Joshua Lynsen reports
Dean slams gay marriage on '700 Club'
DNC issues clarification as HRC joins gay groups' condemnations
Democratic Party Chair Howard Dean has contradicted his party's platform and infuriated gay rights advocates by saying the party's platform states "marriage is between a man and a woman."
"The Democratic Party platform from 2004 says marriage is between a man and a woman," Dean said May 10 during a "700 Club" program hosted by conservative Christian leader Pat Robertson on his Christian Broadcasting Network.
The Actual DNC and 2004 Democratic Party Position
I'm impressed that our network of progressive activists here were so quick and spotting this misrepresentation of our 2004 Democratic Party platforms position and thank Lolligolli for her persistent and extensive work and at least a dozen previous diaries on this topic over the last year.
This is yet another victory for the grass roots power of the people that his the strongest weapon in our progressive arsenal.
And I believe many other's are saddened that the focus of this defensive counter-attack had to be Howard Dean, one of the previous champions of grass roots progressive causes, and one of the heros this Daily Kos site was originaly founded to support and raise funds for.
Which also leads me to acknowledge HoundDog statements last night, where he spoke strongly in support of our party's true position and in defense of the the GLBT community, but also, articulated all of his comments in contingency of a Howard Dean and DNC retraction and apoligy which he expected and was correct about.
We all can make mistakes. However, quick correction and recommittment to our collective principles and committments to our loyal coalition of Democratic stakeholders and voting blocks is equally important.
I do not believe Howard Dean and the DNC statements are sufficient in this regard, but steps in the right direction.
That statement contradicts the Democratic National Committee's official stance, adopted in 2004. The '04 party platform indicates that marriage is an issue that should be left to the states to resolve, taking no position on whether or not states should marry same-sex couples.
"We support full inclusion of gay and lesbian families in the life of our nation and seek equal responsibilities, benefits, and protections for these families," the platform says.
Howard Dean's Retraction
Here is Howard Dean's retratction.
The DNC issued a statement May 11 clarifying Dean's remarks on the "700 Club."
"I misstated the Democratic Party's platform, which does not say that marriage should be limited to a man and a woman, but says the party is committed to full inclusion of gay and lesbian families in the life of our nation and leaves the issue to the states to decide," Dean is quoted as saying in the statement.
"The Democratic Party remains committed to equal protection under the law for all Americans. How we achieve that goal continues to be the subject of a contentious debate, but our party continues to oppose constitutional amendments that seek to short circuit the debate on how to achieve equality for all Americans."
Human Rights Campaign Rally To Defense Of Gay Rights Organizations Criticizing Dean's Misrepresentations of Official Democratic and DNC
Gay organizations were quick to criticize Dean, saying this is just the latest in a series of missteps by the former Vermont governor on gay issues.
"Howard Dean puts his foot in his mouth so often that he should open a pedicure wing in the DNC during his tenure," Log Cabin Republicans President Patrick Guerriero said Wednesday. "Howard Dean's positions on LGBT issues have changed more often than the weather in New England, where he's from."
The Human Rights Campaign refused to accept that Dean's remarks were an accidental misrepresentation of the party's possition and issued a strongly worded statement on Thursday, May 11, condemning the remarks.
"Governor Dean's comments weren't a mere slip of the tongue but a glaring reminder of the governor's lack of leadership on this issue," said Human Rights Campaign President Joe Solmonese.
"As we face a Senate vote in June that threatens to put discrimination in our Constitution, Governor Dean should not only have known better but he should have used the opportunity to speak out about the lack of values involved in the current constitutional debate," Solmonese said, referring to the upcoming vote on the "Marriage Protection Amendment," which would ban states from marrying gay couples.
Solmonese said the DNC's clarification was "a step in the right direction," but that Dean has failed to convey a "commitment to equality."
I agree with Solmonese. Many here in my diary last night on this accused those of us who support basic human rights, equality, and our consititution 14th amendment of having a "hissy fit." This further demeaning and degrading of those of us who believe we are still fighting for achieve Martin Luther King Jr.'s fight to achieve "The Dream" of equality for all Americans and all of God's children around the world find this kind of language to be insulting and revealing a lack of understanding our our party's core principles and commitments to our loyal constituents and base voters.
Jo Wyrick, interim executive director of National Stonewall Democrats, a gay partisan group, also said that Dean was not accurately representing the Democratic Party's views on marriage.
"Democrats do not believe that the federal government should forcefully dictate family policy for individual states, as championed by congressional Republicans and the Bush administration," she said in a statement issued May 10. "Therefore, we strongly point out that Governor Dean incorrectly spoke when stating that the 2004 Democratic Party platform defines marriage as between a man and a woman."
National Gay And Lesbian Force Denounce Dean's Misreprenstation And Return DNC Money: Advocates Call For Boycott of DNC
Several last night in my diary on reporting Dean's misrepresentation announced they will stop their monthly donations to the DNC. I encourage you all to send you money directly to organizations like the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force who have returned the money they had received from the DNC in protest. I will get their address and other true progressive organizations and candidates supporting human rights, equality, and individual rights.
Within hours of the program's broadcast, the National Gay & Lesbian Task Force denounced Dean's misrepresentation.
"Disturbingly, this is not the first time he has misrepresented this important and affirming plank [of the Democratic Party platform], and he has been asked before to correct the record and to cease making these misleading statements," said Matt Foreman, executive director of the Task Force.
"Governor Dean's record on lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender issues since becoming DNC chair has been sorely and sadly lacking," Foreman said. "The Democratic Party chair should stand by and fight for the party's own platform and values."
On May 2, Dean fired the Democratic Party's gay outreach adviser Donald Hitchcock. The firing came less than a week after Hitchcock's domestic partner, Paul Yandura, a longtime party activist, accused Dean of failing to take adequate steps to defend gay rights.
Foreman said in response to Dean's "pandering and insulting interview" with the Christian Broadcasting Network, the Task Force would return a $5,000 donation it received from the DNC.
"We do so with great sadness, knowing that the Democratic Party has long been a champion of our rights," he said. "We urge [Dean] to take the money we are returning today and spend it to defeat these attacks on LGBT people and our families."
Guerriero applauded the Task Force for taking a principled stand, and said Dean's frequent flubs on gay issues are doing gays more harm than good.
"It's not good for the movement as a whole," Guerriero said, "and he should be held accountable for these types of actions."
In an interview May 11, John Marble, communications director of National Stonewall Democrats, said that Dean should move forward by rallying Democrats and gay voters.
"I think that Governor Dean has a strong vision for how to move the party forward, and I truly believe that he has a plan to motivate our community to support Democrats," he said. "However, it will be to the benefit of the party for the DNC to proactively present their vision in a public way."
Marble said Stonewall Democrats and other gay organizations, remain ready to partner with the DNC.
"I think it's really important for the DNC to seize this opportunity," he said, "and not let it slip by."
Dean and gay Dems
The blow-up over Dean's "700 Club" appearance and the firing of Hitchcock are only the latest in a series of public confrontations between Dean and gay Democrats, who had been among his strongest supporters.
Last year, Dean upset some gay Democratic activists by eliminating the DNC constituency desk system, including the GLBT outreach desk. He said he replaced the desk system with a new system of integrating constituency outreach work throughout all DNC offices and programs.
Dean said the new system would be an improvement over the previous system, and that the party would expand its gay outreach efforts.
But some gay Democrats were further angered in February, when the DNC released its "Annual Report to the Grassroots," which omitted any mention of gays or the party's gay outreach efforts. Activists pointed to a similar grassroots report issued a year earlier by Dean's predecessor, Terry McAuliffe, which included a detailed account of the party's gay outreach program.
DNC officials insisted then that the six-page grassroots report issued by Dean was intended to be a brief, preliminary account of Dean's plan to rebuild the party by strengthening its field operation in all 50 states.
Then, six weeks ago, gay rights leaders met with eight prominent Democratic senators to air their complaints about the party's "tortuous" positions on marriage and other issues.
Dean's trouble with gay Democrats comes after gays were credited with playing a crucial early role in the former Vermont governor's 2004 presidential run, raising large sums and generating word-of-mouth support based on Dean's role signing into law his state's landmark civil unions law in 2000.
Conclusions
This sad equivication from our Democratic Party comes on top of our national party's betrayal of Pennsylvania's Woman and other pro-choice and progressive voters with the early backing and anointment of anti-choice and socially conservative Bob Casey. I am still trying to track down to what extent the DNC, DLC, and DCCC have had any role in differential funding supporting Bob Casey and not supporting true progressives Chuck Pennacchio and Alan Sandal prior to the PA primary.
Many PA progressives feel that our primaries have been inappropriately sandbagged by party officials. And want to know to what extent our own financial and other support is being used to work against or own best interests.
One consequence of our national party's betrayal of core progressive voters is that we now will need to win 52 Senate Seats to gain an effective majority of the Senate when it comes down to votes for the many Supreme Court Nomination that will come up in the 2006 to 2012 term.
Progressive's need to get on top of this and regain control of our own mechanisms of political representation. But I believe we can still do this from within the Democratic Party. I highly recommend pro-choice, GLBT, other progressives read the recent joint diary by Lolligolli and HoundDog, two of our strongest progressive advocates, which was entitle something like Core Democratic Principles and Commitments.
They argue well that progressives like ourselves are the in fact the mainstream and most representative of our Party's 5 Decades long commitments to full equality, human, civil, and individual rights in the tradition of our Constitution's 14th amendment and Martin Luther King's dream.
We most not renounce the Democrat party but still here and fight for it heart and soul with the triangulating consultants and those who have lost their way.
We will win, because we are on the right side of this long battle for equal rights, and freedom for all Americans. And as soon as we get back our feet here, we need to take this battle around the world, where many have not yet tasted the benefits of the Dream.
But in the words of the old Chinese saying:
The journey of a thousand miles begins with the first step.
And it's clear to me that we still have substantial work to do right here at Daily Kos before we can clam that the majoirity of our progressive allies agree that that our party's historical committment to woman, people of color, religious and ethnic minorities, and the disabled, apply equal well to a woman's right to choose and the GLBT commnities.
But I beleive if we discuss it extensively, politely, and in the spirit of long term friends and past allies, that the overwhelming majority of us here at Daily Kos and other progressive sights will agree with HoundDog and Lolligolli that our committments to equality, civil, individual, and human rights for all Americans and people of the world is an indivisible part of a higher level committment to the rights and preemeneence of the individual in the greater constitutional balance between individual rights and those powers we voluntarily cede to the government as our freely chosen "social contract" to act as our collecteve agent to protect the common good.