Skip to main content

At courthouses across the United States, it has become increasingly common during the economic downturn for lawsuits to be filed against consumers to collect old debts. Lawyers who specialize in the practice are filing thousands of suits on behalf of large firms that have acquired debts from other companies. Although most people don't fight the suits and lose them by default, a Dallas woman bucked the trend last October.

Chrystal A. Snow challenged the validity of a $9,000 debt in a Dallas County Court-at-Law and countersued the debt collector for making improper phone calls, her attorney Ross Teter said. In a case that has received no media attention, Snow won her suit against Midland Funding LLC and the jury hearing the case awarded her $8.1 million -- $250 for actual damages, $100,000 for mental anguish and $8 million in punitive damages, he said.

"The jury made a finding she did not owe the debt," Teter said in a phone interview. "We argued that they violated the Texas Fair Debt Collection Act by making harassing phone calls and the jury agreed."

Midland Funding is a subsidiary of Encore Capital Group, a company whose primary business is the acquisition and collection of "charged-off consumer receivable portfolios," according to its 2009 annual report filed with the Securites and Exchange Commission.

"We acquire receivable portfolios at deep discounts from their face values," the annual report states. "[W]e have invested approximately $1.4 billion to acquire 28.8 million consumer accounts with a face value of approximately $43.8 billion."

As the owner of millions of long-overdue accounts from credit card, auto, health care and phone companies, Encore has three call centers in the U.S. and one in India to make collection calls. When these efforts are unsuccessful, Encore has a nationwide network of attorneys to pursue legal action for the full amount of the debt. If a creditor wins a lawsuit, it can get a court order to seize bank accounts, garnish paychecks and claim other assets. Consumers can find themselves on the hook for the debt plus interest, penalties and legal fees.

"We generally refer accounts for legal action where it appears the debtor is able, but unwilling, to pay their obligations," the annual report states. "We pay the law firms a contingency fee based on amounts they collect on our behalf."

An April 1 New York Times story on the rising number of court-ordered garnishments told the story of Sidney Jones, a maintenance worker who took out a $4,097 personal loan in 2001 from the subprime lender Beneficial Virginia:

He fell behind, and Beneficial sued. Mr. Jones did not appear in court. "I just thought they were going to take what I owed," he said.

By default, Beneficial won a judgment of $4,750, plus $900 in lawyers' fees, with the debt accruing interest at 27.55 percent until paid in full. The bank started garnishing his wages in March 2003.

Over the next six years, the bank deducted more than $10,000 from Mr. Jones's paychecks, but he made little headway on his debt. According to a court order secured by Beneficial's lawyers last spring, he still owed the company $3,965, a sum nearly equal to the original loan amount.

Allen West, a Republican candidate running for Congress in Florida to unseat Rep. Ron Klein (D-Boca Raton), lost a $2,832 judgment to Midland in 2009 for credit card debt, the Palm Beach Post reported in March. He's "more than half way" to paying it off, he told the paper.

Kristy Welsh, the editor of the do-it-yourself credit repair site Credit Info Center, said the worst thing a person can do is ignore a lawsuit filed to collect one of these "zombie" debts. File a answer to the original suit, Welsh advised in a phone interview. "If you don't answer you lose automatically. You don't want a judgment against you. You have zero to lose [by fighting]."

She wrote a blog post Friday on the six steps to take if you've been sued to collect a debt, even if you can't afford an attorney and must defend yourself:

... by filing an answer, you greatly increase the chance the creditor will dismiss the lawsuit. In other cases the collection agency rent-a-lawyer won't bother to show up themselves -- giving you the automatic win. Some lawyers who work for big collection agencies file as many as 50 lawsuits a day. Why spend time on a consumer who fights back when there are plenty who won't resist?

In Snow's case, the attorney representing Midland Funding did not appear and the one-day trial was conducted without him, Teter said.

Welsh said that a creditor is required to prove in court that a debt is valid, a difficult task for debt-acquisition firms like Midland because they receive a limited amount of information on the debts they acquire -- sometimes as little as the debtor's name, Social Security Number, amount owed and original creditor. "They weren't around watching the original creditor. They weren't around to witness the processing of payment," she said. "The older a debt is, the less chance it has of having any kind of paperwork."

The debts pursued by these firms often are inaccurate or have passed the statute of limitations in a consumer's state and are no longer legally required to be paid, she said.

Welsh runs an online forum where members share information with each other about their legal battles with debt collectors they call JDBs -- "junk debt buyers."

In the section of the annual report where Encore discloses the risks of running its business, the fact that consumers are banding together on the web is cited as a problem:

Consumers are exposed to information from a number of sources that may cause them to be more reluctant to pay their debts or to pursue legal actions against us. ... Various Internet sites are maintained where consumers can list their concerns about the activities of debt collectors and seek guidance from other website posters on how to handle the situation. And advertisements by debt relief attorneys and credit counseling centers are becoming more common, adding to the negative attention given to our industry. As a result of this negative publicity, debtors may be more reluctant to pay their debts or could pursue legal action against us regardless of whether those actions are warranted.

Snow, who did not return requests for comment, has reached a confidential settlement with Midland, her attorney Teter said.

Teter said that it's rare to achieve a result like hers in a debt collection lawsuit, but "I think it's not going to be so rare in the future. A lot of these debt collectors are making lots and lots of phone calls for no reason. The jurors are beginning to understand."

Rogers Cadenhead is the publisher of the Drudge Retort, a liberal social news site with 14,000 members.

Originally posted to rcade on Mon Apr 05, 2010 at 07:01 AM PDT.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

DrFrankLives, Renee, Julia Grey, Alumbrados, buffalo soldier, Joe Bob, chuck utzman, mhtims, Terri, LeislerNYC, Chi, hannah, sny, murphy, grollen, ogre, eleming, raatz, teacherken, laurak, askew, Trendar, Ivan, moon in the house of moe, Raybin, NevDem, badger, artr2, AdmiralNaismith, maynard, mattman, wytcld, Bob Love, newjeffct, tommurphy, Shockwave, Heather in SFBay, tacet, meg, Jay C, Arlyn, clone12, swamp possum, theran, SallyCat, BenGoshi, MarkInSanFran, bumblebums, mataliandy, cgilbert01, marge, Gareth, redtravelmaster, Theodoric of York Medieval Liberal, Heart of the Rockies, dpc, soonergrunt, RumsfeldResign, bara, rasbobbo, agoldnyc, Gustogirl, opinionated, concernedamerican, bronte17, Slacker Gal, Babsnc, conchita, mftalbot, BlackGriffen, BlackSheep1, wonkydonkey, Shadan7, Euroliberal, Doc Allen, Time Waits for no Woman, highacidity, boadicea, mkfarkus, vmibran, lorikay4, Frederick Clarkson, taonow, JuliaAnn, someRaven, Miss Blue, superba, jalbert, Nate Roberts, enough already, bustacap, Cedwyn, antirove, Alna Dem, hopeful, Chrisfs, wader, Texknight, psnyder, hangingchad, SlowToAnger, Dallasdoc, Winnie, businessdem, mad ramblings of a sane woman, gmb, grannyhelen, alivingston, TiaRachel, BMarshall, NYFM, GN1927, Penny Century, Chirons apprentice, defluxion10, TX Scotia, cat chew, weasel, jmknapp, chickeee, lcrp, alizard, Brian82, Democratic Hawk, SingleVoter, Anne from Vermont, cevad, Oaktown Girl, Panda, Exurban Mom, Matt Esler, AllisonInSeattle, zerelda, ybruti, side pocket, sfbrentb, lhuynh, lonespark, JayDean, SanDiegoDem, BigDuck, vacantlook, wezelboy, Schwede, AaronBa, Sybil Liberty, mm201, Julie Gulden, joanneleon, Fabian, chumley, ExStr8, maybeeso in michigan, historys mysteries, Qui Tacet Consentire Videtur, marina, radarlady, Tinfoil Hat, ManOnTheBench, IamtheReason, NoMoreLies, TexasTom, greycat, Ckntfld, snstara, JanetT in MD, Heiuan, SherwoodB, arnott, Erik the Red, PBen, Alice Venturi, Alien Abductee, jhutson, kefauver, basquebob, eru, Mz Kleen, PSzymeczek, Chaoslillith, Morrigan, SaraBeth, Frank Palmer, washingtonsmith, jimreyn, ladybug53, Kayakbiker, Overseas, quaoar, Ice Blue, jane123, kaliope, exmearden, noemie maxwell, Shotput8, shiobhan, CWalter, Ammo Hauler, neroden, wiscmass, Floja Roja, churchlady, Cory Bantic, Rogneid, Ekaterin, jct, psyched, dancewater, Alan Arizona, Land of Enchantment, terjeanderson, kathny, bently, xaxnar, debedb, Born in NOLA, martini, third Party please, Showman, Shirl In Idaho, Jennifer Clare, BachFan, MissInformation, Patriot Daily News Clearinghouse, Keone Michaels, myboo, Kingsmeg, cybersaur, WhyWhat, Clytemnestra, MeMeMeMeMe, BlueInARedState, emeraldmaiden, sfsalty, Themistoclea, DC Scott, seefleur, Dvalkure, kestrel9000, J Chang, deha, Triscula, Texas Blue Dot, Esjaydee, carolita, luckydog, hideinplainsight, TalkieToaster, tecampbell, global citizen, 4Freedom, nonnie9999, gooderservice, gatorcog, imabluemerkin, JVolvo, Preston S, myrealname, Andy30tx, doinaheckuvanutjob, Pilgrim X, Hey BB, Turbonerd, IL clb, dirkster42, profh, Persiflage, fiddlingnero, Madam Deb, blueoregon, kurt, Statusquomustgo, jjellin, PhilW, Picot verde, Temmoku, blueintheface, AllanTBG, andrewj54, Nulwee, ZenTrainer, janetsal, bigchin, tourist305, phonegery, Noor B, out of left field, Cali Techie, anotherdemocrat, meowmissy, wa ma, Ann Galloway, byDesign, dmh44, Deadicated Marxist, VA02 femocrat, yoduuuh do or do not, jds1978, Outrider, beth meacham, power2truth, chigh, HeartlandLiberal, gustynpip, Jimdotz, terabytes, greenchiledem, ilex, deepeco, DWG, sfbob, bornfighting, Kentucky Kid, getlost, jayden, stratocasterman, sabishi, st minutia, vbdietz, Uberbah, mudslide, millwood, Moderation, jhop7, ValleyForger, yella dawg, cececville, Dar Nirron, LWelsch, JML9999, lorac18nc, cacamp, Vinnie Vegas, Hens Teeth, vet, Neon Mama, Empower Ink, brouski, edg, RickMassimo, weegeeone, ScottyUrb, poligirl, skohayes, thetadelta, wonderful world, Akonitum, minerva1157, BlueMindState, pyxylyx, jakebob, Greasy Grant, Calamity Jean, Lujane, tofumagoo, Ministerbruce, boatjones, smartdemmg, geomoo, pickandshovel, MsWings, mnguy66, ShempLugosi, mofembot, Seamus D, Gemina13, pentacon, luckylizard, venger, James Kresnik, dan667, MarkVA71, BYw, eddienutzak, BlueGenes, allie123, slathe, ekyprogressive, Ellinorianne, Futuristic Dreamer, dmhlt 66, Simply Agrestic, dzog, Anjana, GrannyOPhilly, statsone, LaFeminista, Celtic Merlin, FudgeFighter, SciMathGuy, Pris from LA, 1BQ, Louisiana 1976, Bule Betawi, Fonsia, denisegreenbay, emboyo, litoralis, greengemini, Carol in San Antonio, CanyonWren, Nebraskablue, Rabbithead, weltshmertz, notrouble, Partisan Progressive, ScientistSteve, velvet blasphemy, earicicle, BlueInRedCincy, mkor7, CamillesDad1, JesseCW, Daily Activist, Mercuriousss, marzook, MKSinSA, TheOpinionGuy, ZilV, aj2k, Lopez99, jazzence, obscuresportsquarterly, The BBQ Chicken Madness, Keith Pickering, IreGyre, sfarkash, sherijr, fernan47, northernlights, nancat357, Bene Gesserit1, mahakali overdrive, spicecakes69, Livvy5, Randtntx, deviant24x, gaspi, Larsstephens, coppercelt, BrighidG, mamamorgaine, The Distillery, rb137, marabout40, miss SPED, The Jester, amk for obama, jethrock, piers, Prairie Gal, aquarius2001, zaynabou, Ann T Bush, LeftyAce, legalchic, Jersey Jon, 2questions, appledown, BonnieSchlitz, Garfnobl, melpomene1, samanthab, elginblt, ItsSimpleSimon, HartfordTycoon, axel000, j b norton, cai, WattleBreakfast, Funkygal, Betty Pinson, alethea, MsGrin, northLondonLiberal, science nerd, wwjjd, HylasBrook, cherylm, slice, Joe Hills Ghost, Onomastic, Empehi1961, allenjo, ozsea1, coquiero, StateofEuphoria, Gracian, Stella 4 Obama, sowsearsoup, Meggie, wildlife advocate, crtconsu, wahine, La Gitane, BlueJessamine, m00finsan, the national gadfly, BlackQueen40, QuestionAuthority, Bluerall, FarWestGirl, Sand Hill Crane, tresgatos, Jed Lewison, semctydem, grannysally, Cinnamon Rollover, theone718, DruidQueen, slooterdam, JWK, teloPariah, floridablue, evilgalblues, merrily1000, MRA NY, enhydra lutris, Crider, mali muso, PhilJD, stevie avebury, wide eyed lib, mfprtoo, blue aardvark, Miggles, just another vortex, Book of Hearts, jhw22, StepLeftStepForward, DRo, Regina in a Sears Kit House, Eric Jaffa, jaebone, ChiTownDenny, Eposter, MichaelNY, PrometheusUnbound, Dakit, NightOwl40, YaNevaNo, bearette, Han Shot First, livingthedream, pantherq, Patric Juillet, mod2lib, wolfie1818, jxf011, Just Keep it Simple Stupid, Flying Goat, Hookah, OHknighty, oblios arrow, Siri, We Won, IndieGuy, AkronLibertarian, J Brunner Fan, a2nite, Socratic Method, Janetrhodes

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site