Many people have heard of Saul Alinsky and know Alinsky’s rules because of their toxic effect on the regressive rightwing. In Wingnut World, Alinsky is one of the 1960s radicals who indoctrinated Barack Obama. The Republicans gave Alinsky more publicity than he ever had when they tried to connect him to the President in unrealistic terms.
Alinsky’s rules encompass durable truths. They make abstract political theory practical and useful. Although Alinsky was published decades ago, the rules are suited to present day social network settings where politics is a competitive game.
In our two-party system, a majority caucus has to span from an extreme to the center +1, by definition. We should be used to intra-party dissent but in the two-party system some participants automatically perceive that attacks come from the opposition. The constructive alternative places the source of the attack on the spectrum where it belongs so that civil discourse can take place. Some of the pie fights that break out here reflect the anxiety humans are hard-wired to feel when they’re unsure of the intentions of those around them.
There’s another reason why a constructive alternative is necessary in politics. Having a platform of beneficial policy proposals is a competitive edge. A political group that defines itself by what it opposes is at a disadvantage. One of the reasons why Republicans lost in 2012 was excess focus on Obama, instead of their own platform. Of course, their proposals were so unappealing they had to minimize them while running as ‘Not-Obama’ instead of a constructive alternative.
Even though a constructive alternative has obvious value, it’s only useful in a political system that accommodates citizens who have agency. The system has to be responsive to citizen engagement.
Nowadays, it’s becoming clearer to an increasing number of people that the political system no longer functions as a liberal representative democracy. Instead, more people are recognizing that the political system is a status quo that resists input from them. It has become unresponsive and it no longer represents the interests of ordinary people. It's an existential fact that requires participation through a number of daily rituals but there is no chance of ever changing it.
To the people who see the system as a permanent default with its own interests, there is no constructive alternative. In fact, the only alternative is destruction. To that end, the only worthwhile activity relative to the system is dissent.
I doubt that many people see signs of the amorphous new Nihilism developing in the US because of the current unsatisfactory situation. The huge scale of this country can absorb and mute a lot. But there's a picture emerging if you're willing to connect the dots.
Of course not everyone will see the same thing.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.
You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.
Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?
Gooserock, Cedwyn, LakeSuperior, dharmafarmer, Richard Lyon, bobswern, Puddytat, PhilJD, Sunspots, GwenM, RedwoodGirl
Diary Recommended By
Recommended by Mark Lippman
- Denny Hastert Did anyone see this coming? Former Speaker of the House Denny Hastert, a Republican who ...208 comments 82 Recs
- He's already won. Believe it or not (I didn't at first), Hillary's primary poll ...711 comments 147 Recs
- For several decades, state and local governments have been showering private businesses with tax breaks and direct subsidies based on the theory that this practice fosters economic development and, ...10 comments 17 Recs
- Recently, outlaw motorcycle clubs engaged in a daylight gun battle in Waco, Texas. This combat involved hundreds of people. The mall where the riot occurred was left resembling a war zone, with ...48 comments 23 Recs
- Ann Kirkpatrick Tuesday morning brought some exciting news for Arizona Democrats, as Rep. Ann Kirkpatrick announced she'd run against veteran ...57 comments 59 Recs
- 100 comments 25 Recs
- I'm shocked! Shocked! Joe Arpaio is attempting to "manipulate the judicial system" Oh, gawd. This is breaking this morning in Phoenix: lawyers for Maricopa County Sheriff Joe ...85 comments 159 Recs
- Texas Sen. John Cornyn, right, with Sen. Ted ...54 comments 133 Recs
- Hillary Clinton, at a small-business roundtable in Iowa, loses nothing by bypassing the traditional ...263 comments 127 Recs
- Nancy Pelosi could be key in the fight over fast-track trade legislation. Senate Majority Leader Mitch ...46 comments 59 Recs
Mark Lippman's Tags
- No current results.