For some time now, Georgia Tech's Judith Curry has been operating in the space somewhere between legitimate-scientist-that's-skeptical-on-climate-change and full-blown-conspiracy-embracing-denier. However, a recent post unfortunately confirms she has fully entered the latter camp.
The post itself is rather unremarkable. It's mostly a hodgepodge of others' quotes, with a little of her own commentary sprinkled throughout. But then—at the end—she makes two very, very concerning statements that reveal the depth of her denial.
She claims that the Climategate emails were "handled pretty responsibly" by the denier bloggers who released them. Yes, Curry believes the manufactured controversy—wherein a trove of emails were quote mined, with various snippets taken completely out of context and presented as damning evidence of climate science malfeasance—was "handled pretty responsibly." Perhaps she has a unique definition of "responsibly," because NINE investigations cleared the scientists of wrongdoing and showed the bloggers were completely wrong in their portrayal.
Not content to stop there, Curry pulls out what may be the single most misleading doctored quote: the combination of "Mike's Nature trick" and "hide the decline," which deniers trumpeted as evidence that scientists were cooking the books to turn a decline in temperatures into warming. She concludes her post with the following: "Lets face it – 'Mike’s Nature trick' to 'hide the decline' means . . . 'Mike’s Nature trick' to 'hide the decline.'"
No, Curry, it doesn't. At all. "Mike's Nature trick" was referring to (as Greg Laden points out) the process of adding the instrumental observations to the proxy record, and "hide the decline" refers to the fact that tree rings showed a decline in how closely they corresponded with temperatures. The (deliberate) misrepresentation of this truncated quote is a cornerstone of the grand climate denial conspiracy theory that scientists are manipulating data to back up their own theories.
With this endorsement of what may be the single most egregious fabrication of climate change denial, Curry sadly confirms her inability to distinguish between reality and conspiracy, bringing her fully into the climate denier camp.
-----
Top Climate and Clean Energy Stories:
Germany and Brazil join forces on climate change action. Germany and Brazil committed themselves on Thursday to a joint stance on climate change, putting the largest economies in Europe and Latin America on the same page ahead of global climate talks in Paris in December.
Global warming worsened the California drought, scientists say. Amir AghaKouchak, a hydrology professor at the University of California at Irvine who said in June that science did not support connecting the drought to warming, said the report’s results show that human influences are having an effect
Climate wonks focus on economics. They need to pay more attention to politics. We can easily afford the cost of transitioning to a low-carbon system; we cannot afford the costs of failing to do so.
SunEdison Solar Farm Beats Gas With Biggest Colorado Project. “We actually can offer solar and wind that’s cheaper than gas,” Blunden said in a phone interview Thursday. “It’s such an important inflection point. We can sell power without any fuel-price risk.”
U.S. taxpayers are getting ripped off by fossil fuel extraction. As a result of loopholes and subsidies, coal companies end up paying just an effective royalty rate of 4.9 percent — well below the 12.5 percent rate required by law.
Environmental group seeks to rescue US coal assets in carbon credit-linked deal. A US conservation group has reached a deal with bankrupt Patriot Coal to acquire some of its assets in a landmark move that involves restarting coal mining and earning carbon credits from planting trees.