Skip to main content

I really can't add anything to this but to say, I agree.

Via Progressive Review

A letter from David Reber, who teaches high school biology in Lawrence KS.

Mr. Duncan,

I read your Teacher Appreciation Week letter to teachers, and had at first decided not to respond. Upon further thought, I realized I do have a few things to say.

I'll begin with a small sample of relevant adjectives just to get them out of the way: condescending, arrogant, insulting, misleading, patronizing, egotistic, supercilious, haughty, insolent, peremptory, cavalier, imperious, conceited, contemptuous, pompous, audacious, brazen, insincere, superficial, contrived, garish, hollow, pedantic, shallow, swindling, boorish, predictable, duplicitous, pitchy, obtuse, banal, scheming, hackneyed, and quotidian. Again, it's just a small sample; but since your attention to teacher input is minimal, I wanted to put a lot into the first paragraph.

Your lead sentence, "I have worked in education for much of my life", immediately establishes your tone of condescension; for your 20-year "education" career lacks even one day as a classroom teacher. You, Mr. Duncan, are the poster-child for the prevailing attitude in corporate-style education reform: that the number one prerequisite for educational expertise is never having been a teacher.

Your stated goal is that teachers be "...treated with the dignity we award to other professionals n society."


How many other professionals are the last ones consulted about their own profession; and are then summarily ignored when policy decisions are made? How many other professionals are so distrusted that sweeping federal legislation is passed to "force" them to do their jobs? And what dignities did you award teachers when you publicly praised the mass firing of teachers in Rhode Island?

You acknowledge teacher's concerns about No Child Left Behind, yet you continue touting the same old rhetoric: "In today’s economy, there is no acceptable dropout rate, and we rightly expect all children -- English-language learners, students with disabilities, and children of poverty -- to learn and succeed."

What other professions are held to impossible standards of perfection? Do we demand that police officers eliminate all crime, or that doctors cure all patients? Of course we don't.

There are no parallel claims of "in today's society, there is no acceptable crime rate", or "we rightly expect all patients -- those with end-stage cancers, heart failure, and multiple gunshot wounds -- to thrive into old age." When it comes to other professions, respect and common sense prevail.

Your condescension continues with "developing better assessments so [teachers] will have useful information to guide instruction..." Excuse me, but I am a skilled, experienced, and licensed professional. I don't need an outsourced standardized test -- marketed by people who haven't set foot in my school -- to tell me how my students are doing.

I know how my students are doing because I work directly with them. I learn their strengths and weaknesses through first-hand experience, and I know how to tailor instruction to meet each student's needs. To suggest otherwise insults both me and my profession.

You want to "...restore the status of the teaching profession..." Mr. Duncan, you built your career defiling the teaching profession. Your signature effort, Race to the Top, is the largest de-professionalizing, demoralizing, sweeter-carrot-and-sharper-stick public education policy in U.S. history. You literally bribed cash-starved states to enshrine in statute the very reforms teachers have spoken against.

You imply that teachers are the bottom-feeders among academics. You want more of "America's top college students" to enter the profession. If by "top college students" you mean those with high GPA's from prestigious, pricey schools then the answer is simple: a five-fold increase in teaching salaries.

You see, Mr. Duncan, those "top" college students come largely from our nation's wealthiest families. They simply will not spend a fortune on an elite college education to pursue a 500% drop in socioeconomic status relative to their parents.

You assume that "top" college students automatically make better teachers. How, exactly, will a 21-year-old, silver-spoon-fed ivy-league graduate establish rapport with inner-city kids? You think they’d be better at it than an experienced teacher from a working-class family, with their own rough edges or checkered past, who can actually relate to those kids? Your ignorance of human nature is astounding.

As to your concluding sentence, "I hear you, I value you, and I respect you"; no, you don't, and you don't, and you don't. In fact, I don't believe you even wrote this letter for teachers.

I think you sense a shift in public opinion. Parents are starting to see through the façade; and recognize the privatization and for-profit education reform movement for what it is. And they've begun to organize --Parents Across America, is one example.

. . . No doubt some will dismiss what I've said as paranoid delusion. What they call paranoia I call paying attention. Mr. Duncan, teachers hear what you say. We also watch what you do, and we are paying attention.

Working with kids every day, our baloney-detectors are in fine form. We've heard the double-speak before; and we don't believe the dog ate your homework. Coming from children, double-speak is expected and it provides important teachable moments. Coming from adults, it's just sad.

Despite our best efforts, some folks never outgrow their disingenuous, manipulative, self- serving approach to life. Of that, Mr. Duncan, you are a shining example.

Originally posted to Happy Rockefeller on Wed May 25, 2011 at 08:13 PM PDT.

Also republished by Teachers Lounge and The Amateur Left.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

maxomai, Thumb, Tookish, Grassroots Mom, Alumbrados, davej, paradox, Ed in Montana, Susan S, Doug in SF, Mimikatz, John Chapman, Sylv, DeminNewJ, coral, RF, Jack K, filkertom, itsbenj, thinkdouble, grollen, copymark, dalemac, teacherken, Killer, DawnG, assyrian64, El Zmuenga, Better Days, Ivan, cedubose, Don Quixote, bob in ny, No Preference, peggy, GreenSooner, badger, Gooserock, TrueBlueMajority, Dave the Wave, tiponeill, Reino, janinsanfran, Bob Love, Sprinkles, TechBob, tommurphy, Shockwave, wu ming, Caniac41, m maddog, Wintermute, tacet, VetGrl, primeq, celdd, saluda, xynz, Duncan Idaho, verasoie, HootieMcBoob, kdub, LeftHandedMan, upstate NY, devtob, WI Deadhead, Matilda, DrSpike, Just Saying, Jerome a Paris, expatjourno, hubcap, lady sisyphus, niemann, dweb8231, Heart of the Rockies, chipoliwog, cinnamon68, opinionated, EvieCZ, Mr Teem, thm, JohnInWestland, Babsnc, afox, pmcmscot, mmacdDE, magnetics, AikidoPilgrim, OCD, Agathena, bluesteel, Xapulin, stevej, mkfarkus, gakke, mrblifil, markmatson, Aquarius40, rabel, farmerhunt, Frederick Clarkson, bobinson, slatsg, chlduvth70s, Clues, marylrgn, standingup, sngmama, jalbert, mollyd, Dracowyrm, Calprof, egarratt, Bill Roberts, Nate Roberts, fumie, Jesterfox, Recluse, Cedwyn, dylanfan, high uintas, admiralh, CoConut, Oh Dannyboy, Eddie C, wader, nio, revsue, suzq, Braindead, slippytoad, scorpiorising, Dube, Getreal1246, Eric Blair, liz dexic, diane101, mrkvica, Dr Colossus, DeadB0y, figbash, 2laneIA, QuarterHorseDem, dmsmith, kdrivel, Viola Lee, johanus, dubyus, duncanidaho, JimWilson, Bulldawg, BMarshall, downandout, CarbonFiberBoy, DSC on the Plateau, dwahzon, chap, houyhnhnm, TX Scotia, Calidrissp, raster44, rlharry, lcrp, riverlover, dumpster, alizard, faithnomore, MeToo, inclusiveheart, barbwires, cevad, dkmich, One bite at a time, FlyingToaster, parkslopper50, zerelda, mungley, lonespark, Wife of Bath, Deward Hastings, ScienceMom, Steven D, jcrit, TheOrchid, SadieB, Black Max, bronxdem, lyvwyr101, rickeagle, homogenius, vacantlook, wezelboy, AaronBa, Limelite, bay of arizona, spokanian, My Philosophy, wolverinethad, lalo456987, sawgrass727, kmbaya, dvx, tami33, p a roberson, rapala, nailbender, Skennet Boch, lcs, tovan, maybeeso in michigan, historys mysteries, Bluesee, sandblaster, Simian, BadgerGirl, 3goldens, Tinfoil Hat, ManOnTheBench, RaveON, NoMoreLies, denise b, Ckntfld, Sparkalepsy, rimstalker, qofdisks, caul, vinylgirl, greatferm, JanetT in MD, Independent Musings, Alice Marshall, chimene, democracy inaction, Cook, OpherGopher, irate, Technowitch, sc kitty, PBen, Philoguy, Alice Venturi, willibro, WellstoneDem, run around, grimjc, robinwave, caliberal2001, arch, basquebob, TN yellow dog, dewtx, stagemom, david78209, YucatanMan, fireflynw, Laurence Lewis, Kevskos, madmommy, ratzo, fixxit, Spoc42, Chaoslillith, bleeding blue, The Grace Kelly, jimreyn, McMeier, ladybug53, elbamash, Burned, cassidy3, Ice Blue, Steve in Urbana, markdd, babatunde, bjedward, Sandino, bluescrubs, minidriver, petestern, WisePiper, Ginny in CO, Aint Supposed to Die a Natural Death, neroden, coolbreeze, LivesInAShoe, Balachan, Rogneid, daddybunny, MrWebster, Lindy, JanL, SocioSam, Indiana Bob, Arsenic, mightymouse, xanthippe2, Blue Bronc, Snud, zozie, ChuckInReno, xaxnar, splashoil, jiml, accumbens, Jim P, begone, SoulCatcher, Roger Mexico, occams hatchet, LeftOverAmerica, K S LaVida, esquimaux, golfervet, kumaneko, tarheelblue, 417els, BlueInARedState, tobendaro, BeadLady, Russgirl, Malachite, HoundDog, rl en france, Yellow Canary, liberalconservative, technomage, Samwoman, fromer, bluebrain, Albatross, arlene, anastasia p, luckydog, sailmaker, jwhitmill, kck, blueoasis, Alexandra Lynch, LihTox, DarkestHour, MJ via Chicago, erratic, HairyTrueMan, Bradlaugh, A Siegel, gpoutney, gooderservice, SadieSue, paul2port, Doctor Frog, real world chick, katrinka, Sagebrush Bob, Preston S, steep rain, Jjc2006, totallynext, Unitary Moonbat, dirtfarmer, hlsmlane, anninla, mikebailey2000, Turbonerd, onionjim, SingerInTheChoir, Pete Rock, IL clb, JugOPunch, Sardanicas, Unknown Quantity, profh, doingbusinessas, fiddlingnero, means are the ends, frankzappatista, zedaker, shaharazade, amini1, bstotts, thatvisionthing, Elasg, Temmoku, lemonsieur, AllanTBG, sasher, illusionmajik, OHdog, Pandoras Box, NonnyO, AntKat, DBunn, seabos84, tegrat, ammasdarling, pale cold, One Pissed Off Liberal, Sapere aude, pgm 01, threesmommy, Cali Techie, anotherdemocrat, Ken in MN, jessical, wa ma, Russ Jarmusch, SpecialKinFlag, drmah, jhecht, AdamSelene, Debs2, Castine, devis1, scienceworm, ColoTim, Margfh, gailwax, linkage, threegoal, Van Buren, DvCM, wildweasels, yowsta, david mizner, HeartlandLiberal, terabytes, Calvin Jones and the 13th Apostle, sfbob, dissonantdissident, MonsterSound, Webster Hodges, aliasalias, Strabo, Swill to Power, HCKAD, rivamer, akdude6016, letsgetreal, cyncynical, Uberbah, rontripp, millwood, Moderation, hopi13, Librarianmom, CT Hank, Rumarhazzit, word player, conniptionfit, Zydekos, janatallow, keikekaze, eyesoars, cloudbustingkid, TeacherH, Don midwest, ByTor, craiger, South Park Democrat, cville townie, JDWolverton, gundyj, darrow, kimoconnor, hulagirl, kingneil, nderaney, spacejam, Senor Unoball, Foundmyvoice, Fossil, cindymutti, dave1042, crescentdave, bythesea, LI Mike, ozkid, elwior, theunreasonableHUman, Cat Servant, filby, slapper95, Sharon Wraight, Akonitum, KJG52, Calamity Jean, Lujane, TomFromNJ, Ocelopotamus, madame damnable, icebergslim, Jake Williams, MsWings, Jeff Y, Tam in CA, etoipi, mofembot, Seamus D, S C B, royalscam, Gemina13, GayDemInRedDistrict, makettle, DixieDishrag, BYw, Executive Odor, HarpboyAK, priceman, Nica24, rodentrancher, Robobagpiper, SpiffPeters, grsplane, gsenski, lissablack, squarewheel, gmgl, ggwoman55, lostboyjim, Leftleaner, legendmn, LaFeminista, dirtdawg, Fiddlegirl, Design the Future, bluebelle7, prettygirlxoxoxo, multilee, Rhysling, artmartin, cybrestrike, MufsMom, J M F, weaponsofmassdeception, DontTaseMeBro, arendt, Rick Aucoin, ceebee7, divineorder, The Dead Man, juca, radmul, Boudicia Dark, jaf49, Mislead, Randy Odom, Methinks They Lie, Partisan Progressive, Zotz, CamillesDad1, JesseCW, bekosiluvu, EquationDoc, unspeakable, Perry the Imp, obiterdictum, borndem, oxfdblue, ZilV, Shelley99, Keith Pickering, KenInCO, Northern Light, SnowItch, sfarkash, Knarfc, Andhakari, jfromga, ohmyheck, Dragon5616, schnecke21, Maori, Skex, beeninthewoods, Hamlets Father, not this time, Railfan, Amber6541, confitesprit, p gorden lippy, David PA, stegro, roadbear, brunoboy, Susan Grigsby, piers, boriquasi, biggiefries, Houses in Motion, lorla, freeport beach PA, Things Come Undone, plankbob, sunny skies, Simple, Garfnobl, Eddie L, Klaus, ipaman, Focusmarker, 888, ctlrick, Kristina40, DiegoUK, Earth Ling, Chris Purcell, jazzbuff, Patina Gal, Funkygal, Muggsy, Preset, 4kedtongue, Texnance, Betty Pinson, martini drinking atheist, farbuska, roystah, DrTerwilliker, Otteray Scribe, annie em, dalkman, Jack Pine Savage, nosleep4u, fiercefilms, not4morewars, bluestatedem84, not2plato, deli lama, ciganka, Eric0125, Barbara Marquardt, Jasel, agrenadier, mock5, Oldowan, sparkycom, nicethugbert, wildlife advocate, vahana, MaizeandBlue, gbinwc, poorbuster, FarWestGirl, twindad9, yakimagrama, leolamort, bookgirl, mujr, Civil Writes Activist, emilymac, baybelletrist, Outraged Mom, cama2008, boophus, boomerchick, mrsgoo, BaxKen, Ace Nelson, Cinnamon, thomask, dle2GA, slooterdam, muddy boots, KVoimakas, RfrancisR, moldyfolky, Grandma Susie, Faeya Wingmother, jgnyc, Vtdblue, peregrine kate, yaque, phiddle, poliwrangler, Wood Dragon, VTCC73, Caddis Fly, Marihilda, James Protzman, Stonepounder, joey c, jolux, SteelerGrrl, Sunspots, Ezekial 23 20, joanbrooker, StratCat, aerie star, Mentatmark, T100R, PrometheusUnbound, drawingporno, too young to give up, No one gets out alive, stripbubbles, Azazello, Mathazar, Dom9000, BlueDragon, YaNevaNo, livingthedream, quill, jacey, StarbuckAGTM, stormicats, justme2122, Whimsical Rapscallion, Flying Goat, DeanNC, ursoklevar, Malvern, IndieGuy, LefseBlue, Trevin, nellgwen, rustypatina, AlecMN, barkingcat, a2nite, Deep Texan, Ginger1, FreeSpeaker, drnononono, IProfess, s l o w loris, Graff, peachcreek, Forward is D not R, belinda ridgewood, connecticutie, pot, SierraDrinker, BobSmith415, supercereal, Karelin, geojumper, beefydaddy18, brainsqueeze, Arahahex, ClutchCargo, qannabbos, absolute beginner, lunachickie, QuietLight, BuzzLightyear235, splintersawry, Maikeru Ronin, AverageJoe42, bigrivergal, BlueConvert, Kayjay, DarkLadyNyara, maf1029, BradyB, buckybadger1988, Australian2, CalBearMom, WheninRome, Flecked Carbon, Iris Fancier, CA wildwoman

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site