The quotes are all over the news, how the moral Catholic church is being forced to pay to support something that goes against core beliefs.
I offer some analogies:
If the Jehovah's Witnesses ran a university, would it be acceptable for their insurance plans to exclude coverage for blood transfusions for all employees of whatever faith?
In the days before humulin, would it have been acceptable for a large (nonchurch) Hindu organization with thousands of nonHindu employees to exclude coverage of the most common and readily available type of insulin (from cows)? Could they have mandated the only insulin to be covered was pig insulin? Wouldn't that equally go against any Jewish or Muslim employee's religion?
Would it be fine for Yeshiva university to have excluded porcine heart valves from its insurance plan? How about currently excluding porcine factor VIII for hemophiliacs whose antibodies attack the human version? What about if it was a large Muslim organization instead?
It's an emotional issue to many, but change the religion and excluded item, and it looks a little different.