Skip to main content

The cruel and unnecessary death last month of Savita Halappanavar, the 31-year-old dentist denied a life-saving abortion, is rightly prompting soul-searching in Ireland. But those in the United States whose business is saving souls would do well to join them. After all, with their "human life amendment," draconian clinic regulations, "personhood" initiatives, heartbeat bills and outright mockery of the very idea of the "health of the mother," the anti-abortion extremists of the Republican Party promise to put women's reproductive rights—and lives—at risk. And thanks to the rapid expansion of Catholic hospital chains, in entire regions of the United States the denial of life-saving abortion services is already happening here.

When a 17 weeks pregnant Savita Halappanavar pleaded for an abortion after learning that her miscarried fetus was certain to die, doctors at the University Hospital Galway refused, explaining, "this is a Catholic country." While the United States is not, for millions of American women seeking reproductive health care, it might as well be.

Here's why.

For over a hundred years, Catholic hospitals have been one of the cornerstones of the U.S. health system, providing care to tens of millions of Americans of all faiths, races and ethnicities. TNR's Jonathan Cohn explained just how big a role they play and the public support they enjoy in return:

Today, Catholic hospitals supply 15 percent of the nation's hospital beds, and Catholic hospital systems own 12 percent of the nation's community hospitals, which means, according to one popularly cited estimate, that about one in six Americans get treatment at a Catholic hospital at some point each year. We now depend upon Catholic hospitals to provide vital services--not just direct care of patients, but also the training of new doctors and assistance to the needy. In exchange, these institutions receive considerable public funding. In addition to the tax breaks to which all nonprofit institutions are entitled, Catholic hospitals also receive taxpayer dollars via public insurance programs like Medicare and Medicaid, as well as myriad federal programs that provide extra subsidies for such things as indigent care and medical research. (Older institutions also benefited from the 1946 Hill-Burton Act, which financed hospital construction for several decades.)
But increasingly, Cohn cautioned, "the dual mandates of these institutions—to heal the body and to nurture the spirit, to perform public functions but maintain private identities—are difficult to reconcile." For many communities, a Catholic facility is already the only choice. And with the accelerating trend of hospital mergers and partnerships, policies forbidding contraception, abortion and sterilization are becoming the norm at formerly public hospitals. In cities around America, the result is growing confusion for physicians and greater risk for their patients.

(Continue reading below the fold.)

As the New York Times detailed, over just the last three years about 20 new partnerships combining stand-alone hospitals or smaller systems with larger, financially stronger Catholic institutions is adversely impacting the availability of common reproductive health care services. For example:

In Seattle, Swedish Health Services has offered elective abortions for decades. But the hospital agreed to stop when it joined forces this month with Providence Health & Services, one of the nation's largest Catholic systems.
And when Seton Healthcare Family in Texas, a unit of Ascension Health, began operating Austin's public Breckenridge hospital in 1995, it curbed reproductive health care services available to its patients:
In that case, Mr. [Charles] Barnett [of Ascension Health] says the system never agreed to provide services like elective abortions and sterilizations, and public officials and hospital administrators initially struggled to find a compromise. Although another system eventually offered sterilizations on a separate floor of the hospital, complete with a separate elevator, another hospital now provides those services.
Increasingly, the clashing requirements of the Catholic hospitals public mission and religious tenets are putting patients, doctors and staff at risk. In 2007, physician Ramesh Raghavan wrote in the Journal of the American Medical Association of his wife's experience. As Cohn explained the horrifying episode:
[Raghavan's wife], a woman, also pregnant with twins, whose pregnancy was failing, threatening infection that could jeopardize her ability to have future children and perhaps her life. Distraught, she and her husband decided to terminate the pregnancy--only to learn the Catholic hospital would not perform the procedure.
A few years later, New Hampshire waitress Kathleen Prieskorn went to her doctor's office after a miscarriage—her second—began while she was three months pregnant. She quickly learned that her emergency was not one for which treatment would be available from her hospital's new operators:
Physicians at the hospital, which had recently merged with a Catholic health care system, told her they could not end the miscarriage with a uterine evacuation--the standard procedure--because the fetus still had a heartbeat. She had no insurance and no way to get to another hospital, so a doctor gave her $400 and put her in a cab to the closest available hospital, about 80 miles away. "During that trip, which seemed endless, I was not only devastated but terrified," Prieskorn told Ms. "I knew that, if there were complications, I could lose my uterus--and maybe even my life."
Perhaps the most notorious case, as both the Times and the New Republic reported, involved Catholic Health West and one its hospitals in Phoenix. A 27-year-old woman, 11 weeks pregnant and suffering from "right heart failure" came to St. Joseph's Hospital and Medical Center. What happened next may be a frightening omen of things to come:
Physicians concluded that, if she continued with the pregnancy, her chances of mortality were "close to 100 percent." An administrator, Sister Margaret McBride, approved an abortion, citing a church directive allowing termination when the mother's life is at risk. Afterward, however, the local bishop, Thomas Olmsted, said the abortion had not been absolutely necessary. He excommunicated the nun and severed ties with the hospital, although the nun subsequently won reinstatement when she agreed to confess her sin to a priest.
The growing crisis for women's care resulting from the partnership and merger movement is leading to a backlash and some sadly creative solutions. Catholic Health Care splits its network into 25 Catholic and 15 non-Catholic facilities under the new name, Dignity Health. In Kentucky, Gov. Steve Brashear blocked "a bid by Catholic Health Initiatives, another large system, to merge with a public hospital in Louisville, in part because of concern that some women would have less access to contraceptive services." Meanwhile in Rockford, Illinois, there is growing resistance to let the Sisters of the Third Order of St. Francis buy a local hospital because of "new restrictions that would require women to go elsewhere if they wanted a tubal ligation after a Caesarean section."

Still, the worrying trend is creating problems for all parties. Sister Carol Keehan, president of the Catholic Health Association of the United States, which represents the nation's roughly 600 Catholic hospitals, said of Americans' increasingly dependence on her organization's facilities, "That is a constant challenge. It's a challenge we take very seriously." But for American women, the challenge of getting reproductive care isn't just serious; it could be very dangerous. As Jill C. Morrison of the National Women's Law Center worried, the new restrictions mean "women simply don't know what they're getting."

If, that is, they can get it at all. As Lois Uttley, director of MergerWatch explained, "There are a lot of rural places that now have only a Catholic hospital." Arizona obstetrician Bruce Silva, who lamented that he can no longer provide routine services like a tubal ligation, worried about his lower-income patients:

"If you're wealthy, you go up to Tucson and you get a hotel. But a lot of people can't even pay for the gas to get up there."
Which means it's only a matter of time until the next Savita Halappanavar pays the ultimate price. Right here. In the United States of America.

Originally posted to Jon Perr on Wed Nov 14, 2012 at 11:17 AM PST.

Also republished by Abortion, Pro Choice, and Shamrock American Kossacks.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

skybluewater, Sylv, CJB, filkertom, True North, debcoop, Gooserock, Emerson, Shockwave, elfling, caliberal, Matilda, MarkInSanFran, hubcap, chipoliwog, bronte17, EricS, bobtmn, BlackSheep1, annrose, susakinovember, ask, highacidity, CatFelyne, snoopydog, mrblifil, roses, sngmama, splashy, Cedwyn, caspian, Miss Jones, ranger995, Chirons apprentice, Frankenoid, kismet, Oaktown Girl, AllisonInSeattle, KateCrashes, ybruti, lonespark, ScienceMom, Thestral, Emmy, Gowrie Gal, 4fx, rapala, la motocycliste, kplatv, historys mysteries, marina, radarlady, NoMoreLies, DianeNYS, greycat, el dorado gal, caul, sc kitty, Clem Yeobright, dewtx, Brooke In Seattle, dansk47, SaraBeth, ladybug53, lotlizard, Ice Blue, most peculiar mama, Yamara, kaliope, peacestpete, xaxnar, Mother Mags, Born in NOLA, third Party please, kovie, esquimaux, irishwitch, myboo, 417els, Clytemnestra, jkusters, Themistoclea, tonyahky, Dvalkure, mskitty, ladelfina, arlene, Son of a Cat, blueoasis, ER Doc, middleagedhousewife, kurt, Brunette, bstotts, Elasg, Temmoku, NonnyO, Thinking Fella, Tamar, phonegery, Noor B, Cronesense, jessical, Cat Whisperer, weneedahero, moodyinsavannah, gloriana, beth meacham, gustynpip, operculum, terabytes, mommyof3, bnasley, uciguy30, GeorgeXVIII, trueblueliberal, Neon Mama, rogerdaddy, mconvente, TruthFreedomKindness, also mom of 5, ChocolateChris, mamamedusa, Sixty Something, Alexandre, Involuntary Exile, lineatus, Sharon Wraight, Calamity Jean, Lujane, tofumagoo, Cassandra Waites, NogodsnomastersMary, Gemina13, Womantrust, petulans, KrazyKitten, get the red out, Parthenia, BYw, Al Fondy, Mayfly, jlms qkw, LaFeminista, Fiddlegirl, MrsTarquinBiscuitbarrel, maggiejean, Bule Betawi, Mrs M, J M F, spacecadet1, litoralis, greengemini, Michael James, be the change you seek, Norm in Chicago, WakeUpNeo, jennylind, dRefractor, TheOpinionGuy, bfitzinAR, papahaha, Munchkn, winkk, jfromga, futureliveshere, Larsstephens, Amber6541, CalGal47, mamamorgaine, eXtina, eb23, angelajean, AZphilosopher, freeport beach PA, gulfgal98, pixxer, Betty Pinson, Rainefenix, cocinero, Anne was here, science nerd, Oh Mary Oh, Kelvin Kean, wrpereir, Onomastic, Jane Lew, kerflooey, mama jo, sboucher, StateofEuphoria, msazdem, slowbutsure, sostos, vahana, Mistral Wind, FarWestGirl, kevin k, mrsgoo, marleycat, Angela Quattrano, SueM1121, tardis10, MPociask, CherryTheTart, Fire bad tree pretty, wintergreen8694, corvaire, peregrine kate, whaddaya, bluedust, mali muso, stevie avebury, cailloux, Craddoke, SoCalSal, VeloVixen, Catlady62, allergywoman, Mortifyd, No one gets out alive, Laurel in CA, OldDragon, dunnjen, CuriousBoston, Voiceless, Williston Barrett, Siri, IndieGuy, ahumbleopinion, LefseBlue, swampyankee, Lorinda Pike, jan4insight, pittie70, cassandracarolina, tytalus, arizonablue, MusicFarmer, George3, Melanie in IA, corpsechorus, Chaddiwicker, Key6119, wozzlecat, Late Again, glorificus, mtnlvr1946, leeleedee, LaraJones, Lucy West, FourthOfJulyAsburyPark, Avilyn, ET3117, blue91, DaveCaswell, livebyChocolate, LilithGardener, FloraLine, shinobi9, malevola, sfinx, CA wildwoman

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site