Why does the government owe you health insurance?
Idaho Congressman Mike Simpson asked a senior citizen this question at a community forum at Idaho State University more than three years ago, after the man challenged him about why the government doesn't do more to help the uninsured.
Simpson's position hasn't changed much since then. But Obama's maneuvers have Republicans hopping around, dancing to a new tune, in a desparate attempt to sound like they have solutions to America's health care mess.
The music begins with an obligatory lyric:
According to Simpson's camp:
now that the U.S. House of Representatives/
has passed H.R. 3962/
if it is signed into law/
the initiative will be the first step/
to government takeover of healthcare/
From a recent press release:
"Pelosi is touting that she just passed legislation to make health care more affordable, but nothing could be further from the truth," said Simpson. "The frightening reality for the American taxpayer and anyone who will need health care in the future is that she is hiding the true costs of this legislation and doing so in ways that will be disastrous to our nation’s long-term fiscal health."
The Republican leader breaks it down like this:
In addition to the TRILLION dollar cost of H.R. 3962, the bill also contains the following provisions:
Includes a "surtax" on individuals making over a certain income, more than half of which are actually small businesses. Moreover, this tax will continue to entrap more and more middle class Americans every year as their incomes go up because, like the Alternative Minimum Tax, it is not indexed for inflation.
Drastically expands Medicaid, from 100% to 150% of federal poverty level. Starting in 2014, it will cost states, including Idaho, $34 billion to comply with another unfunded federal mandate--something state budgets simply cannot afford during these difficult economic times.
Those individuals who choose not to purchase health insurance will have to pay a penalty. Americans will no longer get to choose whether or not they will purchase health insurance in the future because government will have already made that decision.
Simpson said that people who already have health insurance through their employers will be at risk of losing it. According to this tune, H.R. 3962 will implement expensive new mandates on all employer-provided health insurance that businesses must either comply or be faced with new taxes and penalties.
For many employers, it will make more business sense to eliminate jobs or drop employees’ health insurance and pay the penalties rather than comply with Uncle Sam’s new rules, or so the song goes.
"During a time of record budget deficits, we cannot afford to create another trillion plus dollar entitlement program, like this bill does. However, we all agree that our current health system needs reform," said Simpson. "I will be the first to admit that it is irresponsible to just say no to the current health legislation without offering commonsense alternatives that will actually bring down the cost of health care. For these reasons, I support measures to make health care more affordable and accessible without further drowning our nation in debt.
Simpson and 66 of his colleagues have cosponsored H.R. 1086, the HEALTH Act. They claim that this bill would create effective medical malpractice reform by putting an end to junk lawsuits by placing caps on noneconomic damages and limiting attorney fees. According to his conservative colleagues, this bill would save as much as $120 billion in wasteful spending by stemming the practice of defensive medicine.
Simpson is also a cosponsor of H.R. 2607, the Small Business Healthcare Fairness Act. The Republican spin here is that this action would allow small businesses to band together through associations to buy health care coverage. Their theory is that since
large corporations and even labor unions already leverage their size and buying power to secure lower premiums and rates when buying health insurance for their employees and members
-- this bill would give America’s small businesses the same advantages and make health care coverage for their employees more affordable.
Simpson also supports some types of reforms that Democrats have vigorously advocated for decades, such as reforms that would prohibit insurers from denying coverage to people because of a pre-existing condition. Simpson also supports reforms to make the purchase of health insurance for individuals tax-exempt like it is for employer-sponsored insurance. He also believes that we need to do more as a country to focus on prevention and early intervention.
Simpson also supports prescription drug re-importation, which would control prescription drug costs by allowing Americans to buy FDA-approved prescription drugs from places such as Canada and Europe where drugs are sold for much less money.
But where have such ideas been during the entire Bush administration?
Sounding like a line from a bad commercial jingle, Simpson sang:
"I am disappointed to see that once again, the Democrats have failed to listen to the American people and passed health reform that all Americans could support," Simpson said.
And Republicans have passed such reform???