Skip to main content

The Obama administration won a rare Supreme Court victory regarding the rights of the EPA to regulate pollution from coal plants. Instead of the usual 5-4 decision against anything the Obama Administration wants, this decision was a 6-2 decision.  And you get 1 guess as to who the 2 opposed were.  Yep, Scalia and Thomas.

Well, the minority dissent opinion was written by Scalia, and according to this report from TPM Scalia really screwed up the opinion.

"This is not the first time EPA has sought to convert the Clean Air Act into a mandate for cost-effective regulation. Whitman v. American Trucking Assns., Inc., 531 U. S. 457 (2001), confronted EPA's contention that it could consider costs in setting [National Ambient Air Quality Standards]," Scalia wrote in his dissent, which was joined by Justice Clarence Thomas.

The problem: the EPA's position in the 2001 case was exactly the opposite. The agency was defending its refusal to consider cost as a counter-weight to health benefits when setting certain air quality standards. It was the trucking industry that wanted the EPA to factor in cost. The 9-0 ruling sided with the EPA. The author of the ruling that Scalia mischaracterized? Scalia himself.

The conservative justice's error was noted by University of California-Berkeley law professor Dan Farber, who called it "embarrassing" and a "cringeworthy blunder."

But wait, it gets better.
"This gaffe is doubly embarrassing because Scalia wrote the opinion in the case, so he should surely remember which side won!


"It is a mind-blowing misstatement of a basic fact of the American Trucking Association ruling which Justice Scalia himself wrote. And it's not just a stray passage -- it's the basis for an entire section of the dissent,"

Looks like someone isn't taking their job very seriously, or maybe it's time to "spend more time with the family".  Of course, does anyone really believe Scalia isn't the most political of the Justices?

Originally posted to pollwatcher on Wed Apr 30, 2014 at 07:13 AM PDT.

Also republished by Repeal or Amend the Second Amendment (RASA).

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

skybluewater, sdf, Pat K California, fly, Thumb, Alumbrados, paradox, MichaelPH, Angie in WA State, JWC, buffalo soldier, Joe Bob, Sylv, DeminNewJ, chrississippi, Garrett, KeithH, dwellscho, RF, PrahaPartizan, Sean Robertson, fcvaguy, sny, lanshark, mwm341, Timaeus, kd4dean, kaleidescope, Rolfyboy6, RunawayRose, Bob Love, nmjardine, Emerson, karlpk, MouseThatRoared, Shockwave, Fabienne, wu ming, LynChi, CleverNickName, meg, genethefiend, hyperstation, OLinda, mslat27, celdd, eeff, elfling, red moon dog, sidhra, MarkInSanFran, exNYinTX, expatjourno, hnichols, Creosote, davelf2, astro, Heart of the Rockies, checkmate, opinionated, JesterDel, Zinman, missLotus, 714day, susans, TracieLynn, EricS, BlackSheep1, wonkydonkey, susakinovember, whenwego, twcollier, Merlin1963, CoolOnion, boadicea, mrblifil, farmerhunt, roses, vmckimmey, PeteZerria, splashy, artebella, Alna Dem, hopeful, sidnora, dksbook, wader, revsue, Redfire, Texknight, suzq, recontext, SneakySnu, ammaloy, Mxwll, NYC Sophia, Farugia, Eyesbright, MA Liberal, Noodles, duncanidaho, agincour, JCPOK, texasmom, HeyMikey, wdrath, mnguitar, NYFM, dwahzon, Steven Payne, sgoldinger, betson08, Daniel Case, lcrp, 2dot, Brian82, Sophie Amrain, walkshills, JayBat, zerelda, ybruti, mungley, randallt, Hillbilly Dem, KayCeSF, tomjones, eve, solesse413, Josiah Bartlett, gsbadj, Blueiz, Armand451, BoogieMama, sawgrass727, Gowrie Gal, weelzup, davidkc, Desert Rose, historys mysteries, Bluesee, marina, radarlady, Tinfoil Hat, jhancock, ichibon, freakofsociety, UncleCharlie, subtropolis, klamothe, chimene, democracy inaction, OpherGopher, sc kitty, wallys son, one of 8, grimjc, basquebob, dewtx, ChemBob, juliesie, stagemom, reflectionsv37, FutureNow, fixxit, eru, bleeding blue, Pam from Calif, where4art, GreyHawk, Overseas, skyounkin, Ice Blue, Little Lulu, markdd, jane123, sunbro, ord avg guy, not a lamb, kaliope, Isara, Tool, Tunk, Savvy813, Shotput8, Ginny in CO, FindingMyVoice, Joes Steven, itsjim, deepsouthdoug, peacestpete, Alan Arizona, zozie, kathny, begone, RJDixon74135, dedwords, MadGeorgiaDem, martini, third Party please, Knucklehead, BachFan, Captain Sham, golem, Kingsmeg, 417els, Mr Bojangles, edwardssl, BlueInARedState, tobendaro, profundo, HoundDog, Gorette, raptavio, cookseytalbott, mooshter, Prognosticator, KenBee, The Wizard, Shakludanto, Naniboujou, pengiep, blueoasis, SherriG, NBBooks, aloevera, StrayCat, Rosaura, Libby Shaw, se portland, novapsyche, Terminus, JVolvo, el cid, tommyfocus2003, ER Doc, Dinclusin, middleagedhousewife, anninla, Turbonerd, onionjim, thenekkidtruth, nother lurker, rage, CA Nana, lastamendment, Clive all hat no horse Rodeo, blueoregon, kurt, lynneinfla, shaharazade, NancyWH, FrankieB, kurious, bstotts, dochackenbush, Friend of the court, Temmoku, markthshark, Pandoras Box, PatConnors, cpresley, tegrat, ammasdarling, Sapere aude, FoundingFatherDAR, john07801, Cronesense, Habitat Vic, Loudoun County Dem, camlbacker, Debs2, devis1, Dartagnan, ColoTim, offgrid, paz3, EdSF, edsbrooklyn, FishOutofWater, Blue State 68, tbirchard, jeanette0605, terabytes, Dave in Northridge, shesaid, certainot, sfbob, FischFry, mbh1023, jayden, jedennis, Bullie, cyncynical, Back In Blue, SeaTurtle, bobswern, jnhobbs, Bridge Master, carpunder, Wreck Smurfy, christianlsv, GeorgeXVIII, leonard145b, skod, janatallow, Ralphdog, keyscritter, South Park Democrat, on the cusp, Empower Ink, gizmo59, rmonroe, fb, jwinIL14, gundyj, seriously70, mconvente, JeffW, TX Freethinker, BobBlueMass, GAS, wayoutinthestix, amyzex, Marko the Werelynx, ScottyUrb, 6412093, OleHippieChick, mamamedusa, Youffraita, Involuntary Exile, NewDealer, bythesea, elwior, Laughing Vergil, CDH in Brooklyn, Buckeye Nut Schell, Sharon Wraight, mikeconwell, Calamity Jean, Lujane, TomFromNJ, rssrai, tofumagoo, royce, pamelabrown, Cassandra Waites, RandomNonviolence, Missys Brother, Jeff Y, catly, home solar, brasilaaron, codairem, exdiplopat, glendaw271, petulans, TexanJane, sewaneepat, get the red out, Piren, BYw, Blueslide, dmhlt 66, watercarrier4diogenes, shortgirl, statsone, JBL55, oldliberal, legendmn, enemy of the people, Bule Betawi, pileta, Ran3dy, J M F, zmom, DontTaseMeBro, Ravenstream, Dirtandiron, Softlanded, LinSea, ronnied, Carol in San Antonio, TheFern, Nebraskablue, Methinks They Lie, Gorilla in the room, janmtairy, LibrErica, followyourbliss, geebeebee, TheOpinionGuy, oxfdblue, kevinpdx, Keith Pickering, Munchkn, sfarkash, astral66, kingfishstew, LookingUp, Black Mare, Larsstephens, Lefty Ladig, ruscle, cassandraX, BlueOak, Just Bob, hotdamn, Its the Supreme Court Stupid, commonmass, rb137, Mokurai, FogCityJohn, roadbear, NJpeach, brunoboy, gramofsam1, blueyescryinintherain, leftywright, PurpleMyst, michelewln, LOrion, Polly Syllabic, Lost and Found, freeport beach PA, Things Come Undone, ATFILLINOIS, womankind, melpomene1, JoanMar, NY brit expat, pixxer, kacemo, paradise50, Puddytat, dlemex, DerAmi, DiegoUK, Jaimas, rja, DrTerwilliker, kenwards, ericlewis0, Loose Fur, cocinero, science nerd, ZedMont, stevenaxelrod, eviemarie, jcbdem, Mister Met, Onomastic, Barbara Marquardt, Colorado is the Shiznit, kerflooey, MidwestTreeHugger, ozsea1, Captain Pants, spooks51, ban nock, DLWinMI, slowbutsure, sabo33, AdamR510, cv lurking gf, freesia, Possiamo, Zutroy, BillyElliott, FarWestGirl, kevin k, Alice Olson, EquityRoy, trumpeter, PedalingPete, Haf2Read, marleycat, PorridgeGun, zukesgirl64, laurnj, sethtriggs, Jasonhouse, thomask, Drokkenian, BarackStarObama, RfrancisR, chickeeee, 1718bill, shaso, Grandma Susie, createpeace, worldlotus, RMForbes, corvaire, Calvino Partigiani, chira2, myrmecia gulosa, PhilJD, Liberal Mole, Vatexia, Hayate Yagami, SteelerGrrl, stlsophos, Alfreda89, DRo, Chitown Kev, caryltoo, nyer11Oak, bassinduo, Auriandra, MichaelNY, PrometheusUnbound, friendjudy, No one gets out alive, Laurel in CA, Rejoinder, Monsieur Georges, YaNevaNo, BocaBlue, AnnetteK, Sister Inspired Revolver of Freedom, livingthedream, KiB, bluezen, OldDragon, anodnhajo, sow hat, Catskill Julie, isabelle hayes, StonyB, Siri, molecularlevel, Trevin, Eric Nelson, nellgwen, oldcrow, barkingcat, AnnieR, Joieau, Deep Texan, rukidingme, Farkletoo, 420 forever, Trotskyrepublican, Yonkers Boy, joeschmeaux, Mike RinRI, winifred3, kellius, Forward is D not R, readerwriter, Ana Thema, reginahny, radical simplicity, MartyM, aznavy, pittie70, jes2, lunachickie, wxorknot, james321, rat racer, Victim of Circumstance, ItsaMathJoke, marty marty, raina, Glen The Plumber, George3, Kayjay, Windowpane, ShoshannaD, Heavy Mettle, BobTheHappyDinosaur, mzkryz, Blue Bell Bookworm, simple serf, countwebb, akadjian, jbob, Linda1961, Oregonemom, TeamSarah4Choice, goodpractice, PHScott, aresea, alice kleeman, Aunt Pat, ggfkate, Jollie Ollie Orange, howabout, Jon Sitzman, northerntier, Unsung81, akze29, helpImdrowning, Smoh, Avilyn, Grandson named me Papa, nice marmot, Fordmandalay, ET3117, Hey338Too, tampaedski, librarisingnsf, chicklet, Jim Domenico, Doodlebug9, ChristineM, tubaguy, Halfton81, Catkin, Lordcaradoc, Modified Dog, northcountry21st, starduster, dreamweaver1, TheDuckManCometh, DarthMeow504, pianogramma, The Marti, RUNDOWN, Tom Lum Forest, Chas 981, Leslie Salzillo, Dodgerdog1, eagleray, pierre9045, luerwulf, RightHeaded, Bartskid1, Fish Man, patbahn, Penny GC, Tony Situ, Gurnt, waterstreet2013, kkkkate, NCTim, thanatokephaloides, Skyye, ginimck, SirVantes, DarthEVaderCheney, LilPeach, Urban Space Cowboy, JimValent, Miiiisha, hbk, LubbockGayMale, AJayne, e2247, Arfeeto, Cynthia Hobgood Strauss, Cassandra2014, AWilson, Shawn87, BMScott, numble, Gunnar Thomas, MeanLouise, alypse1, jmosmith, bobcat41702, allie4fairness, BHSDesk, J Williams, BlueDuPage

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site