I imagine all of us are a little tired of hearing men say what they have decided women should do with their reproductive capacity, so let's consider the fact that we as a species reproduce sexually as opposed to asexually (no partner needed). By definition sexual reproduction means it takes a gamete from TWO different sexes to make an embryo. Time to talk about sperm, and the behavior of the sperm carriers.
If birth control should not be covered by insurance, that should mean that vasectomies would not be covered. But they are. If birth control should not be available to women, then neither should condoms be available for men. And yes, I know that condoms are also used for disease prevention, but if you follow the medieval thinking of Santorum and his ilk then the rules are that only virgin males and females get married and have sex only with each other, so disease is not an issue. Or at least not for the virtuous, and the others be damned (if you need a review of medieval thinking, please reread Dante's Inferno).
Now for the consequences, which of course would be babies, and lots of them. These babies need TWO parents supporting them, so I have a nifty plan to make sure that this happens. Everyone at birth gets a social security number and this is tied to a sample of their DNA. It will then be easy to track and bill for child support any daddies who slip through the net after depositing sperm and hitting the road. Or mommies who try to do the same.
And as John Hodgman would say- problem solved.