Top: A painting of a buoy at sea during the day, overlaid with the first four measures of Ludwig van Beethoven's Piano Sonata in E-flat major, Opus 27, No. 1. Bottom: A painting of Sherlock Holmes on a tor as the moon rises behind him, overlaid with the first couple of measures of Beethoven's Piano Sonata in C-sharp minor, Opus 27, No. 2.
A few weeks ago, American pianist Eric Lu won the Chopin Competition in Warsaw, becoming the first American winner since Garrick Ohlson and the first to win with Chopin’s Piano Concerto No. 2 instead of No. 1 since his teacher, Đặng Thái Sơn.
To my knowledge, Donald Trump has not tried to take credit for Lu’s win. Nor has the Chopin Competition invented a fake Peace Prize to give Trump. That would be utterly absurd, wouldn't it be? A piano competition has no business giving out Peace Prizes.
A couple of days ago, Lu played an all-Chopin recital in Singapore (though including a little Bach for an encore). The review in Bachtrack by Chang Tou Liang was headlined “Chopin Competition winner Eric Lu lives up to the hype in Singapore.”
Lu started with Chopin’s Nocturne in C-sharp minor, Opus 27, No. 1. Liang praised Lu for “the colours and shadings he strived for in its slow but gradual build-up, from simmering underlying tension to a final release of pent-up passion.”
As far as I know, the only Beethoven composition Lu has ever played in a concert or recording is Beethoven’s Piano Concerto No. 4 in G major. But I wager Lu has at least studied both of Beethoven’s Opus 27 sonatas. Without a doubt, he’s keenly aware of the second one of those and has surely played it in private.
We have almost arrived at what might be Beethoven’s most famous sonata of them all, one which a lot of pianists regard as both Beethoven’s best and most technically difficult sonata. It certainly helps its fame that it has a very evocative nickname.
But first we look at Beethoven’s Piano Sonata No. 13 in E-flat major, Opus 27, No. 1. Both sonatas were labeled “Sonata Quasi Una Fantasia” by Beethoven himself, but that moniker has really only stuck to the less famous first one of the two.
The appellation could quite sensibly also be applied to Piano Sonata No. 12 in A-flat major, Opus 26, which has its share of deviations from conventional sonatas and could have even been intended to be published as one of three with these two (see last week’s open thread).
No. 13 could be a more famous sonata, if maybe someone could have come up with a very evocative nickname for it in the 19th century. “Sunlight Sonata”? Let’s keep brainstorming...
Backtracking now to the beginning of the sonata, I am often impressed by the brilliant simplicity of how Beethoven starts off his E-flat major compositions. It’s like, anyone could have thought of that, but he’s the only one who actually did.
The Wikipedia article about this sonata is at pains to emphasize that this sonata is in four movements:
I. Andante — Allegro — Andante
II. Allegro molto e vivace
III. Adagio con espressione
IV. Allegro vivace
That’s how it appears in my iTunes collection as performed by Artur Schnabel, with those movements occupying tracks 11, 12, 13 and 14 of Disc 3 of his almost complete set of Beethoven’s piano sonatas. But for Bruce Hungerford’s performance placed in the ambitus of the Bach Guild’s Big Beethoven Piano Box, this sonata is in only two movements:
I. Andante — Allegro — Andante — Allegro molto e vivace
II. Adagio con espressione — Allegro vivace
Of course it’s possible neither of those two pianists saw it divided either of those ways.
Beethoven switches to C minor for the scherzo of this sonata.
In the last two measures of what we could call the second movement we find an example of Beethoven wishing the piano had more bass notes. Ricordi edition editor Alfredo Casella gives a footnote:
In the Ricordi edition of Beethoven's piano sonatas, editor Alfredo Casella gives a footnote in Italian, French and English: "On the modern pianoforte[,] it is preferable thus to complete the undoubted intentions of the composer :"
This is to be followed without a break by the Adagio con espressione.
In order to simplify the notation, I have omitted some low notes from the third measure.
The finale is cool and confident.
Using a hairpin to represent a crescendo is an anachronism here.
Now on to the more famous sonata of the pair, the Sonata in C-sharp minor, Opus 27, No. 2, nicknamed “Moonlight.” The key is one which Beethoven used for music of great melancholy throughout his career (see the Opus 131 String Quartet, for example). The sonata begins with triplets outlining a slow harmonic progression.
Without the figuration, the main melody is rather unremarkable, but it has wound up in the subconscious of at least one later great composer.
The famous melody from Ludwig van Beethoven's PIano Sonata in C-sharp minor, Opus 27, No. 2, colloquially known as the Moonlight Sonata.
We find an echo of that melody in Chopin’s Prelude in E minor, Opus 28, No. 4.
The right hand melody from Frédéric Chopin's Prelude in E minor, Opus 28, No. 4.
That opening adagio is followed by very consoling music in D-flat major.
Then we’re back to C-sharp minor for the very turbulent finale.
No shortage of pianists for this one. I went with Claudio Arrau, probably a performance from earlier in his career, I surmise from the video being in black and white.
Besides having a narrower range, the instruments of Beethoven’s day had a very wiry sound, especially at forte and louder. I wanted Petra Somlai on fortepiano, but YouTube won’t let me embed the video here. I did find a video of Mako Kodama playing both of the Opus 27 sonatas on fortepiano. Not sure why there are two instruments on stage.
There are several different arrangements of the Moonlight Sonata, including at least two in which the piano is supplemented by other instruments. Alicia Keys played an arrangement for piano and string quartet at a memorial for Kobe Bryant.
Several months ago, I came across a fascinating big band version, don’t know if it’s in the original key but it doesn’t matter, it’s very fun.
It was in a comment on the open thread on music in C-sharp minor that someone brought up this rock arrangement of the finale of the Moonlight Sonata.
The open thread question: What is your favorite interpretation or arrangement of Beethoven’s Opus 27 sonatas?
Bonus question: Can you think of an evocative nickname for Opus 27, No. 1?