Skip to main content

This morning I woke up to find an email response to my recent piece on Sarah Palin ("Don't Get Palin's Appeal? Try a Little Harder"):

Thank you, I had forgotten why people like to stuff people like you into ovens.........

If you really think hard,  you can figure out that "people like you" refers to my being Jewish, which this reader must have deduced from my last name, which sounds--Jewish.  

Beyond understanding the perspective of those who lionize Sarah Palin and will constitute her energetic base in politics, we need to make sense of the other, unsavory part of Sarah Palin's support.  Let's call them:


Two Stories: Democratic vs. Violent Order
Many people mistakenly believe that only those who commit acts of physical violence fit into a dangerous category.  This is a misconception.  Whether or not someone is a violent voter depends on the story about politics they carry around in their head.  It is a story that answers this basic question: How does politics work?

Some people give this kind of story in response to that question:

Politics works through an exchange of words.  Prior to the age of politics in which we live, now, people would resolve their problems through violence.  Whenever a problem came up, a solution was imposed by the person who successfully used violence to persuade others.  Today, when a problem comes up, the solution comes from the person who successfully uses argument to persuade others. In politics, we use argument to persuade instead of violence to suppress. Politics is an arena of debate, not fear."

That is the general, democratic story of politics and the hallmark of those voters who carry it around in your head is very easy to spot:  Whenever a political problem arises, voters with the democratic story in their heads want to talk to others in order to persuade them. They want to debate because they believe--even without thinking about it--that the key to finding political solution is conversation, debate, talk.  

But there is another story in the heads of another group of voters--another answer to the question "How does politics work?" which sounds something like this:

Politics should be an extension of the natural order of the strong ruling over the weak.  Originally, this was the case, but then the weak founds ways to use their words and their money take power away from the strong, and they slowly turned politics into an arena for taking from the strong and giving to the weak.  Politics controlled by the weak is based on deceit. The only way to restore the natural order of the strong over the weak is to overturn the political order by any means necessary.

That is the general violent story. It is not something that you will ever hear in its entirety, but you will hear parts of it.  Voters with this violent story in their heads all tend to believe in an original time when the strong or majority was in charge, until the weak or minority took over using tricks, money, deceit. They also believe in an idea of a natural order based on "strength," and as a result see politics as something fundamentally broken--fundamentally immoral because it has been rigged by the weak to prevent the natural order from emerging.  

Two Kinds of Political Action: Argument and Threat
Notice, though, that these two kinds of stories each lead to two different ideas about what counts as meaningful or acceptable action in the political arena.

For people with the democratic story in their heads, political action takes shape through words, talk, conversation.  Even when these people talk about "action, not words," what they really mean is "getting out and talking to people to persuade them."  This is a very basic belief in the idea of society run by citizens who interact in a public sphere of institutions, all of which provide a context for citizens to come together and talk, persuade each other, and solve problems together.

For people with the violent story in their heads, political action is the ability to use violence to impose one's will.  This does not mean actual physical violence.  Most often, the threat of violence is enough to impose one's will.  Holding up a noose, for example, is often enough to remind people of what violence awaits them if they do not comply.  Thus, the kinds of political actions we often see from people with the violent story in their heads involves displays of the implements of violence or, in other cases, reminders of horrific episodes of violence.

The Strong and the Weak
Not all of Sarah Palin's followers have the violent story in their head, but a fairly large percentage does.  There are plenty of people drawn to her because they are persuaded by her arguments, by her words--because they see her as effective at winning arguments against liberals.  No doubt, Sarah Palin has many,  many followers with the democratic story in their heads.

Many of them, however, think about politics through the violent story.  In particular, they see politics as an immoral arena controlled by the weak to defraud the strong. But who are the strong and who are the weak to these people?

For Sarah Palin's followers, the idea of "weak" and "strong" are reified primarily through American understandings of race and religion.

The strong, for Palin's followers are like themselves: white and Christian. The weak are not like themselves: non-white and non-Christian.

This means that they view politics as an arena that was taken away from whites and Christians by non-whites and non-Christians wielding tricks, money, and deceit.  The purpose of their political action is to overthrow that immoral order to restore the natural order of whites and Christians ruling over non-whites and non-Christians.

Now, obviously, this is a controversial way to put things.  I hold no illusions about what it feels like to be a supporter of Sarah Palin and to read that kind of description.   But let me make one thing clear:  We must recognize that there are a great many people in this country who have in their heads a very well-developed story about politics as an immoral system taken over by the non-white, non-Christian minority to defraud the white, Christian majority.  

Conservatively speaking, this story has been around for at least 300 years--at least since John Locke wrote his Second Treatise on Government.

This violent story of politics fueled the European mercantile conquest of North and South America.

This violent story of politics fueled the Atlantic slave trade.

This violent story of politics fueled the American civil war.

This violent story of politics fueled the rise of the KKK.

This violent story of politics fueled Jim Crow.

This violent story of politics fueled the rise of the skinhead and Neo-Nazi movement.

And now, this violent  story of politics has found a place for itself in the figure of Sarah Palin.

Why?  Because  Sarah Palin repeats the same story over and over and over again: This government, this president has used deceit to defraud the majority of the American people.

This is not an abstract argument to those with the violent story in their heads.  It is a description of an African-American president, believed to be a Muslim and a foreigner, claimed to have wealthy foreign Jewish backers who put him in office.

That story of Barack Obama as the symbol of the weak defrauding the strong--as the present incarnation of the non-white, non-Christian trickster using immoral politics to subvert the natural order--that is the story many people hear in the words of Sarah Palin.

And while the violent story of the subverted natural order may be much larger black and white or Christian and Jewish--those are the highly charged symbols that have condensed onto it through the persona of Sarah Palin.

Make no mistake about it. To a sizable percentage of her followers, Sarah Palin represents the return of the natural order of white Christians in Charge.

What to do About It
It is not hard to see why this kind of symbolic logic would emerge at this point.  The Presidency of Barack Obama is the first time the non-white order has been subverted, at least symbolically.  And even though Barack Obama is Christian, his experience in the world has been diverse enough to be different, and therefore threatening, to many people in this country.

But what can be done about these particular supporters of Palin?  What should we do when someone responds to our political arguments about the kind of policies we want from government with violent threats like this:

Thank you, I had forgotten why people like to stuff people like you into ovens.........

First, do not be afraid.

Second, DO, NOT, BE, AFRAID.

Third, describe this kind of language as "violent," and attribute that violence to the person who uses it.

Fourth, remind people that politics based on violence is not what most Americans believe.

Fifth, connect the violent voters to the political figures they support--in this case Sarah Palin.

Sixth, tell people that the problems in America are problems we all face together--we cannot move forward with threats from one group against another.

Seventh, focus on the issue at hand and actual arguments in the debate.

Eighth, remember that there are many people who will never stop pushing violence in politics--so ignore them and speak to someone else.

I have no illusions about changing the mind of a person who threatens me via email with talk of gas chambers and crematoria.  Get serious--I am no dummy.  If Sarah Palin has, say, 1 million fans who think about politics through the violent story of the natural order, there is not much anyone can do to reduce that number.

But there are many, many people who reject that way of thinking and who may be listening to the conversation simply because that is where the loudest noise is right now.  Those people are not driven by the violent story of politics and will listen to arguments by those who make the effort to refocus the issue at hand and the actual arguments in the debate.

Threats against another person on the basis of race or religion are abhorrent, but all it takes is a little presence of mind, self-awareness, and forethought to turn these encounters into something useful in the long run.

And we do have a long way to go.  

Originally posted to Jeffrey Feldman on Fri Nov 20, 2009 at 07:44 AM PST.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

Meteor Blades, mdeatherage, JD SoOR, grytpype, pontificator, Kimberley, Pat K California, Colorado Luis, wozzle, RichM, claude, maxomai, Julia Grey, Jeff in CA, JekyllnHyde, Alumbrados, Superskepticalman, tsackton, Ed in Montana, MichaelPH, Angie in WA State, Susan S, buffalo soldier, Sylv, DavidW in SF, aisling, KeithH, Terri, tmo, kid oakland, PLS, From the choir, RedMeatDem, PrahaPartizan, Sean Robertson, Cowalker, Chi, Beth, filkertom, usagi, catdevotee, Phoenix Woman, nolalily, Radiowalla, itsbenj, Odysseus, dratman, hester, lapin, lowkell, ultrageek, Sally in SF, skyesNYC, ogre, RW, Rayne, decembersue, sheba, teacherken, Bendygirl, crosslark, natasha, Timaeus, XOVER, Trendar, Liberal Thinking, miasmo, rhfactor, moon in the house of moe, daninoah, importer, mickT, Geenius at Wrok, mikeb42, Superribbie, Fenric, pHunbalanced, TrueBlueMajority, Powered Grace, tiponeill, mem from somerville, melvynny, madmsf, am, vancookie, BigOkie, janinsanfran, Knut Wicksell, Bob Love, DebtorsPrison, Lahdee, Emerson, karlpk, bread and roses, dengre, tommurphy, rincewind, Debby, Shockwave, Schmuck, Fabienne, Fishgrease, m maddog, ETinKC, Wintermute, billlaurelMD, SanJoseLady, meg, Jim in Chicago, hyperstation, shayera, rhubarb, Midwest Meg, mslat27, dsb, iconoclastic cat, frsbdg, xynz, azale, Raven Brooks, LuLu, route66, kdub, sersan, devtob, Mumon, frisco, lawnorder, TampaProgressive, marjo, lilorphant, SallyCat, shpilk, sidhra, bumblebums, zeroooo, mataliandy, Harper, Doctor Who, Ruth in OR, Bugsby, strengthANDwisdom, Plan9, sardonyx, soonergrunt, RumsfeldResign, checkmate, eyeswideopen, rasbobbo, ironist, dhonig, opinionated, srbaxley, sbwoodside, EvieCZ, bronte17, IllinoisMom, missLotus, 88kathy, medaka, cskendrick, Wee Mama, mint julep, SamSinister, elveta, annrose, ironheel, nyceve, understandinglife, MD patriot, bhlogger, Baldwiny, Loquatrix, lw1sne, HippyWitch, ask, CoolOnion, highacidity, poemless, boadicea, Cool Blue Reason, toyon toots, Glic, ksh01, gayntom, mkfarkus, pattisigh, buckhorn okie, moiv, mrblifil, greengrrl, rickpickett, Transmission, Aquarius40, Primordial Ooze, chimpy, roses, Frederick Clarkson, pedrito, Holly J, Tejas Geek, someRaven, nargel, nycnat, superba, BruinKid, sngmama, ornerydad, itskevin, jalbert, djk1, ClickerMel, Boxers, Nate Roberts, fumie, state29, Jesterfox, CarlaMalia, navajo, dmsilev, lirtydies, high uintas, Alna Dem, sidnora, OldYellerDog, sele, nuttymango, RayKCMO, SnyperKitty, Eddie C, wader, revsue, Anderson Republican, Quege, jdmorg, NMRed, asterlil, worldwideellen, SneakySnu, Braindead, Oke, jackmac, menodoc, hhex65, dejavu, psnyder, Moody Loner, nancelot, danthrax, TexDem, Dallasdoc, American Zapatista, by foot, pat bunny, Tracker, pointsoflight, MKS, casperr, elmo, brainwave, grannyhelen, alivingston, laderrick, LordMike, TiaRachel, johanus, Nina, hoolia, exiledfromTN, Blank Frank, JimWilson, churchylafemme, jamfan, GN1927, Oy the Billybumbler, On The Bus, hoof32, nika7k, MmeVoltaire, betson08, hazzcon, Greg in TN, annetteboardman, papercut, rlharry, beachmom, Cliff Talus, arielle, kalmoth, Timbuk3, lcrp, Pirate Smile, Schup, seenos, kismet, Pohjola, Democratic Hawk, Chun Yang, barbwires, Donna in Rome, JayBat, econlibVA, parkslopper50, zett, zerelda, ybruti, side pocket, Curt Matlock, Kitsap River, mungley, kfred, lonespark, Lefty Mama, KayCeSF, tomjones, eco, JayDean, CanYouBeAngryAndStillDream, Marcus L Salyer, SanDiegoDem, Marianne Benz, lyvwyr101, bablhous, westcott, American in Kathmandu, valadon, rickeagle, homogenius, Schwede, ganymeade, rambler american, AaronBa, malcontent, eztempo, Ameranth, Sybil Liberty, xxdr zombiexx, pat208, bibble, thereisnospoon, dakrle, sebastianguy99, TekBoss, Armand451, Limelite, environmentalist, Frank Vyan Walton, wolverinethad, TexMex, sawgrass727, Gowrie Gal, Big Tex, averageyoungman, gradinski chai, vcmvo2, Skennet Boch, Recovering Southern Baptist, chumley, bloomer 101, historys mysteries, Bluesee, sandblaster, Simian, marina, radarlady, ZZZzzz, Tinfoil Hat, Kewalo, Treg, capelza, TexasTom, DianeNYS, greycat, Unit Zero, Elise, LakeSuperior, blueyedace2, m16eib, deepfish, lilypew, JanetT in MD, Freakinout daily, CTPatriot, subtropolis, Heiuan, SherwoodB, klamothe, Technowitch, demimondian, KnotIookin, BCO gal, ccasas, panicbean, clammyc, Simplify, DocGonzo, ZappoDave, DoGooderLawyer, basquebob, TN yellow dog, Clem Yeobright, terrypinder, ChemBob, juliesie, TigerMom, miketocci, YucatanMan, wildcat6, EJP in Maine, trinityfly, Laurence Lewis, vigi, roninbushido, reflectionsv37, ratzo, ommzms, fixxit, eru, WinSmith, lennysfo, owlbear1, Mikado, cris0000, Papagoose, Morrigan, SaraBeth, Pam from Calif, Sun Tzu, snootless, JoieDe, nailmaker, pandawoman, Sara R, jimreyn, where4art, aaraujo, ladybug53, Overseas, nwsound, gerardbellavita, blue jersey mom, bmaples, jane123, onanyes, Sandino, kaliope, jtg, exmearden, rb608, Geekesque, FunkyEntropy, The Raven, optimusprime, power model, Shotput8, Aint Supposed to Die a Natural Death, pacotrey, neroden, wiscmass, EeDan, zinger99, coolbreeze, Lisa Lockwood, Dunvegan, deepsouthdoug, grrrlrobyn, Red Bean, Tex Kosmaniac Dem Lady, dsteffen, quiet in NC, bunsk, Cory Bantic, The Fat Lady Sings, Detroit Mark, the fan man, LisainNYC, jj24, doe, Ekaterin, hcc in VA, empathy, JanF, Snud, Land of Enchantment, zozie, terjeanderson, kathny, RainyDay, Sister Havana, bently, noweasels, Jim R, accumbens, begone, lgmcp, mariva, lcork, Philpm, alrdouglas, SoulCatcher, Mother Mags, Denny in Seattle, Audio Guy, occams hatchet, elliott, lilyvaldem, Shirl In Idaho, juliewolf, Jennifer Clare, Nance, L Boom, gwilson, BachFan, PsychicToaster, blizek, LeighAnn, Do Tell, tarheelblue, Stephan Kuttner, Keone Michaels, myboo, keeplaughing, Kingsmeg, vigilant meerkat, Clytemnestra, Junkyard Dem, edwardssl, virgomusic, ferallike, njr, Opakapaka, BlueInARedState, Califlander, Themistoclea, whitewidow, Kimball Cross, fat old man, Gorette, rl en france, Yellow Canary, duckhunter, seefleur, mooshter, kestrel9000, abe57, deha, rhetoricus, Im with Rosey, mango, earwulf, arlene, fou, mystery2me, raincrow, jwhitmill, kck, greenearth, bren, TalkieToaster, jguzman17, global citizen, erratic, A Siegel, philipmerrill, 4Freedom, figleef, Francine Shacter, bubbanomics, gatorcog, jerseyjo, nilocjin, Libby Shaw, mozartssister, Crashing Vor, Bush Bites, imabluemerkin, tapestry, Doctor Frog, mithra, PapaChach, Dauphin, plf515, bleeding heart, tommyfocus2003, totallynext, ER Doc, soccergrandmom, Dinclusin, dirtfarmer, Jax, doinaheckuvanutjob, middleagedhousewife, MBNYC, Phthalo, oakroyd, sharilynn, Pilgrim X, Dagoril, gratis4, Turbonerd, Dyana, Cenobyte, IL clb, rage, Sardanicas, profh, rsie, Persiflage, Roatti, zhimbo, Clive all hat no horse Rodeo, buckeye blue, va dare, fiddlingnero, Madam Deb, Stripe, means are the ends, WarrenS, cherryXXX69, frankzappatista, Dreaming of Better Days, kurt, lynneinfla, revgerry, tallmom, shaharazade, Statusquomustgo, AmySmith, kurious, bstotts, CharlieHipHop, Maimonides, etrangere, bloomingpol, pseudopod, thepdxbikerboy, Temmoku, ipsos, louise the dog, blueintheface, markthshark, mapman, Nulwee, Opposite Reaction, Pandoras Box, Aaa T Tudeattack, NonnyO, DBunn, Thinking Fella, One Pissed Off Liberal, pinkhighway, pgm 01, dov12348, fisheye, A Mad Mad World, Cali Techie, fabucat, goheelsgodems, Buckeye Hamburger, kokoro, Steven wonders, anotherdemocrat, bvljac, donnamarie, wa ma, Haningchadus14, Wanda517, Loudoun County Dem, Mr K, blue armadillo, dmh44, ninkasi23, Kathie McCrimmon, moodyinsavannah, SemDem, Dartagnan, momoaizo, suburi, gloriana, vets74, terryhallinan, EdSF, moosely2006, aravir, threegoal, liberality, Alfonso Nevarez, beth meacham, Allogenes, DoubleBarrellBunnyAnger, edsbrooklyn, FishOutofWater, DvCM, LillithMc, la urracca, yowsta, HeartlandLiberal, noofsh, Matt Z, terabytes, ezdidit, DWG, suejazz, londubh, Unbozo, St Louis Woman, ronlib, newpioneer, Strabo, gatorbot, Kyle the Mainer, Seneca Doane, artisan, getlost, jayden, GMFORD, jedennis, stratocasterman, ubertar, steamkettle, martyinsfo, akdude6016, Singing Lizard, vbdietz, mauro7inf, turthlover, TheCorkBoard, Killer of Sacred Cows, Kiamichi, SeaTurtle, mamafooce, mlv1055, jnhobbs, millwood, Moderation, Jack the R, jhop7, gchaucer2, carpunder, OIL GUY, Wreck Smurfy, Rumarhazzit, Brahman Colorado, madgranny, M Sullivan, LWelsch, JML9999, Korkenzieher, rf7777, Da Rock, Jahiz, sable, Bikemom, dizzydean, gloryous1, Assaf, the1sage, mall teacher, TomP, Empower Ink, gizmo59, roberta g, Spiffarino, VA Breeze, sand805, Winter Rabbit, JDWolverton, MKinTN, Patricia Bruner, CroneWit, FishBiscuit, fayeforcure, alkalinesky, Dem in the heart of Texas, rogerdaddy, gundyj, left turn, Justus, condorcet, JeffW, gfv6800, ShadowSD, RickMassimo, kimoconnor, hulagirl, dotster, TheFatLadySings, Phil N DeBlanc, scooter in brooklyn, ScottyUrb, Cordwainer, GlowNZ, Johnny Nucleo, OleHippieChick, mamamedusa, geez53, FightForJustice, Youffraita, lockewasright, Mr Stagger Lee, Fe Bongolan, FG, Wes Opinion, skohayes, VA gentlewoman, billvb, blindyone, ajr111240, lineatus, wonderful world, Mother of Zeus, Akonitum, Mr Rick, Its any one guess, mikeconwell, Greasy Grant, monkeybrainpolitics, pkohan, LearningCurve, Lujane, rssrai, royce, pamelabrown, boatjones, hwmnbn, madame damnable, geomoo, Jake Williams, bluesheep, TokenLiberal, MsWings, Jeff Y, NogodsnomastersMary, Lyddea, mnguy66, mofembot, Gemina13, kyril, lurxst, meldroc, Abra Crabcakeya, valsagem, luckylizard, nokkonwud, Piren, xysea, wyldraven, BYw, Karl Rover, ptolemynm, punkdavid, A Man Called Gloom, allie123, Executive Odor, HarpboyAK, priceman, binkycat, dont think, HoosierDeb, AndrewMC, Mike Taylor, Simply Agrestic, cactusflinthead, greenpunx, gsenski, GrannyOPhilly, Diogenes2008, papicek, SolarMom, lissablack, statsone, CIndyCasella, squarewheel, Tennessee Dave, maxcat06, oldliberal, mos1133, legendmn, whisperwolf, Fiddlegirl, clent, maggiejean, SciMathGuy, prettygirlxoxoxo, Pris from LA, 1BQ, dinsea, dalamia, Bule Betawi, Turn Left, multilee, pileta, Rhysling, artmartin, Florene, nippersdad, MufsMom, AD in SC, Independant Man, Fonsia, denisegreenbay, Texanomaly, rsmpdx, TxFlipper, Dirtandiron, WSComn, ARS, emboyo, litoralis, meatwad420, snackdoodle, greengemini, LinSea, The Dead Man, hummingbird4015, not a cent, DynamicUno, output, An Affirming Flame, Napoleon, cantelow, Carol in San Antonio, eltee, leftneck, be the change you seek, RustyCannon, Stranded Wind, ryan81, Jack Danger, imchange, Methinks They Lie, Tara the Antisocial Social Worker, velvet blasphemy, jodygirl, bigmikek7, tr GW, LeftyEngineer, Yalin, mkor7, EquationDoc, LibrErica, Daily Activist, jmknapp53, mHainds, langstonhughesfan, Mercuriousss, John Shade, virginwoolf, beegee kochav, BDsTrinity, batgirl71, moonheart, obiterdictum, NWTerriD, TheOpinionGuy, asym, heliosfootball, uno beagle, DClark4129, Hope Monger, soms, Corneliusmingus, kw7777777, Leslie in KY, COwoman, sanglug, allep10, drbcladd, kevinpdx, Shelley99, The BBQ Chicken Madness, histOries Marko, IreGyre, blueocean, mikeplugh, RadioGirl, Green Karma, 57andFemale, babeuf, LaneHW, D Wreck, brushysage, sherijr, fernan47, A Voice, DoggiesWatches, Sleepwalkr, jan0080, Bene Gesserit1, mahakali overdrive, astral66, spicecakes69, Livvy5, futureliveshere, Adept2u, davespicer, deviant24x, Leftcandid, Former Chicagoan Now Angeleno, SweetMartha

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site