold
And promises of fame the thoughtless youth
Already crushed with servitude; he knows
His wretchedness too late....
Look to thyself, priest, conqueror or prince!
Whether thy trade is falsehood..."

In Act II, in his big 'peace aria', he gives full voice, such as this excerpt:

"For peace is not lazy but vigilant,
peace is not acquiescent but searching,
peace is not weak but strong like a bird's wing
bearing its weight in the dazzling air.
Peace is not silent; it is the voice of love.

Oh you with your bugbears, your arrogance, your greed,
your intolerance, your selfish morals and petty victories,
peace is not won by your wars.

Peace is not confused, not sentimental, not afraid.
Peace is positive, is passionate, committing -
more than war itself.
Only in peace I can be free."

Well-spoken sentiments, to be sure, but this is the point of some main criticism of the opera, like Anna Picard's review: that Owen Wingrave is more of a sermon than an opera.  Yet even Owen isn't 'pure' regarding fighting and violence, in moments like:

  • Once in each act, he speaks of past soldiers historical and in his own ancestors, saying "I'd hang the lot."
  • Act II, after he and Coyle talk of the story of that  Wingrave father and boy in that past story, Owen defends the father's act: "The blow was justified! Wingraves do not refuse to fight...ever."

Musically, the opera is not Britten's most memorable, especially compared to the standards of Peter Grimes (where I can hum and sing, very badly, the opening section on demand).  No really good tunes stick in one's head, or at least mine.  The use of the percussion group within the orchestra is interesting, to be sure.  But that's more fascinating in terms of timbre than melody, even if fitting in terms of the militaristic theme.  

The opera ends in a "double dog dare you" from Kate to Owen, after she steps over the line and calls him a coward, which pushes his buttons big time.  She challenges him to sleep in the "haunted room".  Understandably, Owen initially refuses, but finally says 'yes'.  He rightly characterizes that room as follows:

"The anger of the world is locked up there;
the horrible power that makes men fight;
now I alone must take it on,
I must go in there."

He even says that Kate can lock him in.  No prizes for guessing who wins.  The opera ends quietly, almost anti-climatically, no big crashing climax as Owen faces down the demon.  But this is keeping with the story, where Kate realizes the folly of what she's done, but too late, as the story suddenly just ends, even if the description at the end is that Owen "looked like a young soldier on a battle-field".

Yet, as Tim Ashley noted, for political reasons if not totally musical ones, this work has resonance for now, like the War Requiem:

"We will, of course, be hearing it in the knowledge that yet more lives, military and civilian, have been wasted in Iraq, and that the voices of those opposed to military intervention have been ignored. 'Peace is not won by your wars,' Owen tells his family, adding that he would make it a crime for any politician to send men both to slaughter and be slaughtered."

Picard, in fairness, noted that the Covent Garden run fully sold out.  She asserted that Britten expressed his sentiments better in the War Requiem, and I'd have to agree.  There's more than an element of PC in both works, well before the term gained notoriety.

Yet in spite of all this, if the local opera company staged Owen Wingrave, would I go see it?  Heck, yeah.  Culture and art are often seen, in America at least, as detached and isolated from the issues of the day.  The charge, especially in 'highbrow' realms like opera, is just in many ways, especially if you go to someplace like the Metropolitan Opera in NYC, where any deviation from 'tradition' is pounced upon without mercy and new works very rarely get played (admittedly for reasons of cost and scheduling, but I digress).  Owen Wingrave is one opera that engaged in topical issues, if obliquely, and in the context of Vietnam, as noted in several of the articles linked to above.  Topicality is always a risk with art, in dating it and rendering it potentially more vulnerable to the judgments of time.  Given how humanity tends to repeat its follies, however, works like Owen Wingrave and the War Requiem can all too often lie dormant to be exhumed later, if only for a moment.

Originally posted to chingchongchinaman on Wed May 30, 2007 at 04:21 PM PDT.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

  •  Thanks for reading. (8+ / 0-)

    I don't have time to reply now, and sorry that this turned out to be a monster to read through.  I'll respond later to any comments; hope this was worth your time.

    "It's only in books that the officers of the detective force are superior to the weakness of making a mistake." (Wilkie Collins, The Moonstone)

    by chingchongchinaman on Wed May 30, 2007 at 04:08:29 PM PDT

  •  This was a wonderful read. (1+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:

    Thank you!

    There are, in every age, new errors to be rectified, and new prejudices to be opposed. -Samuel Johnson (1709-1784)

    by slksfca on Wed May 30, 2007 at 04:12:41 PM PDT

    •  my pleasure; thank you (0+ / 0-)

      Sorry about the very late reply.  I'm glad that you liked it.

      "It's only in books that the officers of the detective force are superior to the weakness of making a mistake." (Wilkie Collins, The Moonstone)

      by chingchongchinaman on Thu May 31, 2007 at 05:58:15 AM PDT

      [ Parent ]

      •  Very interesting. How did I miss this yesterday? (1+ / 0-)
        Recommended by:

        I suspect strongly considered going to a performance of Owen Wingrave in London.  

        P.S.  I note the "pomp and Circumstance" reference.  But you aren't finished with that topic, eh?

        P.P.S.  Perhaps a list of classical music afficianados at DK with w/e mail addresses.  Then when one of the list posts a diary that includes references to classical music, the diarist could notify the list.  [Digression:  Hillary Clinton's campaign listed songs and solicited people to pick the campaign song.  I didn't know any of the choices!.]

        •  very easily, it seems :) (1+ / 0-)
          Recommended by:

          Well, given only 1 other comment besides mine after the whole evening, and 6 or so recs, lots of other people glossed it over too, it seems.  I wasn't quite sure what the hot topic du jour was yesterday evening, but such is life.

          Actually, I've barely begun with "pomp and circumstance", since it anticipates this Saturday's SNLC :) .  I'll actually need your help to keep that one going, since it will be yet another "post and run fairly soon" edition.

          "It's only in books that the officers of the detective force are superior to the weakness of making a mistake." (Wilkie Collins, The Moonstone)

          by chingchongchinaman on Thu May 31, 2007 at 06:13:35 PM PDT

          [ Parent ]

          •  I'll be around this Sat. Meanwhile (1+ / 0-)
            Recommended by:

            Owen and you made the rescued diaries list tonight.  Kudos.  

            •  yes, just saw it / recent Britten article (1+ / 0-)
              Recommended by:

              I was happily surprised at that.  The other rescued diaries are good too (just posted on one of them).

              The next SNLC goes up pretty promptly on Saturday night; we'll see if rain hits again.

              For general readers: Jessica Duchen has this recent article on a trip to Aldeburgh, Britten's home for many years.  It has a provocative comment from Hans Keller, @ 1952:

              'The hard-hitting critic Hans Keller delivered a startling description of Britten's music in 1952. "It is an established fact that strong and heavily repressed sadism underlies pacifist attitudes," he wrote. "About the vital aggressive element in Britten's music... there cannot be the faintest doubt... What distinguishes Britten's musical personality is the violent repressive counter-force against his sadism."

              The composer responded to this bizarre and possibly politically inspired remark with good humour. But in one respect, Keller was right: Britten's music has hidden teeth, as powerful and threatening as the sea.'

              "It's only in books that the officers of the detective force are superior to the weakness of making a mistake." (Wilkie Collins, The Moonstone)

              by chingchongchinaman on Thu May 31, 2007 at 09:19:28 PM PDT

              [ Parent ]

      •  What is UDKJ12? (1+ / 0-)
        Recommended by:
        •  acronyms (1+ / 0-)
          Recommended by:

          UDKCJ = Useless Daily Kos Culture Journal

          Although, given that I've taken over SNLC from the now on-leave IC/SONS, most of the energy that might have gone to UDKCJ has gone to SNLC, it would appear.

          "It's only in books that the officers of the detective force are superior to the weakness of making a mistake." (Wilkie Collins, The Moonstone)

          by chingchongchinaman on Thu May 31, 2007 at 06:14:34 PM PDT

          [ Parent ]

          •  I'm thinking if you posted the Britten diary at (1+ / 0-)
            Recommended by:

            about 11:30 p.m. PST, you'd get a pretty fair number of readers and commenters.

            •  common motif / I guess so; still..... (1+ / 0-)
              Recommended by:

              I wasn't sure I'd have made the midnight deadline before the end of May 30.

              Oh, one other small point: if you remember in the War Requiem the 3-note fanfare at the beginning of the "Dies irae", which eventually gets transmuted into the "Bugles sang" baritone section, that motif recurs in the song about the boy and the father who fatally hit him ("Trumpet blow / Paramore shall welcome woe").

              "It's only in books that the officers of the detective force are superior to the weakness of making a mistake." (Wilkie Collins, The Moonstone)

              by chingchongchinaman on Thu May 31, 2007 at 09:23:13 PM PDT

              [ Parent ]

  •  Great opera and a great post. (1+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:

    It took me a while to appreciate Britten's operas, but I finally came around after playing in the pit for a production of "Turn of the Screw" in D.C. and Virginia last year.  Another important anti-war work is one of the songs from his set "Who Are These Children?", the song "The Children."  Very very disturbing text and setting by Britten.

    "No man should advocate a course in private that he's ashamed to admit in public." -George McGovern

    by Arturo52 on Thu May 31, 2007 at 08:36:55 PM PDT

    •  Wow, that's great that you played for "Turn" (0+ / 0-)

      I would rate Turn of the Screw as the better opera of the two James adaptations, but as noted above, if there's ever a local production of Owen Wingrave in my lifetime, I'll be first in line for tickets.

      There was once a local production at one of the universities of Turn of the Screw, and I was lucky enough to see it.

      Just wondering: who were the singers in your cast there?  Thanks again for the great post.

      "It's only in books that the officers of the detective force are superior to the weakness of making a mistake." (Wilkie Collins, The Moonstone)

      by chingchongchinaman on Thu May 31, 2007 at 09:01:29 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

      •  It was a great cast - (1+ / 0-)
        Recommended by:

        I played three performances, two at Lorin Maazel's estate in Virginia, one at the Kennedy center.  Maazel conducted two performances, his protege Kynan Johns conducted the other.  The casts were made up of young up and comers, but most have had roles at major houses;

        Peter Quint - Jeffrey Lentz
        Governess - Anne Dreyer
        Mrs. Grose - Michelle Rice
        Miss Jessel - Valerie Komar

        I had a great time, and got to learn the opera quite well, I hope I get to add a few other Britten scores to my rep!

        "No man should advocate a course in private that he's ashamed to admit in public." -George McGovern

        by Arturo52 on Fri Jun 01, 2007 at 06:00:37 AM PDT

        [ Parent ]

        •  I'd heard about that Maazel-led performance (0+ / 0-)

          I think I saw something in the WaPo.  I've now just dug up some old articles about it, here, and here.  That's really so good that you got to do this.  Normally, I'd ask what it was like to work with Maazel, but what you write might be traceable here, so you don't have to talk about that if you'd rather not.

          "It's only in books that the officers of the detective force are superior to the weakness of making a mistake." (Wilkie Collins, The Moonstone)

          by chingchongchinaman on Fri Jun 01, 2007 at 09:50:04 PM PDT

          [ Parent ]

  •  Thanks also for the rescue / DVD version (0+ / 0-)

    I probably should have also said that even though the Wingrave family is one side of caricature, that isn't to say that such people don't exist in real life.  Any glance at Freeperland would tell one that, plainly.

    BTW, for those interested, there's a DVD version, directed by Margaret Williams, that updated the story to the 1956 Suez crisis.

    "It's only in books that the officers of the detective force are superior to the weakness of making a mistake." (Wilkie Collins, The Moonstone)

    by chingchongchinaman on Thu May 31, 2007 at 09:08:42 PM PDT

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site