Skip to main content

The national exit polls showed nearly two-thirds of those identifying themselves as Asian voted for Obama, a strong majority.  Let's use the census data to find some neighborhoods with heavy concentrations of Asian Americans and examine the election results.

Here's a promising place to start:

Free Image Hosting at www.ImageShack.us
Click to enlarge.

This map shows percent Asian by precinct; there is a nice variation from none (yellow) up to about three-quarters (dark blue).

We should see a corresponding pattern in the precinct results then - here, dark blue shows strong support for Obama:

Free Image Hosting at www.ImageShack.us
Click to enlarge.

Oops...  

There's certainly a pattern there, but not what we might have expected from the nationwide exit polls.

Ten Second Summary
The Asian-American population has been growing and changing rapidly over the past several decades.  Politically, there is strong and growing support for Democrats, on average.  The Asian-American electorate is far from uniform, however, with very different voting patterns in different communities.

We Are Not All of Us Alike, Reprise

Clearly, the population shown in the map above did not support Obama for president.  Some of you may have even recognized the neighborhood - it's part of the Ninth Ward in New Orleans - that's Lake Pontchartrain in the upper left corner.  It is the center of a strong Vietnamese-American community,  and home turf for Republican Congressman Joseph Cao.  I estimate support for Obama at 5-8% in this community.  (We can get such a good estimate in part because the Louisiana Secretary of State provides the racial breakdown of those who voted in each precinct.)  As to why this community did not support Obama (or Kerry for that matter), I will note that it was founded by people fleeing communism - but I just don't know.  The point is that it's a very bad idea to assume that all Asian-American communities (let alone individuals) are generally supportive of Democrats.  We are not all of us alike.

Yet all evidence shows that, in aggregate, Asian-Americans nationwide did indeed strongly support Obama and Democrats in general.  In fact, in a previous diary we saw that support for the Democratic presidential candidate was growing rapidly among Asian-Americans, from 31% for Clinton in 1992 to 62% for Obama in 2008.  

What is the reason behind this trend?  Part of the answer could be a bit of identity politics - after all, Obama lived in Indonesia as a child and part of his family is Asian-American.  But that certainly can't explain the entire trend, as it doesn’t apply to Kerry in 2004.  

Everything Changed in the Sixties
The latest census estimate is that there are about 15,000,000 Asian-Americans (including citizens and non-citizens) in the country - or ten times the population in 1970.  Over the past 40 years, there have been about 10,000,000 immigrants from Asia.

Here's a graph showing the number of immigrants from selected Asian countries.  (Remember, not everybody who comes to this country stays, not everybody who stays becomes a citizen, and it typically takes years to become a citizen.)

Free Image Hosting at www.ImageShack.us
Click to enlarge.

After a long history of preventing Asian immigration to the United States and denying citizenship even to those of Asian descent who were born here, immigration from Asia started in earnest following the reforms of 1965.  The proportions of immigrants from various countries has varied over time, leading to dramatically shifting ethnic compositions in the Asian-American population.  In 1960, prior to the new wave of immigrants, almost half of Asians were of Japanese descent; in 2000, it was less than 10%.  Meanwhile, those with (Asian) Indian ancestry now make up 16% of those identifying as Asian.

Free Image Hosting at www.ImageShack.us
Click to enlarge.

Diversity of Politics
What if some of the earlier groups to immigrate were more likely to support Republicans, while those who immigrated more recently were more likely to support Democrats?  Wouldn't it be fun to see the Asian category broken down a bit?  Really, we wouldn't necessarily expect Pakistani-Americans and Korean-Americans to have the same politics, as a group.

Well, through a massive effort, the Asian American Legal Defense and Education Fund did just that.  Their exit poll surveyed 16,665 Asian Americans in 11 languages at 113 polling sites in 11 states and DC.  Wow!  Another group surveyed 1237 Asian-Americans in Southern California.

Finally, using census data and precinct-level results, I estimated support for several additional Asian ethnicities as well.

A word of caution: the results are not necessarily representative of Asian-Americans nationwide.  Both the AALDEF exit poll and my estimates focus on precincts with high concentrations of Asian-Americans, and urban and suburban areas.  The National Election Pool exit poll, on the other hand, probably has the opposite problem, in that they quite possibly didn't conduct any interviews in heavily Asian-American precincts. Previously we have seen there may be a tendency for those who live in more demographically uniform communities to vote in a more uniform manner, so keep this in mind as you pick throught the following data.

Looking at all sources of data we get these numbers:

Free Image Hosting at www.ImageShack.us
Click to enlarge.

One of the important things to notice is the major difference between the voting behavior of Vietnamese-American communities in California (Los Angeles) and New Orleans.  Again, we are not all of us alike.  The different results for all Asian-Americans between the National Election Pool exit poll and the AALDEF exit poll also stand out.  Because of the factors discussed above, I would guess the 'true' results, nationwide, would be somewhere between the two.

Returning to the question of demographic change over time, indeed, we see that the group with the most rapid growth in its share of the Asian-American population - Indians - also has much stronger support for Obama than Koreans, Chinese, or Filipinos.  However, this is balanced out by Vietnamese.  Only a few points of the increase in support for Democrats can be attributed to the changing ethnic composition of Asian-Americans.

Another possible reason for the increase in support for Democrats among Asian-Americans as a whole might be that immigrants fleeing their home countries for political reasons may have been attracted to the more belicose anti-communist rhetoric of the Republicans, whereas their children, and more recent immigrants, don't care about such rhetoric as much.  Let me be clear that this is anecdote-based speculation on my part.  

Finally, the last few decades have brought about a rise in identification and advocacy as Asian-Americans, as opposed to disparate and isolated ethnic groups.  I've read several sources indicating this rise in Asian-American self-identification was spurred by the brutal murder of Vincent Chin in 1982.  Vincent Chin was a Chinese-American bludgeoned to death with a baseball bat in Detroit by a white autoworker and his stepson after an altercation in which, assuming he was Japanese, the attackers yelled at him "It's because of you motherfuckers that we're out of work!"  The underlying sentiments - Asian-Americans are not Real Americans, they're all alike anyways, and they're to blame for current problems - have waxed and waned in public discourse over the intervening years, along with the predictable and tragic results.  What seems clear to me is that such sentiments are part of a nativist, anti-immigration, anti-non-white-American strategy on behalf of the Republican party, and Asian-Americans have been paying attention.  

Back to the AALDEF

There are some more interesting numbers in the exit polls, however:  native-born Asian-Americans were more likely to support Obama (87%) than naturalized citizens (74%).  This is consistent with the anecdotally-based idea above, at least, but far from proof - it could simply be a generation gap similar to that seen among other demographics.  It does, however, clearly dash the hopes of Republicans that the children of immigrants might be more likely to vote for Republicans.  Indeed, in a separate New York City exit poll, foreign-born citizens of all races except "Other" were slightly more likely to vote Republican than native born citizens.

Another point to emphasize is that 35% of voters in the AALDEF exit poll had limited English proficiency.  Without the Voting Rights Act, many of these people may not have been able to vote.

Hey Wait a Minute!
Isn't the Middle East part of Asia too?  Yes indeed.  In fact, the AALDEF survey included Arab-Americans.  In this diary I've mostly stuck to the census definition of Asian as a racial category.  We'll get to the rest of Asia tomorrow.

__________________
This diary is the fifth in a series taking a close look at the 2008 electorate and exploring three themes: diversity within demographics, progressive feedback loops, and demographic change.  

Tomorrow: The West Asian American Electorate:  Rapid Change

Cross posted at Open Left.

Diaries in this series (updated list):

Looking Back
Alternate History
Why Republicans Should Be Really Scared
African-Americans – We Are Not All of Us Alike
East and South Asian Americans – Diverse and Growing
West Asian Americans – Rapid Change
Native Americans – Increasing Participation
Islander Americans – In Need of More Representation
Native Alaskans – An Economic Factor?
Latino Electorate – Increasing Influence
European-Americans – Tribal Politics Persist
“Americans” – You Might Be Surprised
Appalachia – Surprisingly Democratic
Why Republicans Should Be Really, Really Scared
Why Republicans Should Be Really, Really, Really Scared
A Few More Tidbits

Related 2008 electorate diaries:
Maps: Blue America and the Changing Electorate
Maps: Obama and White Evangelicals

Originally posted to dreaminonempty on Wed Nov 04, 2009 at 06:10 AM PST.

Poll

How many Representatives have districts with >10% Asian population?

26%5 votes
31%6 votes
10%2 votes
5%1 votes
26%5 votes

| 19 votes | Vote | Results

EMAIL TO A FRIEND X
Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags

?

More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

  •  Note on poll (6+ / 0-)

    More specifically, more than 10% of the population choosing the racial category 'Asian alone' in the 2006-2008 3-year data from the American Community Survey, part of the census.

  •  How did Asian Americans vote in NJ? (0+ / 0-)

    I don't think Corzine courted the Asian American vote enough.

  •  Asian Pacific Americans for Progress (2+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    Nulwee, icemilkcoffee

    Thanks for the post. For more info on progressive Asian Americans, please go to our website at apaforprogress.org.  We're the former AAPI's for Dean.

    In terms of AAPI demographics, you also have to consider the fact that the majority of us live in urban areas (cities and suburbs) and blue states (CA, HI, NY, NJ, WA, VA, etc.), and we are the least religious and most educated of all racial groups. We're not really built for the current Republican party. Those are just some of the reasons we have trended away.

    P.S. - The murder victim is actually Vincent "Chin," not "Chen," and our organization just did a new documentary on the case.  Our sold-out LA premiere is tonight.

    (I tried commenting over at Openleft, too, but for some reason it couldn't find the page.)

  •  Thanks for this newest diary (0+ / 0-)

    Read your last several with some interest. Wow!

    These clowns claim to admire him [Cronkite] but do not wish to emulate him - GUGA

    by Nulwee on Wed Nov 04, 2009 at 09:07:56 PM PST

  •  Anecdotes that support your theories about (0+ / 0-)

    the differences between 1st gen immigrants and their children:

    I know several 1st gen Asian "cold war Republicans" for whom the struggle against Communism was and is the defining feature of their lives & political identities, similar to the Cuban community in FL. Their children, from what I can see, do not define themselves as the children of victims of Communism.

    I have heard the argument that Asian-Americans are or will be "honorary white people" due to the upwardly mobile nature of several of the notable subgroups. Someone said to me, "The Irish were actively discriminated against earlier this century and no one cares about that now. Same with the Jews." There is some truth to this; certainly, the Asian-American experience in America is vastly different from the experience of Hispanics. However, I gotta believe that Asian ethnic "otherness" is more fixed than Irish or even Jewish ethnicity, less likely to fade away. Certainly Republican anti-immigrant rhetoric is no help.

    I remember the Vincent Chin murder. That for me was an aha moment; it crystalized a feeling that the Caucasian experience in America is unalterably different than the non-Caucasian experience. At some point in life of non-Caucasians in America (black, Hispanic, Asian), regardless of socio-economic status, one will face

    the assertion that non-white=not true American.

    BTW, great diary. I'm glad this was rescued.

    "It's not enough to be right. You still have to use your nice voice." -said by my then six-year-old daughter; "Love binds us all."-willb48

    by be the change you seek on Wed Nov 04, 2009 at 10:08:17 PM PST

    •  Who gets to be white? (1+ / 0-)
      Recommended by:
      be the change you seek

      Thanks for your comment.  Everybody seems to have similar anecdotes about the generation gap, so it is seeming more likely to be true.  Still, I wish there were a poll asking about attitudes towards communism by age.  

      Another point you raise, It seems like one way to parse the history of this country is be asking who was called white?  Over time, more and more ethnic groups have been folded into the 'white' or 'honorary white' category as new 'threats' from new groups of immigrants have materialized...

  •  Why I will NEVER vote Republican (0+ / 0-)

    I grew up in CA in the 80's and 90's. Most of the people I live around were white "Christians" who were the most bigoted, racist, ignorant people ever. If you were n't white and Christian, they were awful to you and there was no recourse when they gouged you or vandalized your property. The cops were their family members or churchmembers. They were all Republicans and had the Republican "my way or the highway" attitude. Most other 2nd gen Asians I know had similar experiences and due to these experiences will NEVER vote for Republicans - even if Republicans figured out how to cure cancer we would never vote for them, even if the Democrats ate babies, we would never vote Repub.

    Of course, since a lot of our families came from rather conservative cultures, our parents voted Republican because of tax issues and also because they were uncomfortable with gay rights and abortion. The Asians I know who are still Republicans grew up in the 80's when they had hide their Asianess to fit in. They grew up during the time of Reagan and still carry that inferiority complex with them to this day. So they are Republicans because they figure it's the safe choice, the red blooded American choice so to speak. A lot of Asians in the south are republicans just so they can fit in - stupid I know because that conservative mindset will never accept them.

    And seriously, Joe Cao should become a Democrat - he already thinks the Republicans are stupid and he won't get elected if he stays a republican anyways, he reps a majority black district. That would be sweet, the Vietnamese and Blacks teaming up to kick ass in Louisiana - it'd be like when Andre the Giant and Hulk teamed up, they'd whoop ass together down there.

    •  Thank you for your comment (0+ / 0-)

      Very interesting to hear your perspective.  Something in it that really resonated with me is the phrase 'they figure it's the safe choice.'  Some groups of immigrants have tried to be over-the-top American, at least in my family, to 'hyperassimilate' so they will be accepted and have the same opportunities as everybody else and avoid (unsuccessfully often) marginilization.  

      I wonder if this is a universal patten among immigrants.  Today, as you say, it seems that 2nd gen Asians are embracing their heritage more than their parents, both culturally and in their politics.  In the 60s & 70s, one cultural current seemed to be 2nd and 3rd generation ethnic white young people embracing their heritage culturally and politically as well, trying to break away from the (perceived) 50s uniformity.  Things that make you go hmmmm.

  •  Generation Stuff (1+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    wu ming

    Great diary! Let me add -- in the community I am familiar with, Taiwanese-Americans, there is a generation gap that I expect is being played out in many Asian-American communities. Older T-A immigrants tend to vote Republican, partly because so many remember Carter's betrayal of Taiwan, and partly because there is a widespread perception that Republicans support Taiwan but Dems do not. But the second and third generations are far more supportive of Dem politics even though they do not agree with Dem China policies.

    Of course, it would have been difficult to provide generational overlays for the maps!

    Michael Turton

    •  OT, but how was that quake in taichung? (0+ / 0-)

      it felt like it was huge down there from the way it throbbed up here in taipei.

      surf putah, your friendly neighborhood central valley samizdat

      by wu ming on Thu Nov 05, 2009 at 04:13:19 AM PST

      [ Parent ]

    •  Taiwanese Americans (0+ / 0-)

      Thanks for you comments.  I was unable to find a geographic location with a large enough concentration of Taiwanese Americans to try to estimate their political voting patters, sadly.

      If I had data by age I'd do the maps - too bad it doesn't exist!

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site