Skip to main content

Holy Name Cathedral
Holy Name Cathedral in Chicago, IL
(Gerald Farinas/Wikicommons)
New York Times visits the topic of Catholic Charities shutting down their foster care and adoption services in Illinois after the state passed civil unions bill for LGBT couples. After a long and nasty fight, they reached an endgame on the question of whether Catholic Charities can enjoy state subsidies while denying services. The state told the Church no, the Church fought mightily in court, but finally threw in the towel and dropped the lawsuit, amid rumors it was too expensive.

Laurie Goodstein visits the ongoing "debate" if discriminating against LGBT people is an essential component of religious express, and whether LGBT discrimination is a constitutionally protected right. The New York Times chooses an unfortunate, and inaccurate frame for its headline: "For Bishops, a Battle Over Whose Rights Prevail." The implication being the Church has a "right" to state-funded social services contracts. If the state does not award a contract to any organization, have their "rights" have been violated? Cue the whining of the powerful, wealthy and entitled:

For the nation’s Roman Catholic bishops, the outcome is a prime example of what they see as an escalating campaign by the government to trample on their religious freedom while expanding the rights of gay people. The idea that religious Americans are now the victims of government-backed persecution is now a frequent theme not just for Catholic bishops, but also for Republican presidential candidates and conservative evangelicals.

“In the name of tolerance, we’re not being tolerated,” said Bishop Thomas J. Paprocki of the Diocese of Springfield, Ill., a civil and canon lawyer who helped drive the church’s losing battle to retain its state contracts for foster care and adoption services

I'll stop Bishop Paprocki right there.

This not about "tolerating" views.

This is all about the money.

I refer the Bishop to the preceding paragraph (emphasis mine):

But now most of the Catholic Charities affiliates in Illinois are closing down rather than comply with a new requirement that says they can no longer receive state money if they turn away same-sex couples as potential foster care and adoptive parents.

The heart of the matter is the Roman Catholic Church collects lots and lots of taxpayer dollars, in Illinois and across the country, to perform social services on the government's behalf, like placing kids in foster care and adoption. These are services paid for by all Americans, including LGBT citizens' dollars.

The Catholic Church wishes to retain its rights to dole out their taxpayer-funded services only to some of the people who are funding these services. Sorry, that's not fair.

Which was the experience of one person quoted in the article:

Tim Kee, a teacher in Marion, Ill., who was turned away by Catholic Charities three years ago when he and his longtime partner, Rick Wade, tried to adopt a child, said: “We’re both Catholic, we love our church, but Catholic Charities closed the door to us. To add insult to injury, my tax dollars went to provide discrimination against me.”

And despite their protestations this is a "religious freedom" issue for the Church, it's easy to conclude this issue is really all about the money for them as well.

These contracts are very big money-makers for the Church, from the Times (again emphasis mine):

Catholic Charities is one of the nation’s most extensive social service networks, serving more than 10 million poor adults and children of many faiths across the country. It is made up of local affiliates that answer to local bishops and dioceses, but much of its revenue comes from the government. Catholic Charities affiliates received a total of nearly $2.9 billion a year from the government in 2010, about 62 percent of its annual revenue of $4.67 billion. Only 3 percent came from churches in the diocese (the rest came from in-kind contributions, investments, program fees and community donations).
Of those 10 million people they serve, they wish retain the right to not serve any LGBT people.

But LGBT people pay taxes too. Actually, it turns out, more than their fair share, according to a recent CNN/Money magazine article. And LGBT people should have a right to obtain the services their tax dollars support. It really isn't that complicated.

And in fact in many jurisdictions, the Church could continue to fund discriminatory foster care and adoption services if the Church wished, just not subsidized by taxpayers. The Church would have to offer these services supported only by its own money. Oh, that's right, they're only willing to fund 3 percent of these endeavors with the Church's own money.

Apparently the Church's concern for children isn't so great they'd pay to fund placement services out of their own pocketbook. I guess that shouldn't surprise anyone, given the Church's record of concern for children.

It is truly sad to see the Catholic Church disengage itself from charitable endeavors in Illinois, and before in Massachusetts, and anywhere. But this is a choice they are making for themselves.

So they could fund the services themselves. Or they could relent, as a the Lutheran Church has done. Gene Svebakken, president and chief executive of the agency, Lutheran Child and Family Services of Illinois, has decided to abide by Illinois' directive, despite his Church's long-standing condemnation of gay people:

“We’ve been around 140 years, and if we didn’t follow the law we’d go out of business,” Mr. Svebakken said. “We believe its God-pleasing to serve these kids, and we know we do a good job.”

Society is evolving, but the Catholic Church is refusing to evolve with it. These states have chosen to recognize some of the basic civil rights of their LGBT citizens. They have also decided it is not legal or appropriate for a state to be funding discrimination against them.

Perhaps, someday the Catholic Church will catch up to the society that surrounds them. I hear they finally admitted Galileo was right about that crazy idea of the Earth orbiting the sun back in 1992.

Originally posted to Milk Men And Women on Wed Dec 28, 2011 at 01:11 PM PST.

Also republished by Friends of Keith Olbermann and Rachel Maddow and Daily Kos.

EMAIL TO A FRIEND X
Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags

?

More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

kos, Sharoney, Mike S, colleen, Alumbrados, Hunter, DeminNewJ, Bill in Portland Maine, itsbenj, MadRuth, teacherken, deben, glitterscale, SaveDemocracy, badger, artr2, tiponeill, Eman, LynChi, donna in evanston, m maddog, Wintermute, billlaurelMD, SanJoseLady, Jay C, jdld, xynz, devtob, freelunch, hnichols, Creosote, davelf2, scribe, entlord, opinionated, CatM, concernedamerican, Justina, bronte17, davechen, TracieLynn, annrose, whenwego, Ian S, KMc, Frederick Clarkson, jalbert, oceanview, MadEye, Iberian, splashy, Cedwyn, KathleenM1, sidnora, dksbook, TexDem, Miss Jones, ranger995, Steven Payne, Sychotic1, Calidrissp, Exurban Mom, FlyingToaster, mungley, lonespark, lyvwyr101, vacantlook, Josiah Bartlett, llellet, davidkc, joanneleon, ExStr8, unclejohn, OpherGopher, kitchen sink think tank, craigkg, dewtx, Brooke In Seattle, Laurence Lewis, eru, Viceroy, majcmb1, Gordon20024, skyounkin, Ice Blue, markdd, babatunde, Ginny in CO, mph2005, Rogneid, SocioSam, jct, fhcec, bently, occams hatchet, rserven, dannyinla, BachFan, Medium Head Boy, tung sol, Yellow Canary, kestrel9000, dougymi, NNadir, arlene, fou, blueoasis, wild hair, StrayCat, twigg, Bloke, agnostic, gooderservice, real world chick, JVolvo, middleagedhousewife, anninla, bumbi, a small quiet voice, fiddlingnero, kurt, Statusquomustgo, amini1, bstotts, blueintheface, AntKat, BentLiberal, krwheaton, Thinking Fella, old wobbly, pgm 01, bluicebank, Habitat Vic, Old Gardener, camlbacker, gailwax, gloriana, EdSF, psychodrew, Cofcos, terabytes, burlydee, DWG, sfbob, davehouck, bnasley, RosyFinch, jayden, martyinsfo, stcroix cheesehead, Rumarhazzit, leonard145b, Ralphdog, JeffW, wayoutinthestix, Steve15, Johnny Nucleo, dadadata, Bjorn in MN, bythesea, binkaroni, CDH in Brooklyn, Lujane, tofumagoo, MrJayTee, Jake Williams, Jeff Y, catly, Tam in CA, alnep, Seamus D, Horsefeathers, petulans, kempsternyc, makettle, LaEscapee, DixieDishrag, OrdinaryIowan, Karl Rover, ekyprogressive, DavidW, Tennessee Dave, oldliberal, legendmn, LaFeminista, J M F, spacecadet1, Mislead, weltshmertz, shopkeeper, Remediator, dRefractor, petral, MKSinSA, asym, CityLightsLover, schnecke21, jpmassar, porchdog1961, Larsstephens, Railfan, Amber6541, henlesloop, Broke And Unemployed, pyegar, FogCityJohn, TFinSF, ATFILLINOIS, Eddie L, DiegoUK, sharonsz, science nerd, Its a New Day, annieli, Maximilien Robespierre, kerflooey, kayak58, Bob Duck, Zooey Glass, cv lurking gf, cooper888, ontheleftcoast, CoExistNow, susanala, MasterfullyInept, IllanoyGal, BarackStarObama, Yogurt721, TRPChicago, enhydra lutris, Joe Hill PDX, foresterbob, sound of progress, Vatexia, ratcityreprobate, Nightshade Q, Chitown Kev, aerie star, Mentatmark, allergywoman, PrometheusUnbound, drawingporno, No one gets out alive, Mathazar, AnnetteK, jacey, Cordyc, anodnhajo, We Won, ahumbleopinion, oldcrow, S F Hippie, draa, JGibson, FreeSpeaker, Horace Boothroyd III, kait, belinda ridgewood, Syoho, the Don, Arahahex, absolute beginner, notdarkyet, sexgenderbody, tytalus, arizonablue, Wes Clark Democrat, Marjmar, maf1029, GoGoGoEverton, Jonathan Hoag, nomandates, koosah, The grouch, glorificus, Praxical

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site