Pennsylvania, Michigan and Wisconsin are being run by competent governors. Independents are the voters who will listen to those who are calm and want to debate/problem solve. Plus they want competency and decency that is not too far left/nor too far right.
Independents want to focus on policy not personal as the reasons for why they are voting for or against. Furthermore, it is specific decisions and ideas/vision.
Arizona is a bipartisan purple moderate Anti Trump anti far right Mccain-Romney Maverick Mormon Moderate Conservative state.
Georgia is a bipartisan purple moderate progressive liberal state (with Warnock- Osaoff) and Stacey Abrams.