Skip to main content

If, like me, you grew up watching Looney Tunes, then you grew up with Brahms.  

Most of the music in that cartoon comes from Brahms' Hungarian Dances.  Romantics in the mid-19th century decades became fascinated with different types of ethnic and world music.  They sought ways to exploit them for their own music.  In, of course, a Westernized Romantic way.  It's hard to listen to that and hear real Gypsy music, as firmly associated now, as it is, in our minds with Brahms.  And Looney Tunes.

More below, including the final two movements of the Brahms Symphony #1, which we started last week.

The Brahms Symphony #1 isn't in that ethnic mold, however, but in a Beethoven mold, the universal mold.  Brahms' allies had promoted him as the new Beethoven, and by implication, the un-Wagner.  This made Brahms uncomfortable not just because it raised expectations but because it made the composition of his first symphony a matter fraught with politics both musical and unmusical.  So he delayed, delayed, delayed, what everybody expected to be Beethoven's Tenth Symphony, and very nearly is.  It channels Beethoven to the extent of even musically quoting Beethoven in homage at key points, including a variation on the Ode to Joy theme from Beethoven's Ninth, which makes a striking appearance in the final movement as the main theme

The first time I heard this symphony, I didn't get a connection with Beethoven's Ninth, because I had never heard Beethoven's Ninth.  Much later, I heard Beethoven's Ninth for the first time.  When it got to the Ode to Joy part, I went, hummm... that reminds me of Brahms!  The direction arrow got reversed for me.

One reason I decided last week to skip the symphony I had promised and to go with the Brahms #1 is that I knew I would never have a better tee-up, using it as a followup to Schubert's Ninth and the Beethoven homage implicit in that, and the discussion of Berlioz's Beethovenian reaction/counter-reaction.  These three works, in particular, give us a better view of how drastically Beethoven raised everybody's game.

The format of the Brahms #1, for example, is based on the Beethoven "Triumph Symphony" model of Beethoven's Fifth Symphony, a model that we encounter again and again in post-Beethoven music.  The format of Beethoven's Fifth can be described thus:

1. First movement.  In a minor key.  Tragic but feisty.  The introduction contains short motifs that recur throughout the symphony as structural glue, especially at key moments.  The movement ends ominously.

2. and 3.  Second and third movements.  A slow movement and a scherzo/dance movement.  Nothing uniquely Beethoven about that, but in this formula the two movements use the motif of the first movement's introduction to remind us that they are part of an organic four movement musical message.  They serve the purpose of lowering the tension and providing contrast with the first movement.

4. Finale.  There is an ominous introduction returning us to the tense mood of the first movement.  It hints at the possibility that things could go very badly here.  Then suddenly we have a dramatic shift, and we have strong, courageous major key music.  It's as if we are passing a moral test.  The symphony ends in triumph over adversity.

I haven't just described Beethoven's Fifth or Brahms' First.  I've just described a whole big bunch of symphonies that came after Beethoven.

Well, jeez, Dumbo, you say.  If it's such a formula, then where's the creativity?  You make it sound as rigid as a Brady Bunch episode.  

Just because we have a formula within a genre of art doesn't mean the art using the formula isn't creative.  It's all in how its done.  Give Beethoven due credit for being the architect of form that he was.  But it is a great form that uses music in a more ambitious way than it had been used before.  It DEMANDS to be exploited!  Music as moral struggle!  How can you go back after that?

The nineteenth century would also see the invention of a counter formula to that, the dystopian symphony, the Tchaikovsky Pathetique Symphony #6 being the model.  Just like the Beethoven Fifth model, but, in the end, complete and utter devastation that leaves people walking out of the concert hall wishing they could eat a gun.  

Furtwangler's 1951 performance, above, of the final movement of Tchaikovsky's 6th.  I think I used Von Karajan when we did the diaries on Tchaikovsky's 6th.  I really wanted to use Furtwangler, because it's  so much more miserable,  but the audio quality was too poor.

Now, we could compare either of those two moral symphonies, Beethoven's Fifth, or Tchaikovsky's Sixth, to earlier pre-Beethoven symphonies.  For instance, the Mozart #40 in G minor ends rather tragically.  Is Mozart's Symphony #40 like the Pathetique?  Noooooo.  Not even close!  The message of Tchaikovsky's Pathetique is futile resistance to failure and death.  We can try to impose a Tchaikovsky-ish program on Mozart's #40, but that feels forced; Mozart composed pure music and it has to be judged that way.  We could also compare Beethoven's Fifth to Mozart's Symphony #41 in C, the Jupiter, with its monumental fugal conclusion.  But here too, Mozart is pure music.  His symphonies are not representations of moral combat in a four movement arc.

Brahms, particularly here, in his First Symphony, got that.  We're headed towards a dramatic showdown of light and darkness.  The stakes are high and the good guy's going to win.  


Yes, some very generous person has shown her support for my moral struggle by sending me a coffee cup.  One that met my very special needs, as I described in this pic:

So I am less pitiful tonight than I was last week.  Yay!  I'm gloating.

(I promised to post a pic but I can't because, as I just discovered, my camera batteries crudded up and I will need to clean the contacts.  The picture will have to be next week.)

So let's go to the music where we left off...

Brahms' Symphony #1 in C minor, Third movement, Un poco allegretto e grazioso (graceful and a little fast).  Jascha Horenstein conducting the London Symphony Orchestra.

The movement is in symmetrical ABACA form.  If the first theme sounds familiar, you might want to compare it to the oboe theme from the middle of the second movement.  They are very similar.

A section (0:00)

If the first theme, played here by the clarinet, sounds familiar, you might want to compare it to the oboe theme from the middle of the second movement.  They are very similar.  The mood here is very, very light and peaceful, to set up a contrast for the coming final movement.  ]

The woodwinds do most of the heavy lifting in this movement (and in the previous second movement as well).  Remember that the orchestra Brahms uses for this symphony is no larger than the normal Beethoven orchestra -- it just sounds bigger.  The woodwinds, in particular, cut through with a fantastic beauty and clarity in Brahms hands.  That's craftsmanship.  As good as Beethoven was with everything else, he was crappy with woodwinds.

Also, notice how the recurring motif of the symphony, three chromatic half-steps, shows up again in the harmony.  In Brahmsian style, it's buried in there so you have to pick it out.  

The three note chromatic half-step motif of Brahms Symphony #1.  Sometimes it goes down, sometimes it goes up.

I almost didn't make a graphic for this because it's hard to understand it if you do it in the right key, so I changed it to start at B and it made sense.  I don't do this so you can read the music or play it, but so you can VISUALLY SEE THE PATTERN.  I assume you're worse at reading music than I am, and I'm not very good at all.

As we recall, in the first movement, this motif showed up in the introduction as either three half-steps up or three half-steps down.  In this movement, he inserts three downward half-steps at 0:30, so subtly you wouldn't notice it unless you were looking for it.  A couple of bars later, at 0:40, he does it again, but with three half-steps upward.  Sneaky stuff, I know, but it allows us to enjoy the symphony at multiple levels, either as large scale drama or as musical tiddlywinks.

B Section (0:56)

We get a short contrasting minor key theme.

A Section again (1:22)
The A section returns again.  But it's very brief, and is even interrupted by...

C Section (1:36)

The C section breaks into it in midstride.  The rhythm changes here from 4/4 to 3/4.  You might think a changeover of rhythm like that would be more obvious, but thanks again to Brahms' craftsmanship, it's dovetailed in in a way you don't notice it happening!  So we have yet another fun listening game you can play with this movement: trying to find the rhythm changeovers.  

The A section is coming back, so we're going to have to go back to 4/4 soon.  Listen for how he does it at 2:53.

A Section again(3:07)

The main theme is back again, and we're back in 4/4.  The theme seems to have learned something along the way, because it is changed.  

Coda (3:48)

This movement, like all the other movements, has a coda.  In this case, a wistful look back.  The first theme, now more subdued, passes over to the 3/4 C section, which (to my ears) seems to be saying, "Goodbye!  It was nice meeting you all!"  

And so we come down to a very, very, very gentle landing for a very gentle movement, one that is deliberately gentle to set us up for the storminess of the on-coming finale.

-------------------- END OF THIRD MOVEMENT -----------

If you want to grab a cup of coffee, please do!  I don't want to have to drink alone!  I'm drinking Brazil Cerrado light roast from CBLT today.  Out of my special cup designed specifically for keeping me well-caffeinated and hyperkinetic while working on these dairies.

Brahms' Symphony #1 in C minor, Fourth movement, Adagio – Più andante – Allegro non troppo, ma con brio – Più allegro.  Jascha Horenstein conducting the London Symphony Orchestra.

As you can tell from the movement's tempo description above, there will be a few changes of mood and speed.  It's in Sonata-Allegro form, our favorite thing in the whole classical music world, yay.  We all mumble Exposition Development Recapitulation in our sleep, I'm sure.  I know I do. As a reminder, just in case, here's my graphic that saves me typing:

Dumbo's Handy-Dandy Blue Graphic

Introduction (0:00)

There is a very long introduction to this movement.  The introduction pulls us out of the warm rose-scented bathwater of the third movement and throws us into a bleak C Minor landscape familiar to us from the first movement, one we might have thought we had escaped.  We haven't heard anything from the timpani for two movements.  Right from the start, they are back.  The woodwinds that dominated the second and third movement are in retreat.  The organization of the intro is anarchic at first and filled with a sense of expectation of something terrible (or great) to come.

We begin the intro with a brief crescendo that immediately pulls back.  Slinks back.  

At 0:36, plucked strings give us an ominous chromatic theme, like someone sneaky tip-toeing up behind us.  It speeds up at the tail end, becoming a little frantic before suffering a setback.  At 1:24, again, it tiptoes upon us; again, it suffers a setback.  

Over the foreboding thrum of the basses, a new and even more distressed theme emerges.  It works its way up to a mini-climax.  At 2:21, the mini-climax -- three chromatic half-steps.  The recurring theme of the symphony.  We're at a turning point.  The drums punctuate the moment, and the orchestra fades away...

And now comes the greatest magical moment of the symphony, the great horn solo of the Brahms Symphony #1.  2:38.  A solo French horn intercedes, bringing us out of the darkness of C minor, into the light of C major with a theme full of hope and courage that he claimed to have heard an Alpine horn play.  "High on the hill, deep in the dale, I send you a thousand greetings!"  Brahms wrote.  We are pulled out of the despair of the introduction by this announcement, this turning point.

At 3:14, the horn theme passes to the flute.

At 3:56, the brass have a brief, religious-in-tone chorale like moment.  The solo horn then returns with the great horn theme.  (Earn a gold star if you can hear the three chromatic downward half-step motif in the harmony of it.)  With rumbling drums, it climaxes, and fades away, setting us up for...

Exposition First Theme (5:05)

The main theme of the movement.  And it's based on Beethoven's Ode to Joy, although Brahms isn't crass enough to just steal it without making it his own.  It has a dignity and majesty, like a graduation commencement march.  The strings carry it with great richness of texture (by using parallel thirds, if that kind of thing matters to you).  At 5:40 it passes to the woodwinds, who repeat it.

See if you can hear the three chromatic half-step motif in the harmony of the theme.  (Like, at 5:54).  

As the woodwinds come near the end of their restatement of the theme, the orchestral tension rises.  At 6:10, the theme passes now to the full orchestra, who throw away their staid bearing and let the theme burst out in mad joy, all the madder and more joyful for the long, long buildup we have had to this moment.  

At 6:43, we transition to G major, setting us up for...

Exposition Second Theme (6:53)

Actually a group of themes here, the first one, in the strings, at 6:53.  Then a second one in the oboes at 7:17, with the chromatic downward half-step motif in the harmony.

We get a third one at 7:37 in the strings.  If it sounds familiar, it's because it's based on the "distressed" music of the intro just before the horn solo came in.

At 8:14, this third theme works itself up towards a mini-climax to round off the exposition.  It's a little vague here, at the end of the exposition, whether we're ending in the sunny G major, or the darker E minor.  Brahms exploits this ambiguity to add to the drama of metaphorical moral conflict.  Who will win, the (metaphorical) good guys or the (metaphorical) bad guys?  

We finally end the exposition with a cadence in E minor.  Bad guys, I guess.

Development Section (8:54)

And with a quick transition, we are suddenly back in the home key of C major, and there's our main theme again, in its majestic form.  SOMETIMES, there will be a repeat of the exposition here in performances, and I think it actually benefits from it.  Whether they do or don't, the effect at this point, when the development starts, is we get the sense that we are back at the beginning of the exposition.  

Not so!  As we find out at 9:20, when this familiar theme changes course and changes key.  And begins to travel from key, to key.  Where are we going?  Dark notes try to sneak into our happy theme but they are shrugged off.  As the tension rises, the "madly joyous" version of the main theme returns to enter the fray.

At 10:18, we tumble down a hole, and through a whole bunch of different key changes.  This part is very Bach-like with complex counterpoint.  At 10:38, it seems to bottom out temporarily.  The tonality of the harmony has become gradually less stable as this development has gone along.  At 11:01, it becomes twisted and grotesque, reminiscent of the angular sharp-edgedness of the first movement.  

We're building towards the climax now.  It doesn't take much projection on my part, I don't think, to characterize this as a musical battle.  At 11:19, the brass come in fighting with a fragment of the main theme.

At 11:40, it becomes more dissonant and the tempo changes, becomes more broken.  The crisis is at hand.  

The Crisis  11:55, and we finally crash headfirst into an immovable barrier with a massively dissonant chord that brings all forward propulsion to a stop.  

This massively dissonant chord morphs.  It transforms itself into...  The beautiful horn solo theme!  It returns to rescue us yet again.  And we're back in the home key, finally, of warm, happy, C major.  

Recapitulation Second Theme Group Again (12:47)

The recapitulation skips the first theme, which we've heard quite a bit of, and goes straight to the second theme group.  It begins in a very subdued manner, unlike the boisterousness of its first appearance in the exposition.  I suppose it's a bit tuckered out from all the drama of the development.  But it regains its momentum and carries us through the rest of the themes, ending finally, at the very end, in C minor.

Coda (14:45)

C minor?  That's the bad guy key.  Who's (metaphorically) winning this (metaphorical) moral battle?  And so we enter the coda where we'll get final resolution on that.

The coda begins with a series of mystical sounding chords, changing the tone of things.

At 15:00, the main theme returns, or part of it, anyway.  But now it is in the deep bass, and there's a scary hungry growl to it.  It rises higher, higher, higher, the rest of the orchestra backing away from it fearfully.  The tension rises to new heights.

At 15:25, we break out into a full gallop, with the drums and brass leading the way.  We're building to a climax.  And...

At 15:40, the brass rise to ascendancy.  The religiously-toned chorale-like chords of the intro return, but with devastating climactic authority.  

Now that's a "Triumph Symphony" for you!

At 15:56, we begin the final gallop, heading for the big satisfying C major finish.  What a journey.

And we're done.

--------------------- THE END -----------------------

Next week: Next Thursday, June 28, Ramara's going to do a diary for us on Tchaikovsky's Piano Trio.  I'm going to be here, sipping coffee out of my triumph cup, reading it, just like you.  REMEMBER, to read it, look for the CMOPUS tag next week, or just a diary titled Thursday Classical Music, because it won't be under my name.  

The week after that, I'll be back with the Saint-Saens Symphony #3 in C minor, "The Organ Symphony."  I might be able to do that in one diary.

Originally posted to Dumbo on Thu Jun 21, 2012 at 09:52 PM PDT.

Also republished by DKOMA and Community Spotlight.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

  •  "The heartbeat of the universe" (9+ / 0-)

    is what one of my piano teachers called the first movement of this wonderful symphony.

    Barack Obama is not a secret Marxist class warrior who wants to redistribute wealth in America. But I'll still vote for him, anyway.

    by looty on Thu Jun 21, 2012 at 10:10:17 PM PDT

  •  Amazing diary (11+ / 0-)

    I know this work musically backwards and forwards, in the sense that I've heard it many times and if you play me a few seconds of it, I know exactly what's coming next.  What I did not know so well is how it is formally structured, so thank you for taking the time to teach me!  The pounding timps at 12:15 in mvt. 4 I always hear as an echo of the timpani strokes that open the symphony, but I recall that the slow opening to mvt. 1 was added later. Whatever the case may be, it works!

    Favorite recordings: Furtwangler/Hamburg (M&A), Jochum/Berlin (DG), Levine/Chicago (RCA).

    Thanks again!

    •  That may be deliberate. (6+ / 0-)

      In fact, I think it is now, now that you have me thinking about it.  I realize he composed the intro after the first movement, but that doesn't mean he didn't do spot welding back and forth between the movements.  That makes sense.

      The Furtwangler recording is good, better than the Horenstein, but not very good audio.  Since last week, I did some digging.  The Horenstein recording is on some lists among the top 3 recordings of the Brahms 1st, alongside Furtwangler and Klemperer's.  

      Furtwangler's recordings are so damn good, blowing the curve, it's starting to make me wonder if the whole musical conductor-world hasn't been in decay for some time.

    •  This was the first major work (4+ / 0-)
      Recommended by:
      Dumbo, seefleur, JeffSCinNY, JKTownsend

      that I remember my father explaining to me as a child. He imagined for me a little bird who had gotten trapped in a snare and was struggling to free itself, which it finally does in the end when it flies off triumphantly.

      It has always been one of my favorites and I have listened to it many hundreds of times without being aware of just how meticulously it had been crafted. Possessing no formal training, I just knew that it worked for me.

      So I join darkmatter in thanking Dumbo for adding for me a reason to listen with a whole new sense of awe to this astounding creation.

      I have become completely dependent on this series to start out my Friday mornings on the right foot.  Thank you Dumbo!

  •  Looking forward! (6+ / 0-)
    The week after that, I'll be back with the Saint-Saens Symphony #3 in C minor, "The Organ Symphony."
    I love it!!

    Join us at Bookflurries-Bookchat on Wednesday nights 8:00 PM EST

    by cfk on Thu Jun 21, 2012 at 10:52:31 PM PDT

  •  So glad you got a coffee cup, and sorry I didn't (4+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    Dumbo, ER Doc, ExStr8, JKTownsend

    help on that, but I don't read Morse Code, and I was kinda indisposed this past week.

    This is a very helpful analysis. I listened last night, and again tonight, following your guidelines, and I think you have helped me gain new insight into the structure and method Brahms used for impact. I could hear the Beethoven, too. Stirring and joyful 4th movement.

    I listened to the Tchaikovsky movement and had forgotten that he premiered it only nine days before he died. When I listened to it, I said to myself, that sounds like someone who just found out that he had syphilis and there was no cure for it. Poor Pyotr Ilyich. What a terrible way to go (I know, it wasn't syphilis, but you know what I mean).

    Loony Tunes--I hadn't seen that one in all these years since the 40s or whenever it came out. I am blessed to have many of the Hungarian Dances on that Erica Morini violin album, so I hear them without the cartoon fairly often.
    Thank you for a wonderful listening and reading experience.

    W. H. Auden: "We must love one another or die."

    by martyc35 on Fri Jun 22, 2012 at 12:27:57 AM PDT

  •  I'm a bass trombonist for a living... (8+ / 0-)

    and even though I have to get cold, waiting through three movements of "tacet" to play that first trombone chorale is SO worth it.

  •  Thanks again for this! N/T (5+ / 0-)

    -7.25, -6.26

    We are men of action; lies do not become us.

    by ER Doc on Fri Jun 22, 2012 at 05:09:38 AM PDT

  •  Thank you so much (6+ / 0-)

    His 4 symphonies are on my "desert island" list - I absolutely get lost in them all.

    So much of his music reminds me of an ocean beach, with the waves coming and going, varying in intensity, sometimes receding so quietly sometimes roaring in...but always so many layers of movement...

    What a lovely wakeup for the armadillo this morning and yes, a good cup of coffee to go with it too. :D

    And I agree about the woodwinds...they absolutely shine in his work.

    Beethoven was amazing but Brahams speaks to my soul.

    "one useless man is a shame, two is a law firm, and three or more is a congress" -- John Adams

    by blue armadillo on Fri Jun 22, 2012 at 06:49:47 AM PDT

  •  I know horn players that revere this almost as (3+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    Dumbo, martyc35, JKTownsend

    much as they revere Mahler.  And when you're in the middle of the orchestra and you hear five horn players just singing that out, your nipples get hard.

    "Nothing in all the world is more dangerous than sincere ignorance and conscientious stupidity." --M. L. King "You can't fix stupid" --Ron White -6.00, -5.18

    by zenbassoon on Fri Jun 22, 2012 at 08:33:35 AM PDT

  •  Thanks, Dumbo! (4+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    Dumbo, martyc35, seefleur, JKTownsend


    Mother Teresa: "If we have no peace, it is because we have forgotten that we belong to each other."

    by Amber6541 on Fri Jun 22, 2012 at 08:37:39 AM PDT

  •  Years ago, I, liking it immensely, composed (5+ / 0-)

    lyrics to go with that wonderful last theme.

    When darkness enfolds you
    And liberty's flame burns low
    When prison walls hold you
    And terror is all you know.
    Remember, the clouds will part and the night will end
       and the sun will rise again
    Remember, remember, my friend
    The dawn always comes!

    When hatred surrounds you
    And all of your hope is gone
    When cruelty astounds you
    And night stretches on and on
    Remember, a single spark,
       can ignite a flame, and that flame
    Can light the world.
    Remember, remember, my friend
    The dawn always comes!  

    Freedom has two enemies: Those who want to control everyone around them...and those who feel no need to control themselves.

    by Sirenus on Fri Jun 22, 2012 at 10:26:06 AM PDT

    •  That's nice. I rarely approve of lyrics written (2+ / 0-)
      Recommended by:
      Dumbo, JKTownsend

      where none were intended, but in my old age I have recently relented on a few. Currently, I enjoy some young Italian guys singing to words written to Saint-Saens The Swan from Carnival of the Animals. Most of the fan remarks on YT reveal that young fans have never heard of Saint-Saens and become confused by it being called The Swan when the lyrics are all starry night, etc. You may enjoy it:

      W. H. Auden: "We must love one another or die."

      by martyc35 on Fri Jun 22, 2012 at 11:33:11 AM PDT

      [ Parent ]

    •  I'm impressed by that. (2+ / 0-)
      Recommended by:
      JKTownsend, martyc35

      Those lyrics do fit the music magnificently.  I like the way "the sun will rise AGAIN" ends on that accented rising note.  That's very well done.

  •  Brahm's first (3+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    martyc35, JKTownsend, Dumbo

    The expressive theme in the final movement was turned into hymn tune (just like the Beethoven 9th).  

  •  We're going to Bartok's "Bluebeard's Castle" (3+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    martyc35, JKTownsend, Dumbo

    tonight.  Any thoughts?  Hubby selected this one and I know nothing about it.

    •  It'll be challenging ... (3+ / 0-)
      Recommended by:
      Dumbo, lineatus, martyc35

      ... but approach it with an open mind and Bartok opens up sonic worlds. I hope the featured two singers are capable! Most performances only run about an hour, so if there's too much dissonance for you, it's over soon.

      Ah, my friends from the prison, they ask unto me, "how good, how good does it feel to be free? " And I answer them most mysteriously, "are birds free from the chains of the skyway? " (Bob Dylan)

      by JKTownsend on Fri Jun 22, 2012 at 06:34:10 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

    •  Personally, I hate it, but (3+ / 0-)
      Recommended by:
      lineatus, JKTownsend, martyc35

      I'm in a minority on that, I think.  It's less like his later music, more like the German postromantic expressionist music of the 1920s.

  •  Beautiful piece of music (3+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    JKTownsend, Dumbo, martyc35

    although my preference is still for the works of Thomas Tallis (ah, the wonders of intonation and grace the human oice are capable of...)    :)

    "You say that I am ignoring the time-honored traditions of the Royal Navy? And what might they be? I shall tell you in three words. Rum, buggery, and the lash! Good morning sirs." - Winston Churchill addressing the Sea Lords, 1912

    by Dingodude on Fri Jun 22, 2012 at 05:59:09 PM PDT

  •  WOW - you just took me back (3+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    Dumbo, JKTownsend, martyc35

    to a music teacher I had who was an unsung hero/genius.  Thank you for reminding me of what is sublime in this life.

    When will our consciences grow so tender that we will act to prevent human misery rather than avenge it? Eleanor Roosevelt

    by seefleur on Fri Jun 22, 2012 at 06:32:16 PM PDT

  •  The Greatest Moment in Western Music (3+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    Dumbo, JKTownsend, martyc35

    I hope it doesn't sound like I am full of myself, but I am probably the best expert in the world to comment on the opening of the last movement of this symphony.

    As you mentioned, this moment in the music features an Alphorn solo - the proper name for the instrument is Alphorn in Switzerland - and I have taught Alphorn at the Swiss Alphorn School for the last 13 years.  

    Brahms was reluctant to write a symphony.  He waited until he was in his late 30s to get started seriously to write a symphony.  He often expressed that he felt like he was in the shadow of Beethoven, the great symphonist of the previous generation, and he wasn't ready for that comparison.   In 1868, he was hiking from Mürren to Steckleberg in the Berner Oberland of Switzerland, and he heard an Alphorn player play a melody.  He wrote the melody on a postcard and sent it to his paramour, Clara Schumann, for her birthday.  He was so inspired by this Alphorn melody that he began seriously writing his First Symphony at this point.  The Alphorn melody is traditional to this valley, the Lauterbrunnen Valley, and the proper translation of the words to the melody is:  "High on the mountain, deep in the valley, I greet You (capital Y, meaning God), ten thousand times."  The implication of these words is that, if an Alphorn player were to play this melody every night of his life for thirty years, he would play it ten thousand times.  This gives you some idea of how the Swiss feel about the Alphorn and its place in the mountains.

    The buildup to this Alphorn melody, of course played by the French Horn in the orchestra, is the wind building up in the Alps.  I've been a French Horn player in a symphony orchestra for 35 years, and in my opinion, this is the greatest moment in Western Music.

    In fact, when the symphony was premiered, many of Brahms admirers called it "Beethoven's Tenth Symphony".

    God is innocent: Noah built on a flood plain.

    by alphorn on Fri Jun 22, 2012 at 09:00:56 PM PDT

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site