Skip to main content

Yet another installment of my ongoing debate with my uncle...  This time he presented his warped caricature of what a "liberal" believes and suggested it was how I thought...  I did my best to set him straight!  Sorry, it's long, I tend to ramble but i wanted to hit him point for point.

First, his email, then my response:

One other thing...you don't look at this country in the same way as I do...
You blame America first...I don't
You see more wrong than right...I don't
You have less faith in the peoples abilities than I do...
You have more faith in Government than I do...
You think you can talk your way out of war with terrorists...I don't
You think the All Voluntary Army needed the job and benefits...I don't...It's called patriotic...
You think Big Business is bad...I don't
You think Corporations need to be taxed...I don't...They just pass the tax on to me (and you)
You think competition is bad...I don't
You think taxes are good...I don't
You want Health Care by the same people that gave you the Housing Projects...Welfare and Katrina
You want the same government that had the war on poverty (6 Trillion later) and the numbers are the same...except that our poor are the richest poor in the WORLD...
I'm about worn out trying to point out the obvious...but I'll keep trying.

----------------------------------------

Now, my response:

How arrogant of you Uncle, to try to tell me what it is that I think!  You must have me confused with some liberal caricature that you argue with in your own mind...  not that I'm surprised, mind you, that after all this time that we have been talking you still don't have a clue what it is that I think, you never bother to listen to a goddamned thing that anyone else has to say, much less me, so convinced as you are of your own righteousness despite the clear and obvious FAILURE of everything you have stood for and professed as true your whole political life.  

Well, if you will, allow me to retort, and this time I suggest you pay a bit of attention.  

I do not "blame my country first", as you claim, but I do hold my country to a higher standard of behavior, as I hold myself to a higher standard of behavior, uncle.  I don’t know what you taught your children, Uncle, or what your parents taught you, but my parents taught me that it not important only to succeed in life, but to succeed in life while always doing the right thing!  I have always tried to live my life that way, and will expect the same of my son.  And I expect the same of my Country!  I would not sell my soul or my ideals or my values for success or security, and I hold my country to that standard.  I do this because I love my country, and as I would be remiss if I failed to recognize my own failings when I fail, so would I be remiss in not recognizing my countries failings and calling them out!

I do not see more wrong than right, but I recognize that you cannot right the wrong without seeing it, without looking at it, without understanding it.  You might believe that so long as you wake up every day to a rousing chorus of "USA! USA! USA!", that all will be right with the world, but I can only pray that you don’t take the same tactic when dealing with problems in your own life.

I don’t have less faith in people’s abilities, in fact quite the opposite, I have the utmost faith in peoples abilities, and I believe when I see the whole of the middle and working classes of this country struggling, that we as a nation can and must do more to see that the American people are more able achieve their potential.  

I don’t have more faith in my government, I have a higher expectation for my government.  You see Katrina as simply the result of government failures, and believe that government can do no better...  As your President might say, that is the soft bigotry of low expectations.  I see Katrina as a failure of the people in charge of government, and I believe that My government can and should do better.

I don’t believe that we can talk our way out of a war with terrorists, but I don’t think that war is the best or only solution to the terrorist problem.  There will be times, uncle, when my country will have to go to war to defend itself, and to bring those who wish to do it harm to justice.  But if you believe, uncle, that continuous warfare against the innocent people of a country that had done nothing to us is the only way to keep America safe from terrorism, then I can only tell you that you have no understanding of the threat that we face, and you and those who share your ideology will never be able to defeat it!

I believe uncle, that our men and women in the Armed services are patriots of the highest order, but that there is a reason that the recruiters rarely stopped by my upper middle class high school, but had a heavy and constant presence at the underprivileged urban high school I worked at after I graduated from college.  I believe that there was a reason why my brother went into the military after he graduated high school, and why your own son did not.  It has nothing to do with the patriotism of the individuals, I believe your son loves his country as much as my brother does.  The difference between the two of them has more to do with opportunity than patriotism, uncle.  Let me be clear, this is not a slam on the military, I am proud of my brothers service, nor is it a knock against your son, I know him to be a good man and a patriotic American.  It is merely an attempt on my part to help you see the difference between the two.

I do not hate big business.  I work for a big business, one of the biggest businesses around in fact, and am quite proud of what I do and who I work for.  But I can be proud because I know from experience that the company I work for is responsible both to the customers it serves and to the employees on it’s payrolls.  It encourages unions and workers rights, is forward thinking on workplace safety and on it’s members health and well being.  And, by the way, it succeeds, Uncle, not despite the fact that it does these things but because it does these things.  I don’t hate big business, I dislike irresponsible business, business that fails the needs of the communities that they purport to serve, that use their muscle to get favorable tax structures that you and I pay for at the expense of their smaller competition.  I dislike businesses that have profits that are less than the amount of the subsidies that it’s high priced lobbyists extract from the government.  

As far as corporations being taxed, uncle, well, you got me there.  I pay my taxes, and so should a corporation that makes billions of dollars in profits, or at the very least, that my tax dollars shouldn’t go to a corporation making billions of dollars in profits in the name of corporate welfare and subsidies, especially when the same corporation sends American jobs overseas to pad their bottom line.  

I don’t think competition is bad, I think it’s one of the things that make this country great, but you are willing to overlook the fact that the playing field isn’t on the level anymore, that companies like Wal-Mart can and do extract favorable deals from local governments that give them favorable deals and tilt the playing field in their favor, and against independent retailers.  I think competition is necessary, but too many of our vital national industries, from Oil Companies to utilities to media companies are becoming more and more centralized and thus there is less and less competition in the marketplace.  You are so blinded by your love of profits that you fail to see the growing inequity on the playing field of competition, which makes it less of a competition and more of a fixed game.  

And again, I DON’T LIKE TAXES!!!  I've said that before but you never listen, probably because, as is typical of your generation (and especially republican's of your generation) you never close your goddamn mouths long enough to listen to what anyone else has to say (And then you wonder aloud why you never hear any good ideas from the other side).  I pay taxes, in fact, I have an above-the-median income, and no deductions, so I pay a hefty tax bill that I can scarcely afford.  Nonetheless, unlike you (who I am sure pays as much if not more in taxes as I make in a year) I don't piss and moan about the taxes I pay.  What irritates me isn't the taxes I pay but where that money goes.  It really irks me that we have 47 million Americans in this country without health insurance yet the government gives Billions of dollars in subsidies to Wal-Mart, and Montsanto and Exxon Mobile, companies who make billions in profits (though often times those billions are less than the billions in subsidies, suggesting that the companies probably shouldn't exist in the first place or at least not in the form that they currently exist).  It grates on me that with the security threats we face as a nation, we spend Hundreds of Billions of dollars on a Military meant to fight the cold war...  It's idiotic, THAT's what needs to change, not the taxes they take but the money they spend.  But again, I am not in favor of taxes for the sake of taxes!!!

I don’t want government provided health care (and I certainly don’t want health care from the people who brought us Katrina, those were your people, remember?).  but I think we need to do something to see that people have access to adequate preventative medical care as a moral issue but because we spend too much money on health care in this country!!!  We spend more per capita in this country on health care and have on average a lower quality and standard of health care than much of the industrialized western world.  That might be fine with you, unc, but it’s not ok with me.  We can and must do better!  And we better do something soon, unc, because with 40 million uninsured and growing, at some point access to socialized medicine sounds a lot better than access to no medicine.  I work for a private, for profit health care provider, unc, and I like it, but the problem with health care in America (and there is one) isn’t a lack of profit, it’s a lack of access and a lack of coverage.  

Listen, if you’ve managed to get through this, why don’t you allow me the pleasure of telling you what YOU think:

You think that the only thing wrong with America is that the richest one percent don’t have enough money.

You think that government can’t work and vote for people who insure that it doesn’t.

You think the only way you can sleep well at night is if our young men and women are in a foreign country killing brown people you think look scary.

You claim to love your country but cry louder than my son with a dirty diaper when your country needs money to fight a war that YOU want it to fight.

You think that poor people are poor because they are stupid or lazy.

You think Paris Hilton is rich because she works hard and deserves it.

You think that the findings of the worlds scientists mean nothing next to your gut feeling about things.  

Have I got it about right????

Originally posted to Old Man Jeremy on Wed Feb 20, 2008 at 03:33 PM PST.

EMAIL TO A FRIEND X
Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags

?

More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

  •  You got it just right. I assume you (1+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    HoosierDeb

    know that nothing will change his mind. But as a cathartic experience for you, this must be well worth while.

  •  Mine was a little different (3+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    debedb, myrealname, HoosierDeb

    My crazy uncle believes that Obama is no less a cult leader than Jim Jones was.  He begs me to not drink any Kool Aid, if offered.

    I just told him that at our Obama meeting, after we faced Mecca and said our prayers, we finished up the remaining details of the surrender to terrorists.  Then...they guy who was supposed to bring the Kool Aid forgot.  So, naturally, we stoned him to death.

    I haven't heard back yet.

  •  If someone addressed such a vile (0+ / 0-)

    piece of shit like that to me, personally, I would delete it and never speak to them again.  Period.  Uncle or no.

  •  G.W. Bush's approval as per ARG (1+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    HoosierDeb

    has fallen to 19%:

    http://americanresearchgroup.com/...

    It used to be 89% a month after 9/11. 70% of Americans changed their mind about him. Your uncle sounds like one of the 19% diehards, but minds can be changed when we see the light.

    "Some men see things as they are and say 'Why?' I dream things that never were and say, 'I need to quit drinking!'" - Greasy Grant

    by Greasy Grant on Wed Feb 20, 2008 at 03:44:51 PM PST

  •  Um. Honestly, I don't think so. (1+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    altruista

    I say this as respectfully as possible because I realize that your uncle is family and I don't want to appear as though I am insulting you or your uncle.  

    But what makes you think you are in a debate with your uncle?

    Seriously.

    Have you ever been in an honest discussion, a healthy debate, where the person you were talking to told you what you thought, what you were about, about everything, without ever allowing you to speak for yourself?

    When you talk to your friends, do they respond to you by quoting lists and talking points provided from thinktanks?

    You just wrote a huge manifesto. It must have taken you a long time. In response to a person who isn't debating you, they are wasting your time so you can't actually do something that might make America a more liberal country.

    It's a tactic, not a discussion.

    You would honestly be better off ignoring your uncles baiting you and spend the extra hour doing something to help what you believe in.

    People like your uncle are never going to wake up one day and smack a Hilary or Obama sticker on their vehicle anymore than you are likely to wake up one day and worship Michelle Malkin's every whisper.

    Sometime this year, an eighteen year old soldier will die in a war that started when he was thirteen. -Anonymous

    by LeftHandedMan on Wed Feb 20, 2008 at 03:47:07 PM PST

    •  Also (0+ / 0-)

      You may not realize this, but the second your uncle goaded you into taking his talking points seriously, and having to take the time to justify your not agreeing with them as if they were posited in an intellectually honest fashion, he won his little wingnut moral victory.

      You had to justify your beliefs on his terms. He got to be Sean Hannity accusing you of 'wanting the terrorists to win' and you got to be Alan Colmes explaining that 'you don't want the terrorists to win'. Getting you in that Colmes place is why he spams you with wingnuttery.

      That's why conservatives say people 'hate America'. Because nothing is more entertaining to a wingnut that forcing a liberal or moderate to have to stand there talking about why they 'don't' hate America, instead of saying 'that's bullshit' and not giving it the time of day as if its a legitimate line of argument.

      If you are a kid in a schoolyard, and some other kid calls your mother a whore, there are lots of ways you can fight back. You can walk away, or you can slug him in the jaw.

      But if you find yourself standing in the middle of a schoolyard giving a ten minute explanation on why you mother isn't a whore, that's a win for the creepy bully. He lives for this kind of stuff.

      Because he baited you into cruelly entertaining him, and he doesn't care what you think... or he wouldn't be thugging you by calling your mother a whore in the middle of the schoolyard in the first place.

      The type of person who sends you the latest 'liberals hate the troops' spam doesn't care what you think. He doesn't intellectually respect you enough not to spam you with bullshit talking points.

      Sometime this year, an eighteen year old soldier will die in a war that started when he was thirteen. -Anonymous

      by LeftHandedMan on Wed Feb 20, 2008 at 04:00:23 PM PST

      [ Parent ]

      •  Haha, it's funny that you mention that (1+ / 0-)
        Recommended by:
        HoosierDeb

        because actually this was the first time I had heard form him in awhile, becuase just a few weeks ago, I stopped playing defence (which I usually do becuase I can) and started playing offence, demanding that he justify his ideology and the failures of the Bush administration, without responding to his attacks...  Needless to say, he didn't respond and stopped emailing for a few weeks.  He knew he couldn't, and he knew I knew he couldn't, so he just laid low for a bit and hoped I'd forget about it...  I sent him another email after this assuring that I had not...

        But to be honest, I don't mind playing defense, we should be able to defend ourselves, and a good defense can be a good offence if you know how to do it...  Perhaps if Alan Colmes wasn't so bad at it that show wouldn't be such a joke!

    •  Well, you are right, it's true (2+ / 0-)
      Recommended by:
      ohioskeptic, HoosierDeb

      that i'll never change his mind...  in fact, I'm not debating him to do that, he's old and has already chosen what he wants to believe facts be damned, but for whatever reason, I have a tough time writing without being prompted, and he gets me going...  I'm not doing it to convince him, i'm doing it to sharpen my writing skills and keep them sharp...  If i could do it without prompting, I would.

  •  I wouldn't even bother trying to reason with him (0+ / 0-)

    Frankly, when it comes to people like your uncle, they aren't interested in hearing any debate or discussing any issues. They just want to push their viewpoints on you and be self-righteous about it. Frankly you're better off just agreeing not to discuss politics. He's part of that 40% that exists on both sides of the political spectrum who isn't going to change his mind no matter what you say or argue.

  •  Corporations Pass on.... (0+ / 0-)

    their taxes to us? Yes, they do.  My phone bill, for instance, is laden with taxes levied on the phone companies, and they just bill their customers for them.  But if we were to repeal taxes now levied on corporations, who could be so naive as to think that they'd pass the savings on to us?  Give me a break.  

    If I ever found out that someone was going around telling people I'd make a terrific corporate CEO, I'd sue them for slander.

    "Your silence will not protect you." --Audrey Lorde

    by altruista on Wed Feb 20, 2008 at 04:38:24 PM PST

  •  I come from a Republican family..... (0+ / 0-)

    and I've long since given up challenging the bigotry, the belief in "The Welfare Queen" picking up her welfare check in a Cadillac, the "Bruce Springsteen is a lefty.  He hates America" baloney.  It's no use.

    "Your silence will not protect you." --Audrey Lorde

    by altruista on Wed Feb 20, 2008 at 04:41:05 PM PST

  •  You need short responses - you can't rebut (0+ / 0-)

    talking points with complete sentences.  They won't bother with that much reading.  Simple thoughts for simple minds, etc...

    One other thing...you don't look at this country in the same way as I do...  You're right.
    You blame America first...No, I don't blame America, but I do want it to take responsibility for its actions, good or bad.
    You see more wrong than right...No, I some wrong that must be righted, to achieve America's ideals.
    You have less faith in the peoples abilities than I do...I have great faith in people's abilities, and I wish this administration would trust our opinions
    You have more faith in Government than I do...I have faith in Government, when the government has faith in itself; when it's run by people who don't believe in it, I have no faith in it whatsoever.
    You think you can talk your way out of war with terrorists...I don't  You think you can bomb your way out of war with terrorists...I don't
    You think the All Voluntary Army needed the job and benefits...I don't...It's called patriotic... I think anyone patriotic enough to risk their life for our country deserves to have us hold up our end of the deal.
    You think Big Business is bad...I don't  I think that any business that puts short-term gain ahead of what's good for the nation is bad, big or small.
    You think Corporations need to be taxed...I don't...They just pass the tax on to me (and you)  I think that tax burdens should be fair.
    You think competition is bad...I don't  I think competition is great, but I want to compete on a level playing field.
    You think taxes are good...I don't  I understand that some things can only be done collectively, such as providing for the national defense (which I think you support) and we have to pay for those things somehow.  I'm willing to pay my share.  You aren't.
    You want Health Care by the same people that gave you the Housing Projects...Welfare and Katrina.  No, the last thing I want is health care by the people responsible for Katrina.  Fortunately, they'll be out of office in 11 months.
    You want the same government that had the war on poverty (6 Trillion later) and the numbers are the same...except that our poor are the richest poor in the WORLD...  I want a government that wants the best for all of its people - including YOU - not just the top 1%.
    I'm about worn out trying to point out the obvious...but I'll keep trying.  Well, at least we can agree on one thing.

    Now, go spread some peace, love and understanding. Use force if necessary. - Phil N DeBlanc

    by lineatus on Wed Feb 20, 2008 at 05:17:45 PM PST

    •  ps - ironic that his sentences all say (0+ / 0-)

      "You think.... I don't"

      That pretty much sums it up, doesn't it?

      Now, go spread some peace, love and understanding. Use force if necessary. - Phil N DeBlanc

      by lineatus on Wed Feb 20, 2008 at 05:23:27 PM PST

      [ Parent ]

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site