Skip to main content

Back by popular demand, here is my analysis on the top three most likely State Senate Seats to flip in November! Hope you'll all enjoy!

Democrats currently hold 15 seats in the 33-seat Senate Chamber. Due to redistricting, we will have to give up one seat made ultra-red by redistrict. This means we'll effectively need to flip three seats to regain the Senate Majority.

Map Key:
Dark Red = 15+ points Romney
Red = 10-15 points Romney
Light Red = 5-10 Points Romney
Purple = 0-5 Points Obama or Romney
Light Blue = 5-10 Points Obama
Blue = 10-15 Points Obama
Dark Blue = 15+ Points Obama

1. The 19th Senate District

     Location: The Fox Valley - Cities of Appleton and Menasha
     Incumbent: OPEN
     PVI: R+2 (Obama Majority)
     Rating: Toss-up

    Analysis: The 19th Senate District is in the heart of the Fox River Valley - for those
     not familiar with Wisconsin geography, this is the stretch of land in the East from
     Green Bay all the way down to Fond du Lac that is home to a plethora of Tech
     Schools and manufacturing firms. Appleton is conservative by urban standards, but
     does tilt Blue and is getting bluer.

     The 19th is swingy to the point of being somewhat hilarious. Obama won the 19th
     District by 12 votes - not 1,200 votes, not 120 votes, but 12 Votes. Meanwhile,
     Tommy Thompson beat Tammy Baldwin 49%-47% here. The district is conservative
     but it is not adverse to electing Democrats locally (Both Winnebago and Outagamie
     counties, which more often than not go red during state elections, have
     un-apologetically Democratic County Executives). The area is socially conservative
     but open to "liberal" economic policies, so Blue Collar Dems definitely have a place

     First of all, I must give a shout-out to Appleton for electing Gypsy Vered Meltzer, the
     first openly Transgendered person to hold elected office in Wisconsin! But to the race
     at hand...

     Our incumbent here is a GOP Senator by the name of Mike Ellis. Ellis was elected all
     the back in 1982, and was in the State Legislature since 1971. The man is an
     institution up in Neenah (his hometown), and has in the past garnered an
     independent reputation for supporting healthcare and public education in the Fox
     Valley. You may remember Mike Ellis from his gavel-busting tirade in which he
     pushed that awful abortion bill through the state senate. A few weeks ago, he rather
     abruptly retired after being caught on tape discussing illegally using Dark Money to
     fund his campaign.


     As of Tuesday, Republicans were quick to rally around Roger Roth, a former State
     Representative out of suburban Appleton from 2007 to 2011. Roth has an
     admittedly attractive profile. He's young (age 36), and is an Iraq War Veteran in the
     Air National Guard. If his name sounds somewhat familiar, he ran for Congress in          
     2010 in Wisconsin's 8th District, but was defeated by current Congressman Reid
     Ribble. All other major GOP figures in the 19th District have already declined and
     Roth has the endorsement of Governor Walker and Scott Fitzgerald, so the primary  
     is just a coronation.

     Luckily, we have a GREAT Candidate in Representative Penny Bernard Schaber
     (D-Appleton). Schaber was a nurse before her election to the State Assembly. She
     has experiencing running in difficult campaigns, as she represented a swingier
     district prior to redistricting. She received early support from Wisconsin's Planned
     Parenthood and women's groups when she was planning on running against Ellis, so
     she's in a great place with money, at just below 100K as of the last campaign
     finance deadline.

     Needless to say, conservative groups are going to dump loads of money in keeping
     this seat red. That said, Penny Bernard Schaber is the exact sort of Democrat that
     performs well in the swingy Fox Valley. If she can keep the same intensity and
     enthusiasm she had pursuing Ellis, and redirect it toward Roth, Democrats will hold
     the 19th for the first time in decades.

     Click here to donate to Penny Bernard Schaber via ActBlue!

2. The 17th Senate District

     Location: Southwestern Wisconsin
     Incumbent: OPEN
     PVI: D+6
     Rating: Toss-up

    Analysis: The 17th District takes up a huge swath of SouthWestern Wisconsin. As
     discussed in my previous diary, southwestern Wisconsin is stereotypical, midwestern
     farm country. Honestly, readers from outside of the Badger State ought to visit - its
     some of the most beautiful land in the nation. The Senate District is sparsely
     populated, with no cities exceeding a population of ~20K.

     Federally, the 17th District leans Democratic. President Obama received 57%, and
     that Madison liberal Senator Baldwin received 54% down here. However, southwest
     Wisconsin has something of a reverse-Deep South complex: the region is rapidly
     trending blue, but is ancestrally Republican, and so the GOP performs much better

     The current Senator here is Dale Schultz, one of the last few genuinely moderate
     elected Republicans left in Wisconsin. Schultz made himself nationally famous for
     being the sole GOP vote against the 2011 "Budget Repair Bill," and for voting against
     many of the Walker Administration's most extreme proposals. This earned Schultz a
     daunting primary challenge from State Representative Howard Marklein, a
     conservative Republican elected in the 2010 wave. Schultz recently announced his
     retirement, lambasting the GOP Caucus on his way out.

     Howard Marklein wasted no time in fundraising to take on Senator Schultz. Now he
     has at least 145K in his campaign warchest as of March, which unfortunately makes
     him the frontrunner despite the 17th District's blue-ish nature. Although this is a
     D+6 district, this might be Marklein's race to lose. He currently represents a district
     just northwest of Madison that gave 59% of the vote to Obama in 2012: during
     that same year, he defeated his democratic opponent with 52%. Despite that
     Marklein's voting pattern is identical to conservative Assembly-people in Waukesha
     County, he absolutely has the chops to compete in blue territory.

     Many in the Wisconsin polito-sphere viewed this seat as a squandered opportunity until
     Wednesday. The new instant-frontrunner, Pat Bomhack, was an aide for Congressman
     Ron Kind, Senator Russ Feingold, and Governor Jim Doyle. He grew up in the Dodgeville
     area, and moved back to the 17th District after college at Stanford. He ran for state
     assembly last year as an underdog in the primary (ironically, to face off with Howard
     Marklein) and very nearly won. He was gunning for the assembly a second time until
     Democratic officials and SD-17 convinced him to upgrade to the Senate Race due to
     concerns of confronting Howard Marklein's ~145K war chest. Bomhack faces former
     Director of the UW-Madison Transportation Center Ernie Wittwer in the Democratic

     This area is rapidly turning blue, but Marklein is going to be a formidable candidate.
     Nevertheless, Marklein is a Walker Conservative, not a Moderate Dale Schultz. His    
     politics simply do not fit the area. For this reason only, this race currently Toss-
assuming Bomhack is our candidate, or if Wittwer's fundraising picks
     up in a significant way.

     Click here to donate to Pat Bomhack via ActBlue

     Click here to  
     donate to Ernie Wittwer via ActBlue!

3. The 9th Senate District

     Location: East Wisconsin along Lake Michigan - Sheboygan, WI
     Incumbent: OPEN
     PVI: R+6
     Rating: Leans Republican

    Analysis: The 9th Senate district runs up the coast of Lake Michigan in between the
     Milwaukee and Green Bay Metro Areas. Two cities make up the bulk and political
     make-up of the 9th District: Manitowoc and Sheboygan. Sheboygan is a blue collar
     city of just under 50K and, like other fox valley cities, relies on industry. Sheboygan
     also happens to be the surfing capital of the midwest. Manitowoc is a smaller city of
     ~34K of a similar nature. Besides the two population centers is the very, very
     conservative countryside.

     This part of the wider Fox River Valley is very culturally Conservative. Both Mitt Romney and
     Tommy Thompson both won the 19th District by daunting margins and over the long run,
     Sheboygan and Manitowoc Counties are unfortunately trending away from the Democrats.
     Nevertheless, Democrats do perform remarkably better on the local level: the DAs of both
     counties and other countywide officials are Democrats, and Democrats at the state
     legislative levels tend to outperform statewide Dems.

     Tom Petri's retirement caused a VERY significant political shake-up in Sheboyga-towoc.
     Senator Joe Leibham is personably very popular in Sheboygan, but his retirement to run for
     Congress creates a huge opportunity for Team Blue -- and it could not have occurred at a
     better time. Two of the three GOP assemblymen, Steve Kestell and Mike Endsley, had
     already retired - Kestell due to old age presumably, and Endsley to run to the private sector.
     Paul Tittl of Manitowoc definitively will not run.

     That leaves only one GOP candidate - Devin LaMahieu, chair of the Sheboygan County Board (and son of State Rep. Dan LeMahieu):
     certainly a legit candidate, but not first tier for a State Senate Race, due to a lack of name
     recognition. He previously primaried State Rep. Endsley from the right in 2012, and due to
     radical redistricting in the area, lost with a respectable 40%.

     We also landed a great candidate in Martha Laning of Sheboygan. Laning is a successful
     entrepreneur, which is a quality that plays particularly well to swing voters in this part of
     Badgerland. She is known in Sheboygan as a professional fundraiser, most notably    
     for the Plymouth Multigenerational Facility, raising nearly $5 Million dollars for the  
     project and many other projects. She is potentially the prime candidate to win the
     9th district - successful businesswoman, no political experience, Central-Wisconsin
     roots, and genuine belief in Democratic ideals.

     This district may swing between Republicans Democrats in certain respects, but it
     gave Governor Walker over 60% in the recall election. Granted the Recall was an
     exceptional circumstance, but the Governor is popular here and will be on top of the
     ballot in November. For this reason, the race leans GOP.
     However, Laning had a strong fundraising period, and LeMahieu had a virtually
     non-existant fundraising haul. Expect something of a Dem resurgence here in

    Click here to donate to Martha Laning via ActBlue!

Originally posted to BlueSasha on Sun May 04, 2014 at 03:38 PM PDT.

Also republished by Badger State Progressive, State & Local ACTION Group, and Community Spotlight.


How many Senate seats will the Democrats hold in 2015?

6%13 votes
8%17 votes
11%25 votes
33%70 votes
32%69 votes
5%12 votes
2%6 votes

| 212 votes | Vote | Results

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site