Skip to main content

For any who may be reading this series for the first time: this is a thought experiment where I try to see what would happen if the size of the House of Representatives were doubled to 870 members from 435. This series is both highly theoretical and very unlikely to ever occur.

I almost didn't publish this final diary, I wasn't sure if people would even notice. But thanks to WisJohn, I know I have fans! So even though the timing of this, with only 4 weeks to go until the general election, is not conducive to fantasy redistricting diaries, here it is, the final installment in Doubling the House.

Links to the adopted plans in this diary: Arkansas, Iowa, Kentucky, Minnesota, Oregon

Previous Doubling Diaries: CA, PA, TX, WA, MT, NY, AZ, CO, KS, AL, GA, TN, IL, MD, WV, DC, New England, NE, MO, NC, MI, FL, SC, WI, LA, MS, UT, NV, OK, AK, WY, IN, NJ, VA, OH, HI, ND, SD, NM, VT, DE and ID


Arkansas is a unique case. Even after the red bloodbath that was 2010, Democrats managed to hold on to the redistricting trifecta, even while losing two sears in Congress, both due to the incumbent Democrats retirement. However, Gov. Beebe and the legislature showed much more interest in holding on to their legislative majorities than taking back the congressional delegation. And on top of that, Mike Ross, the delegation's last remaining Democrat, made a lot of demands for his district that weakened the map overall, and then abruptly decided he wasn't running for reelection at all. So we will most likely see a 0-4 delegation next year, from a map drawn by Democrats! It's ludicrous.

Anyway, Arkansas gets 8 districts under doubling.

VAP: 58.2 White, 33.2 Black

Tim Griffin (R-Little Rock) lives here. Pulaski County (Little Rock), minus some very white rural precincts at the periphery. President Obama won Pulaski County with 55%, so this is very much a district that Griffin would not want to run in. He'd most likely parachute to the 5th. This is a district that State Senator Joyce Elliott, who was our nominee in 2010, would do well in. Safe D

VAP: 50.3 W, 45.5 B

Open. The Arkansas Delta, including West Memphis and Pine Bluff. There are a couple tendrils into El Dorado, Camden and Hope to bring up the Black %age, so this district may even satisfy the VRA, giving black Americans the opportunity to elect. Regardless of that primary outcome, this is Safe D

VAP: 77.4 W, 16.6 B

Open; Mike Ross (D-Prescott) is retiring. Southwestern corner of the state. This one I'm a little wobbly on. It contains some of the best counties for Mark Pryor's first run at the Senate in 2002, plus some of Jimmie Lou Fisher's best counties in her failed run for the Governorship in the same year. However, I did cut out a few black precincts to put in the 2nd. Since this doesn't reach up into the very red northwest corner of the state like the current AR-04 does, I'll be bullish and say Lean D, assuming the right candidate.

VAP: 90 W

Open. West central, including some Little Rock suburbs. Nothing to be said, this would be very Republican. Largest city: Benton. Safe R

VAP: 87.6 W, 7.6 B

Open, though like I said I believe Griffin would run here. East central, with some Little Rock suburbs. Largest city: Conway. Safe R

VAP: 91.8 W

Rick Crafword (R-Jonesboro) lives here. Northeast corner. Crawford, who currently sits in the most Democratic district in the state, for what that's worth, would breathe a sigh of relief that he got this district. Safe R

VAP: 83.7 W, 8.4 Hispanic

Steve Womack (R-Rogers) lives here. The northwest corner, minus Fayetteville. Safe R

VAP: 80.7 W, 11.1 H

Open. Fayetteville, Springdale and Bentonville. I hold out hope that as this grows and gets more Hispanic, it will get more competitive. But for now, the HQ of Walmart is Safe R
Arkansas goes from a 1-3 delegation in a likely 0-4 map to a 3-5 map. Counts as an improvement.


Iowa gets 8 districts

Iowa redistricts by a non-partisan commission, which also is forbidden to split counties. I tried to hold true to that.

VAP: 93.5 W
58.4 Obama

Bruce Braley (D-Waterloo) lives here. Northeast corner, with the cities of Waterloo, Cedar Falls and Mason City. Braley is safe. Safe D

VAP: 89.9 W
58 Obama

Open. The Iowa half of the Quad Cities, plus Clinton, Dubuque and Muscatine. I imagine this would be very Safe D.

VAP: 89.9 W
63 Obama

David Loebsack (D-Iowa City) lives here. Cedar Rapids and Iowa City. Loebsack adds a few points of safety. Safe D

VAP: 94.2 W
49.5 Obama (win by 1900)

Open. The southern tier of the state, with the largest cities being Burlington and Ottumwa. This would probably be a district that Kerry and Gore lost be a healthy margin, so it would take a very good candidate for our side to win this one. Christie Vilsack, who most likely lives in Mount Pleasant with her husband, might be our best shot. Lean D if Vilsack runs.

VAP: 94.1 W
44.2 Obama

Open. The northwest corner, going down into the east central. The weakest Dem district, I think Steve King might be tempted to run here to avoid being Iowa Dem's favorite target cycle after cycle. Safe R

VAP: 90.9 W, 5.5 H
48.5 Obama

Steve King (R-Kiron) lives here, though he may run in the 5th instead. West central, including Sioux City, Council Bluffs and Fort Dodge. Assuming Vilsack runs in the 4th instead of here, it would take a good candidate for us to win this, with maybe some leniency if King stays in the district. Lean R to be safe.

VAP: 92 W
51 Obama

Tom Latham (R-Ames) lives here. Des Moines suburbs on all sides, including Ames and Marshalltown. Latham has enough of a moderate reputation to do well here, and without an incumbent Democrat to run against, he'd probably survive, though it would be quite a fight once the seat was open. Likely R

VAP: 82.8 W, 5.7 B, 6.5 H
57.8 Obama

Leonard Boswell (D-Des Moines) lives here. This is the one county split I allowed, since Polk County is simply too big for one congressional district under Doubling. So this is Des Moines and West Des Moines, and pretty much nothing else. Boswell, who is in genuine danger this election cycle running against Tom Latham, would be very safe in this district by contrast. Safe D
Iowa's new congressional map could probably be called 2-0-2, and this November it could go anywhere from a 4-0 to a 2-2. But under Doubling, I have us at 5-3, assuming Christie Vilsack runs in the 4th.


The Bluegrass State gets 12 districts.

Kentucky is a classic Demosaur state, perhaps one of the few left, with Arkansas and West Virginia. Registered Democrats still outnumber Republicans, and Democrats just swept 5 out of 6 statewide elections in 2011. They currently hold the House of Representatives and the Governorship, while Republicans hold the Senate. I imagine we could get a map fairly similar to this under Doubling, although most likely less gerrymandered.


VAP: 92.3 W
36.9 Obama

Open. The western tip. Largest city: Paducah. This district would have voted for Beshear by wide margins, even in his first run in 2007, but I have no idea if it could support a Democrat federally. Likely R to be safe.

VAP: 87.9 W, 7.3 B
34.5 Obama

Ed Whitfield (R-Hopkinsville) lives here. Brett Guthrie (R-Bowling Green) might also live here, or in the 3rd, but he would run here, since the 3rd is inhospitable. West/west central Kentucky, including parts of Bowling Green and Greenville. Hopkinsville is likely the largest city. I would say a primary with Whitfield and Guthrie would favor Whitfield due to his seniority, but he could also choose to retire. Safe R no matter what.

VAP: 85.4 W, 9.1 B
48.4 Obama (McCain win by ~2000)

Open; like I said Brett Guthrie's home might be here, but he's very unlikely to try a run here. A good old-fashioned Ohio River gerrymander, with the cities of Bardstown, Owensville and Henderson, along with some gerrymander tendrils into Elizabethtown, Bowling Green and Madisonville. This could possibly support a centrist Democrat, but any Blue Dog would be completely safe here. Safe D

VAP: 80.1 W, 11.8 B
51.2 Obama

Jefferson County district #1. John Yarmuth (D-Louisville) could live in either one, and he'd have to make a choice between taking a not-insignificant hit in Obama's performance (from 56%), to running in a district that may be too liberal for him. Regardless, I think this would be Safe D

VAP: 66.7 W, 26.6 B
61.2 Obama

Jefferson County district #2. See above for Yarmuth's dilemma. If Yarmuth chose not to run here, this district could support a truly liberal Democrat. Safe D


VAP: 94.6 W
27.2 Obama

Hal Rogers (R-Somerset), Chair of the House Appropriations Committee, lives here. South central Kentucky, with lots of midsize cities. Between this one and the 9th, these are probably the only two districts that didn't vote for Steve Beshear in 2011. More of Rogers' territory is in the 9th though, so he may decide to run there instead. Safe R

VAP: 93 W
34.8 Obama

Open. A very suburban district, it takes in Louisville and Lexington suburbs, including some of the outer Cincinnati suburbs. Another district that Beshear would have done relatively well in, but it's unlikely a Democrat could win here federally.Safe R

VAP: 93.2 W
36.8 Obama

Open; Geoff Davis (R-Hebron) resigned in July. Cincinnati suburbs, the cities of Covington, Florence, etc. Beshear would have won this district, but very narrowly. Doesn't spell good things for national Democrats.Safe R

VAP: 96.5 W
25.7 Obama

Open. Southeast. The most Republican district in the state, the other one that Beshear would have lost, with the 4th. No major cities, but a handful of midsize ones. Safe R

VAP: 95.4 W
45.7 Obama

Open. Coal country, including Elliott County, the county with the longest one-party voting streak in the country (it has voted Democratic since 1870). Some bigger cities would be Ashland and Richmond. A Nick Rahall-type Democrat could do very well here (better, perhaps, since KY-10 is better than the current WV-03). Lean D

VAP: 78.1 W, 12.5 B, 5.3 H
50.8 Obama

Ben Chandler (D-Versailles) lives here. Frankfort and Lexington. Chandler gets much safer so he can rest easy while he plans his statewide run. Safe D
Kentucky goes from a 2-4 delegation in a map where there are a couple theoretical Demosaur districts, but where we have very little chance of winning, to a 5-7 map, including at least one solid Democrat joining John Yarmuth. So I think everyone would be pretty happy.


The Land of 10,000 Lakes gets 15 districts

Minnesota has had a court-drawn map for (at least) the last two redistricting cycles, due to partisan differences between the Governor and the Legislature. So we got a relatively least-change map, although Republican John Kline's district took a small hit and could become an enticing target when it's open. So I just wanted to try to test the limits in my Doubled map.

The Dem average is compiled of "All 2004-2008 statewide races" So a mixed bag in spots, considering Tim Pawlenty's reelection in 2006 and the super close Senate race in 2008, but generally favorable to Democrats.

VAP: 90.1 W
55.8 Obama, 55.1 DFL

Tim Walz (DFL-Mankato) lives here. Basically the current MN-01, with all the reddest parts excised and adding some blue areas along the Mississippi like Red Wing and Inner Grove Heights/Cottage Grove in the MSP area. Walz is rewarded for holding down a marginal district like he has for 3 terms by getting some extra safety. Safe DFL

VAP: 89.7 W, 5.2 H
51.6 Obama, 52.6 DFL

Open. More remnants of MN-01 and MN-02. Closer to the current MN-01 politically, it contains Owatonna and Faribault. Given both the extremeness and brokeness of the MN Republican Party, I'll hazard a guess at Lean DFL.

VAP: 93.2 W
43.3 Obama, 44.1 DFL

John Kline (R-Lakeville) lives here. Parts of MN-02 and MN-01, once again, but the most Republican parts of both. Kline is safe, except from a primary. Safe R

VAP: 93.7 W
61 Obama, 64.8 DFL

Open. A true Iron Range district without any need to go into the MSP metro, this would be safe as can be for Rick Nolan, though he would probably either fall in a primary to a Duluth-area pol or retire, again, before too long. Safe DFL

VAP: 89.6 W
52.1 Obama, 52.5 DFL

Collin Peterson (DFL-Detroit Lakes) lives here. As before, I took his current district, cut out the most Republican parts, and added some more Dem-leaning parts. Peterson is absurdly safe given his profile, and maybe we could even hold it after he's gone. Safe DFL

VAP: 93.3 W
44.3 Obama, 46.3 DFL

Open. Exurban MSP, including St. Cloud. This is where Michelle Bachmann would run, despite living in the 7th. She'd still be in danger due to her lightning rod status, but it would be safe for anyone not her. Likely R

VAP: 90.1 W
43.4 Obama, 42.5 DFL

Erik Paulsen (R-Eden Prairie) lives here. More exurban MSP, the most Republican district in the state. Like Kline, Paulsen is safe except from a primary. Safe R

VAP: 95.2 W
43.5 Obama, 45.4 DFL

Open. Miscellany, leftovers from my MN-12 gerrymander. The whitest district in the state. That's all I got. Safe R

Minneapolis/St. Paul

I split the Twin Cities in ways that locals would probably find criminal, so I don't know for sure which district Keith Ellison (DFL-Minneapolis) and Betty McCollum (DFL-St. Paul), but I'll hazard a guess.

VAP: 82.7 W, 5.3 B, 5.6 Asian
59.3 Obama, 57.2 DFL

Open (?). Apple Valley, Rosemount, Burnsville and Eagan in Dakota County and Bloomington and parts of Minneapolis in Hennepin. Safe DFL

VAP: 83.5 W, 7.8 B
59 Obama, 57.6 DFL

Open (?). Part of Minneapolis, plus Minnetonka and then into very red outer Hennepin County and parts of Wright County. As the bluest of the Minneapolis districts, I imagine Keith Ellison would most likely run here. Safe DFL

VAP: 74.6 W, 11.7 B, 6.8 A
57.5 Obama, 55.7 DFL

Open (?). Parts of Minneapolis, plus Brooklyn Center and Plymouth in Hennepin County, plus parts of Wright County. Ellison could also run here, the high(ish) black and Asian populations could be considered parts of his base. Safe DFL

VAP: 77.9 W, 7.5 B, 7.8 H
63.5 Obama, 62.2 DFL

Michele Bachmann (R-Stillwater) lives here, but like I pointed out above she would run in the 13th with St. Cloud. Most of Washinton County, with parts of both St. Paul and Minneapolis, plus some suburbs in Dakota County. Safe DFL

VAP: 74.4 W, 8.3 B, 5.4 H, 9.7 A
59.2 Obama, 58.8 DFL

Chip Cravaack (R-Lindstrom) lives here. Chisago, Washington and Anoka Counties, but mostly Ramsey County and St. Paul proper. Betty McCollum might run here, or in the 10th. Safe DFL

VAP: 78.5 W, 8.1 B, 5.8 A
57.7 Obama, 57.6 DFL

Open (?). Minneapolis and Champlin in Hennepin County, New Bedford in Ramsey and Fridley in Anoka. Smallest disparity between Obama and average DFL performance here. Safe DFL

VAP: 85.1 W, 5 B, 5.1 A
57 Obama, 56.7 DFL

Open (?). St. Paul, outer Ramsey County and most of Anoka. As I mentioned above, McCollum could choose to run here too. Safe DFL
So, from a 5-3 map that gave us a 4-4 delegation following the 2010 elections, in Doubled we get 11-4! Cravaack gets axed but another crazy Republican gets to join Kline, Paulsen and Bachmann, and they're all in super safe districts so they can't build a profile to run statewide. I'm happy, hopefully you're happy too.


The Beaver State gets 11 districts.

Oregon is a marginally blue state that has been trending bluer as of late, delivering larger margins to our presidential candidates (47-46.5 in 2000, 51-47 in 2004 to 58-40 in 2008). However, Republicans had some big gains in the state legislature in 2010, cutting down our margin in the State Senate to just 2 and actually tying in the State House.

Anyway, here's the map. No political data, but I consulted with our resident Oregonians, SaoMagnifico and James Allen to make the best map I could.

VAP: 83.4 W, 11.3 H

Open. The vast majority of the state, geographically speaking. But very few people live here. Greg Walden was just drawn out of this district, but may want to run here if he wanted a guaranteed job for a while. Safe R

VAP: 88.9 W, 6.2 H

Open. Republican cities of Grants Pass and Medford, plus some miscellany in Coos, Curry and Douglas Counties. Safe R

VAP: 88.1 W, 6.4 H

Greg Walden (R-Hood River) lives here, but like I said he may want to move to the 1st. This district makes a mockery of communities of interest, and it's also one of my favorite ones I've drawn in this whole series. It takes in the most Dem parts of Jackson and Josephine Counties (Ashland), Coos Bay and Bandon in Coos County, Dem-trending Bend and the solidly Dem Hood River and Wasco Counties. It passes through some very red territory to get there like Eugene's suburbs, but overall I'd call it Dem-leaning. Lean D

VAP: 85.5 W, 6.2 H

Pete DeFazio (D-Springfield) lives here. Eugene/Springfield and Corvallis, home to OSU. DeFazio, who has always been a little too liberal for his current district, is right at home here. Safe D

VAP: 85.2 W, 10.2 H

Open. The third Republican vote sink, with Albany, Woodburn and most of the Cascades. Safe R

VAP: 78.8 W, 13.8 H

Open. Salem, minus its suburbs, outer Corvallis and coastal Lincoln County. Safe D

VAP: 79.6 W, 12 H

Open. Clatsop, Columbia, Tillamook Counties, plus parts of Yamhill and Washington, including the city of Hillsboro. Swingier than the rest of the districts, but still Lean D


VAP: 75.3 W, 10.6 H, 9.7 A

Open; Suzanne Bonamici (D) lives in Portland, but her base in her current district is mostly Washington County, so she may run here instead. This district is entirely in the aforementioned Washington County, including Beaverton, Tigard and Tualatin. Safe D

VAP: 86.3 W, 5.9 H

Kurt Schrader (D-Canby) lives here. Clamackas County, plus part of Portland and one precinct in Washington County, for population equity's sake. This is the inner portion of Clamackas, very blue Portland suburbs, and Blue Dog Schrader is likely too conservative for it. He may choose to run in the Salem-based 6th instead. This district is Safe D regardless.

VAP: 78.6 W, 6.2 B, 6.3 H, 5.2 A

Open (?); Earl Blumenauer (D-Portland) could live in either the 10th of 11th, and could run in either of them easily. Eastern Multnomah County and the majority of the City of Portland. Safe D

VAP: 72.4 W, 11.5 H, 8.9 A

Open (?). Portland, Gresham and western Multnomah County. Safe D
Oregon goes from a 4-1 delegation on a 3-1-1 map to 8-3 under Doubling.

These 5 states add up to 32-22, bringing the whole House to 488-320-62, an impregnable Democratic majority.

I'll do one final diary wrapping up the series, but as for new maps, this is it! Thanks everyone for reading.


Can Democrats win AR-3 and KY-10?

33%7 votes
33%7 votes
9%2 votes
23%5 votes

| 21 votes | Vote | Results

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

  •  Tip Jar (2+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    dufffbeer, WisJohn

    24, Practical Progressive Democrat (-4.75, -4.51), DKE Gay Caucus Majority Leader, IN-02; Swingnut. Gregg/Simpson for Governor! Donnelly for Senate! Mullen for Congress!

    by HoosierD42 on Tue Oct 16, 2012 at 05:57:53 PM PDT

  •  you forgot KY-12! (2+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:
    WisJohn, HoosierD42

    And just a clarification, Eugene has no suburbs.  The small towns that are some miles out of it kind of function as bedroom communities, but they aren't deep red.  Aside from Creswell and Lowell, I think Obama won all of the rest of them, but many like Veneta, Cottage Grove, and Junction City tend to lean Republican to an extent.  The reddest parts of this OR-03 would probably be in eastern Douglas and northern Jackson counties.  They would be more than outweighed by southern Jackson county alone.  Obama got more than 80% of the vote in Ashland, and even the rural areas around it are deep blue.

    ...better the occasional faults of a government that lives in a spirit of charity, than the consistent omissions of a government frozen in the ice of its own indifference. -FDR, 1936

    by James Allen on Tue Oct 16, 2012 at 09:05:24 PM PDT

    •  Whoops! I'll add that soon. (0+ / 0-)

      And thanks for the clarification.

      24, Practical Progressive Democrat (-4.75, -4.51), DKE Gay Caucus Majority Leader, IN-02; Swingnut. Gregg/Simpson for Governor! Donnelly for Senate! Mullen for Congress!

      by HoosierD42 on Tue Oct 16, 2012 at 11:02:29 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

      •  also (1+ / 0-)
        Recommended by:

        I think DeFazio would be a shoe-in in your OR-03 even though he doesn't live there.  People in most of the southern portion are either already in his district or wish they were.  He's also not liberal enough for the Eugene-Corvallis district, which would probably be in the neighborhood of D+15.  Sara Gelser would be good there, or Paul Holvey, or Phil Barnhart, all liberal Democratic state reps from Corvallis or Eugene.

        In OR-02 I could see Bruce Hanna, the Republican Co-Speaker of the House.  Jason Atkinson could conceivably come out of retirement for it, too.

        In OR-05 I could see State Reps Vic Gilliam or Andy Olson, or State Senator Larry George.

        In OR-06 State Rep Brian Clem (D-Salem).

        In OR-07 State Rep Brad Witt.

        In OR-08 Suzanne Bonamici (whose base is in Beaverton).

        In OR-09 State Senator Richard Devlin.

        In OR-10 Earl Blumenauer.

        In OR-11 potentially Portland City Councilor Randy Leonard.

        ...better the occasional faults of a government that lives in a spirit of charity, than the consistent omissions of a government frozen in the ice of its own indifference. -FDR, 1936

        by James Allen on Wed Oct 17, 2012 at 08:56:18 AM PDT

        [ Parent ]

        •  What about Schrader? (0+ / 0-)

          Does he try and run in his home district?

          24, Practical Progressive Democrat (-4.75, -4.51), DKE Gay Caucus Majority Leader, IN-02; Swingnut. Gregg/Simpson for Governor! Donnelly for Senate! Mullen for Congress!

          by HoosierD42 on Wed Oct 17, 2012 at 02:51:25 PM PDT

          [ Parent ]

          •  you haven't given him a good district (1+ / 0-)
            Recommended by:

            the Salem one has none of his base (Clackamas County), so a strong candidate from Salem would probably beat him.  The Clack Co. suburbs one is too blue.  The rural one is too red.

            ...better the occasional faults of a government that lives in a spirit of charity, than the consistent omissions of a government frozen in the ice of its own indifference. -FDR, 1936

            by James Allen on Wed Oct 17, 2012 at 04:12:56 PM PDT

            [ Parent ]

            •  Hm, oh well (0+ / 0-)

              I shed no tears over losing a Blue Dog.

              24, Practical Progressive Democrat (-4.75, -4.51), DKE Gay Caucus Majority Leader, IN-02; Swingnut. Gregg/Simpson for Governor! Donnelly for Senate! Mullen for Congress!

              by HoosierD42 on Wed Oct 17, 2012 at 09:20:00 PM PDT

              [ Parent ]

              •  Also (2+ / 0-)
                Recommended by:
                James Allen, WisJohn

                I have spent my entire politically-conscious life thinking it was Clamackas County. And I'm only just now noticing that it's Clackamas

                24, Practical Progressive Democrat (-4.75, -4.51), DKE Gay Caucus Majority Leader, IN-02; Swingnut. Gregg/Simpson for Governor! Donnelly for Senate! Mullen for Congress!

                by HoosierD42 on Wed Oct 17, 2012 at 09:20:59 PM PDT

                [ Parent ]

  •  Aww. You mentioned me!! Thanks. (1+ / 0-)
    Recommended by:

    As with all of you other doubling diaries, I enjoyed this one. I do have some quibbles/suggestions/comments.

    AR-05, AR-06: I think you should do north-south districts, instead of east-west districts. I think it would improve Democratic chances if the Jonesboro district didn't have the areas around Mountain Home in them. From what I understand, this is what makes the real new AR-01 unwinnable.

    IA-05, IA-06, IA-07: I think there possibly (depends on the POP of the county) rearrange these three to make a D-leaning one with Ames and Marshalltown and Newton, along with those 4 counties that really don't look like they belong in the 5th into a district, and then make two other Republican-leaning districts out of the rest of the territory.

    KY-01, KY-3, KY-12: You forgot a write-up for 12! Obviously, it is what's left over after your KY-10 gerrymander. Love me that 3! :) Your 1 could maybe be won by the right Dem in the right year. MAYBE.

    MN: The state in this diary that I know the most about. I see that you were trying to find the limits here. Loved the series.

    I would cede one more district to the Repubs. That 2 would be pretty shaky in the wrong year. Every place in 2 besides the metro, and Faribalt and St. Peter is pretty red. Qwatonna is a city that leans R. All the rural area around Rochester is very red.

    I love that you give most of Wright County a Democratic Rep, as that would piss them off so much!

    Cravaaaaaak could run in your 13 if Bat Lady death-runs somewhere else, or is elected president (Baaaaahaaaahaaaa!). Also, I would take the southern-most county (Kanabec) in your 11 and move it into your 13, and put more of Pine County in to you 11th. Pine is more Dem.

    Also, I believe you are correct in saying that we would hold 12 when Collin retires. This is Farmer-Labor country, and there are some very strong local Dems that could win (Paul Marquardt, Kent Eken)

    I feel Democratic Saint Cloud is wasted in a exurban district, but looking around your map, I can't easily find a place where it could be of more use without destroying the basic structure of your map.

    Also, you made some name and location errors.  Inver Grove Heights/Cottage Grove is in your 2, not your 1. In your 9th, the city is New Brighton, not "New Bedford"

    You are very much correct that locals would find your divisions criminal!! That 15 especially ugly. :)

    OR: Love me that sneaky 3!!

    Overall: I can't wait untill more partisan data is loaded. Sorry for the super-long comment.

    Farm boy, 20, who hit the city to go to college, WI-03 (home, voting), WI-02 (college), -6.00, -3.54, I finally got a chance to do something my parents have done for years- vote against Tommy Thompson!!!! Tammy Baldwin for US Senate!!!!!

    by WisJohn on Tue Oct 16, 2012 at 09:10:05 PM PDT

    •  No problem, thanks for being so thorough! (0+ / 0-)

      I'll try and remember to fix those Minnesota naming errors when I jump back in to write up KY-12 (Safe R, btw).

      24, Practical Progressive Democrat (-4.75, -4.51), DKE Gay Caucus Majority Leader, IN-02; Swingnut. Gregg/Simpson for Governor! Donnelly for Senate! Mullen for Congress!

      by HoosierD42 on Tue Oct 16, 2012 at 11:09:30 PM PDT

      [ Parent ]

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site