Skip to main content

Doing a Michigan judge-drawn map might seem like an academic exercise since the state lege and governorship are both Republican.  But, one of the underlying assumptions embodied in the Republican map is that you can't draw two VRA districts contained wholly within Wayne County, forcing more than one district to dip into Oakland County from Wayne.  Well, it's wrong, and the proposed GOP map violates Michigan state law.  It may not be pretty, but you can draw two VRA districts without leaving Wayne County.  Now, the Michigan Supreme Court is 4-3 Republican so it might not rule in Team Blue's favor.  But the judges might be forced to redraw the map, so below is what a nonpartisan effort would look like:

CD1: Dan Benishek (R)
Upper Penninsula/Northern Michigan
2008: Obama 49.6-48.6
Avg: Republican 55-45

The First District is mostly the same in my map and the GOP map.  And like the old First District, this one narrowly went for Obama.  Considering how rural areas have moved away from Democrats, this is probably lean Republican for the decade.  

CD2: Bill Huizenga (R) and Fred Upton (R)
Western Michigan
2008: McCain 51-1-47.1
Avg: Republican 63.2-36.8

Historically it's the most Republican district in the state, and McCain only got 51% here.  It's probably safe Republican unless Sharron Angle runs.  Fred Upton and Bill Huizenga both live in this district and a faceoff between the two would probably shape up as establishment (Upton) vs. teabagger (Huizenga).  Tim Walberg lives in the new 6th, and the 7th is open but it leans Democratic so a move by either would be unlikely.  Thus, this might actually force Blll Huizenga into the race against Debbie Stabenow since Upton wouldn't leave his chairmanship.  

CD3: Justin Amash (R)
Grand Rapids Metro Area
2008: McCain 49.5-48.8
Avg: Republican: 62.5-37.5

Amash doesn't have to take on Battle Creek in this map (unlike the proposed Republican map), staying entirely within the Grand Rapids metro area.  It's still likely Republican; Amash actually seems like he might have some crossover appeal because he doesn't toe the party line all the time.  Still, Democrats might Gerald Ford their way into Gerald Ford's old seat if Amash missteps.

CD4: Dave Camp (R)
Central Michigan
2008: Obama 50.9-47.3
Avg: Republican 57.2-42.8

Dems should at least try to see if Dave Camp is vulnerable under this map.  The Republicans knocked off committee chairs Jim Oberstar, Ike Skelton and John Spratt last year (thought only Oberstar was in a lean D district).  Camp hasn't faced a serious challenger in a long time, and Dems should at least see if he still has his sea legs in a district that still takes in most of Central Michigan but looks much more compact.  

CD5: Dale Kildee (D)
Flint-Saginaw-Bay City
2008: Obama 62.5-35.9
Avg: Democratic 55.4-44.6

Kildee has held this Roger & Me-based seat for decades now, and he should continue to hold it under this iteration.  It's basically the same as the CD5 in the current plan (.7% less Democratic)

CD6: Tim Walberg (R)
Southern Michigan
2008: Obama 53.7-44.6
Avg: Republican 55.4-44.6

Schauer-Walberg round 3?  Both live in this version of the district.  Mark Schauer might also try moving to Lansing to the new open CD7.  He was a state legislator and grad student there for a significant period.  As the district average shows, Obama probably overperformed here because John McCain pulled out of the state.  Still, I'd rate it a toss-up if Schauer enters the race, Lean Republican if he doesn't.  Of note, Walberg barely lives in this district; Tipton is on the border with new CD8.

CD7: Open
Lansing Metro Area
2008: Obama 57.3-41.1
Avg: Republican 53.1-46.8

That average makes me hesitate a bit in calling this a Democratic district, but there aren't many Republicans who could win a seat in a presidential year where John McCain only pulled in 41%.  Republicans have cracked up the Lansing area in the past 2 gerrymanders to protect Mike Rogers, but this map would reunite it.  Maybe Virg Bernero runs here, banking on "I shouldn't have voted for Rick Snyder" support.

CD8: Mike Rogers
Detroit Exurbs
2008: McCain 50.4-47.9
Avg: Republican 61.2-38.8

Rogers probably has this district locked down for now, but as suburbs trend Democratic this might be contestable by the end of the decade.  This takes in a few rural areas, but mostly consists of exurbs.  Thad McCotter might be tempted to eat some cat fud and run here because his old CD11 is virtually unwinable in this map.

CD9: Gary Peters (D) and Sander Levin (D)
Oakland County
2008: Obama 63.6-35.2
Avg: Democratic 52.3-47.7

Even under this map, Levin and Peters (who do live close to each other) are thrown together.  Levin lives closer to the Macomb County line and has represented portions of the new CD12 before, but it's unclear if he's willing to stomach a tough re-electon fight while he's in his 80s.  I doubt Peters would move to the new CD12 as well, since he said he might run for Oakland County executive.  My guess is Steve Israel asks Peters to move next door, but considering that most of his old district remains intact he probably stays and fights.

CD10: Open
Thumb and Exurbs
2008: McCain 51.6-46.5
Avg: Republican 62.2-37.8

Candice Miller technically lives over the border in the new CD12, but she probably runs in her old CD10, which retains much of her old territory and is probably a safe seat absent a Macaca moment.

CD11: Thad McCotter (R)
Wayne County suburbs and Ann Arbor
2008: Obama 61.5-36.8
Avg: Democratic 51.7-48.3

McCotter might try to stick it out, but he'd have to run up against the buzzsaw that is John Dingell, who represents much of this area already and barely lives over the line in CD14.  McCotter could run for Senate, which I welcome since Stu Rothernberg basically said he's a dumb jerk who only got this seat because of his powerful mother.  Better yet, he could run for president!  Also, while researching where McCotter lived (part of Livonia is in CD14) I found out that his address is on Golfview Lane.  How fucking Republican is that?

CD12: Candice Miller (R)
Macomb County
2008: Obama 54.7-43.5
Avg: Republican 52-48

With Miller moving to CD10, this becomes a targeted open seat.  The lower spread between Obama and the average indicates that this seat is home to a lot of Reagan Democrats, and probably leans Democratic ancestrally.  Further, the bluing of the suburbs should help future performance.  I wouldn't write off Republicans here, but a Dave Bonior-type could lock this seat down.  Speaking of which, what's Dave Bonior up to these days?

CD13: Hansen Clarke (D) and John Conyers (D)
Detroit: South and East
50.2% AA VAP
2008: Obama 81.4-17.7
Avg: Democratic 71.9-28.1

Conyers, if he's got the stomach for another campaign, probably runs next door even though he lives in Highland Park.  I told you it wouldn't be pretty creating to Wayne County-only VRA districts, but I pulled it off with a few-hundred AA voters to spare.  This district also takes in Detroit's Latino neighborhoods, making its white VAP only 37.9%

CD14: John Dingell (D)
Detroit: North and West
50.4% AA VAP
2008: Obama 77-21.9
Avg: Democratic 67-33

Conyers probably runs here, but I wonder if he can get out of a primary considering his ethical lapses and all the new voters in this district.  He's not quite Clay Davis, but his appeal is probably limited on the suburbs.  Michael Moore is his homeboy, though, so that might help among white liberals.


So there's what a nonpartisan map would look like.  There's no telling what the Michigan Supremes would ultimately hand down, but this would be a good jumping-off point.  Further, even though Michigan is a Dem-leaning state, the map still puts a thumb on the scale for Republicans.  Dems only have five safe seats (CD5, CD9, CD11, CD13 and CD14) and two that lean their way (CD7 and CD12).  Meanwhile, the only Republican seat where Dems would have a shot most years would be CD6 (especially since Walberg is an ideologue) but 8-6 should be the norm in Michigan, not a good year for Democrats.

Love this diary?  Hate this diary?  Follow me on Twitter @Bobby_BigWheel.  Some politics, mostly sports.

Originally posted to Bobby Big Wheel on Tue Jun 21, 2011 at 05:44 AM PDT.

Also republished by Michigan, My Michigan.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

  •  Not this map, exactly... (0+ / 0-)
    Further, even though Michigan is a Dem-leaning state, the map still puts a thumb on the scale for Republicans. is the population structure, the fact that Democrats are more concentrated (mostly in urban areas) than Republicans are that puts the thumb on the scale.

    By the way, I can't see your maps. The links return a msg, "This XML file has no style data" or something similar.

    Mark E. Miller // Kalamazoo Township Trustee // MI 6th District Democratic Chair

    by memiller on Tue Jun 21, 2011 at 06:16:57 AM PDT

  •  Don't see courts going for your 11th (0+ / 0-)

    otherwise it looks pretty good. I think your VRA districts would probably face retrogression suits though being just so barely over 50.0% VAP.

  •  I Like The Concept, But Fear.... (1+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:

    That it will never be used. I agree with your opening paragraph. I think the MI Supreme Court upholds the legislature's gerrymander of the state.

    After all, watching the WI Supreme Court argue that an obvious violation of the open meeting law somehow WASN'T a violation of the open meeting law, I don't have a lot of faith in the application of law by a state Supreme Court.

    "Every one is king when there's no one left to pawn"
    Black Rebel Motorcycle Club

    by Steve Singiser on Tue Jun 21, 2011 at 07:00:11 AM PDT

  •  Your maps also violate the redistricting standards (0+ / 0-)

    The integrity of municipality boundaries is just as protected as the integrity of county boundaries.

    And unfortunately, by "just as protected", I mean "not protected at all". Last cycle, the Michigan Supreme Court ruled that the standards can't be held as binding upon the legislature. This is because the redistricting standards are statuatory and redistricting plans are statuatory. The plan as the newer law obsoletes the standards as older law rather than violating them.

    However, your intrepid example showing the general parameters of two truly majority African-American districts in Wayne County inspired me to create this:

    That map conforms with the standards and produces two majority African-American by VAP districts. Together, the two districts are majority African-American by VAP by about 100 people. Collectively, the three districts are within 59 people of ideal; the highest deviation is -166. The blue district includes all of Monroe County.

    I can post more stats is people want them later, (and will probably post a full-state diary based off that configuration sometime soon (probably after I finally get around to the state senate district analysis I promised a few days ago)) but I need to get to bed.

    Thanks again for your discovery!

    Also, the code to insert images is

    (img src="")

    with the URL of your link between the quotation marks and the parentheses replaced with carets.

    30, male, MI-11 (previously VA-08). Evangelical, postconservative, green.

    by borodino21 on Tue Jun 21, 2011 at 09:17:23 PM PDT

  •  I think that we could elect a Dem up here in (1+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    Ana Thema

    the Upper Peninsula/District 1 but it'd have to be the right Dem.

    Someone who could stir anger against the banks and actually do something about jobs (or promise as much) would probably go a long way towards a Dem. Stupak was up here for years....

    Republicans cause more damage than guns ever will. Share Our Wealth

    by KVoimakas on Wed Jun 22, 2011 at 02:22:00 AM PDT

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site